CHAPTER I. THE MILLIONAIRE'S DAUGHTER
CHAPTER II. THE COMING OF THE CHAROLAIS
CHAPTER III. LUPIN'S WAY
CHAPTER IV. THE DUKE INTERVENES
CHAPTER V. A LETTER FROM LUPIN
CHAPTER VI. AGAIN THE CHAROLAIS
CHAPTER VII. THE THEFT OF THE MOTOR-CABS
CHAPTER VIII. THE DUKE ARRIVES
CHAPTER IX. M. FORMERY OPENS THE INQUIRY
CHAPTER X. GUERCHARD ASSISTS
CHAPTER XI. THE FAMILY ARRIVES
CHAPTER XII. THE THEFT OF THE PENDANT
CHAPTER XIII. LUPIN WIRES
CHAPTER XIV. GUERCHARD PICKS UP THE TRUE SCENT
CHAPTER XV. THE EXAMINATION OF SONIA
CHAPTER XVI. VICTOIRE'S SLIP
CHAPTER XVII. SONIA'S ESCAPE
CHAPTER XVIII. THE DUKE STAYS
CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE GOES
CHAPTER XX. LUPIN COMES HOME
CHAPTER XXI. THE CUTTING OF THE TELEPHONE WIRES
CHAPTER XXII. THE BARGAIN
CHAPTER XXIII. THE END OF THE DUEL
The rays of the September sun flooded the great halls of the old
chateau of the Dukes of Charmerace, lighting up with their mellow
glow the spoils of so many ages and many lands, jumbled together with
the execrable taste which so often afflicts those whose only standard
of value is money. The golden light warmed the panelled walls and old
furniture to a dull lustre, and gave back to he fading gilt of the
First Empire chairs and couches something of its old brightness. It
illumined the long line of pictures on the walls, pictures of dead and
gone Charmeraces, the stern or debonair faces of the men, soldiers,
statesmen, dandies, the gentle or imperious faces of beautiful women.
It flashed back from armour of brightly polished steel, and drew dull
gleams from armour of bronze. The hues of rare porcelain, of the rich
inlays of Oriental or Renaissance cabinets, mingled with the hues of the
pictures, the tapestry, the Persian rugs about the polished floor to
fill the hall with a rich glow of colour.
But of all the beautiful and precious things which the sun-rays
warmed to a clearer beauty, the face of the girl who sat writing at a
table in front of the long windows, which opened on to the
centuries-old turf of the broad terrace, was the most beautiful and
the most precious.
It was a delicate, almost frail, beauty. Her skin was clear with
the transparent lustre of old porcelain, and her pale cheeks were only
tinted with the pink of the faintest roses. Her straight nose was
delicately cut, her rounded chin admirably moulded. A lover of beauty
would have been at a loss whether more to admire her clear, germander
eyes, so melting and so adorable, or the sensitive mouth, with its
rather full lips, inviting all the kisses. But assuredly he would have
been grieved by the perpetual air of sadness which rested on the
beautiful face—the wistful melancholy of the Slav, deepened by
something of personal misfortune and suffering.
Her face was framed by a mass of soft fair hair, shot with strands
of gold where the sunlight fell on it; and little curls, rebellious
to the comb, strayed over her white forehead, tiny feathers of gold.
She was addressing envelopes, and a long list of names lay on her
left hand. When she had addressed an envelope, she slipped into it a
wedding-card. On each was printed:
"M. Gournay-Martin has the honour to inform
you of the marriage of his daughter
Germaine to the Duke of Charmerace."
She wrote steadily on, adding envelope after envelope to the pile
ready for the post, which rose in front of her. But now and again,
when the flushed and laughing girls who were playing lawn-tennis on
the terrace, raised their voices higher than usual as they called the
score, and distracted her attention from her work, her gaze strayed
through the open window and lingered on them wistfully; and as her
eyes came back to her task she sighed with so faint a wistfulness that
she hardly knew she sighed. Then a voice from the terrace cried,
"Yes. Mlle. Germaine?" answered the writing girl.
"Tea! Order tea, will you?" cried the voice, a petulant voice,
rather harsh to the ear.
"Very well, Mlle. Germaine," said Sonia; and having finished
addressing the envelope under her pen, she laid it on the pile ready
to be posted, and, crossing the room to the old, wide fireplace, she
rang the bell.
She stood by the fireplace a moment, restoring to its place a rose
which had fallen from a vase on the mantelpiece; and her attitude, as
with arms upraised she arranged the flowers, displayed the delightful
line of a slender figure. As she let fall her arms to her side, a
footman entered the room.
"Will you please bring the tea, Alfred," she said in a charming
voice of that pure, bell-like tone which has been Nature's most
precious gift to but a few of the greatest actresses.
"For how many, miss?" said Alfred.
"For four—unless your master has come back."
"Oh, no; he's not back yet, miss. He went in the car to Rennes to
lunch; and it's a good many miles away. He won't be back for another
"And the Duke—he's not back from his ride yet, is he?"
"Not yet, miss," said Alfred, turning to go.
"One moment," said Sonia. "Have all of you got your things packed
for the journey to Paris? You will have to start soon, you know. Are
all the maids ready?"
"Well, all the men are ready, I know, miss. But about the maids,
miss, I can't say. They've been bustling about all day; but it takes
them longer than it does us."
"Tell them to hurry up; and be as quick as you can with the tea,
please," said Sonia.
Alfred went out of the room; Sonia went back to the writing-table.
She did not take up her pen; she took up one of the wedding-cards;
and her lips moved slowly as she read it in a pondering depression.
The petulant, imperious voice broke in upon her musing.
"Whatever are you doing, Sonia? Aren't you getting on with those
letters?" it cried angrily; and Germaine Gournay-Martin came through
the long window into the hall.
The heiress to the Gournay-Martin millions carried her tennis
racquet in her hand; and her rosy cheeks were flushed redder than
ever by the game. She was a pretty girl in a striking, high-
coloured, rather obvious way—the very foil to Sonia's delicate
beauty. Her lips were a little too thin, her eyes too shallow; and
together they gave her a rather hard air, in strongest contrast to
the gentle, sympathetic face of Sonia.
The two friends with whom Germaine had been playing tennis followed
her into the hall: Jeanne Gautier, tall, sallow, dark, with a
somewhat malicious air; Marie Bullier, short, round, commonplace, and
They came to the table at which Sonia was at work; and pointing to
the pile of envelopes, Marie said, "Are these all wedding-cards?"
"Yes; and we've only got to the letter V," said Germaine, frowning
"Princesse de Vernan—Duchesse de Vauvieuse—Marquess—Marchioness?
You've invited the whole Faubourg Saint-Germain," said Marie,
shuffling the pile of envelopes with an envious air.
"You'll know very few people at your wedding," said Jeanne, with a
spiteful little giggle.
"I beg your pardon, my dear," said Germaine boastfully. "Madame de
Relzieres, my fiance's cousin, gave an At Home the other day in my
honour. At it she introduced half Paris to me—the Paris I'm destined
to know, the Paris you'll see in my drawing-rooms."
"But we shall no longer be fit friends for you when you're the
Duchess of Charmerace," said Jeanne.
"Why?" said Germaine; and then she added quickly, "Above
everything, Sonia, don't forget Veauleglise, 33, University
Street—33, University Street."
"Veauleglise—33, University Street," said Sonia, taking a fresh
envelope, and beginning to address it.
"Wait—wait! don't close the envelope. I'm wondering whether
Veauleglise ought to have a cross, a double cross, or a triple
cross," said Germaine, with an air of extreme importance.
"What's that?" cried Marie and Jeanne together.
"A single cross means an invitation to the church, a double cross
an invitation to the marriage and the wedding-breakfast, and the
triple cross means an invitation to the marriage, the breakfast, and
the signing of the marriage-contract. What do you think the Duchess of
Veauleglise ought to have?"
"Don't ask me. I haven't the honour of knowing that great lady,"
"Nor I," said Marie.
"Nor I," said Germaine. "But I have here the visiting-list of the
late Duchess of Charmerace, Jacques' mother. The two duchesses were
on excellent terms. Besides the Duchess of Veauleglise is rather
worn-out, but greatly admired for her piety. She goes to early
service three times a week."
"Then put three crosses," said Jeanne.
"I shouldn't," said Marie quickly. "In your place, my dear, I
shouldn't risk a slip. I should ask my fiance's advice. He knows this
"Oh, goodness—my fiance! He doesn't care a rap about this kind of
thing. He has changed so in the last seven years. Seven years ago he
took nothing seriously. Why, he set off on an expedition to the South
Pole—just to show off. Oh, in those days he was truly a duke."
"And to-day?" said Jeanne.
"Oh, to-day he's a regular slow-coach. Society gets on his nerves.
He's as sober as a judge," said Germaine.
"He's as gay as a lark," said Sonia, in sudden protest.
Germaine pouted at her, and said: "Oh, he's gay enough when he's
making fun of people. But apart from that he's as sober as a judge."
"Your father must be delighted with the change," said Jeanne.
"Naturally he's delighted. Why, he's lunching at Rennes to-day with
the Minister, with the sole object of getting Jacques decorated."
"Well; the Legion of Honour is a fine thing to have," said Marie.
"My dear! The Legion of Honour is all very well for middle-class
people, but it's quite out of place for a duke!" cried Germaine.
Alfred came in, bearing the tea-tray, and set it on a little table
near that at which Sonia was sitting.
Germaine, who was feeling too important to sit still, was walking
up and down the room. Suddenly she stopped short, and pointing to a
silver statuette which stood on the piano, she said, "What's this?
Why is this statuette here?"
"Why, when we came in, it was on the cabinet, in its usual place,"
said Sonia in some astonishment.
"Did you come into the hall while we were out in the garden,
Alfred?" said Germaine to the footman.
"No, miss," said Alfred.
"But some one must have come into it," Germaine persisted.
"I've not heard any one. I was in my pantry," said Alfred.
"It's very odd," said Germaine.
"It is odd," said Sonia. "Statuettes don't move about of
All of them stared at the statuette as if they expected it to move
again forthwith, under their very eyes. Then Alfred put it back in
its usual place on one of the cabinets, and went out of the room.
Sonia poured out the tea; and over it they babbled about the coming
marriage, the frocks they would wear at it, and the presents Germaine
had already received. That reminded her to ask Sonia if any one had
yet telephoned from her father's house in Paris; and Sonia said that
no one had.
"That's very annoying," said Germaine. "It shows that nobody has
sent me a present to-day."
Pouting, she shrugged her shoulders with an air of a spoiled child,
which sat but poorly on a well-developed young woman of twenty-
"It's Sunday. The shops don't deliver things on Sunday," said Sonia
But Germaine still pouted like a spoiled child.
"Isn't your beautiful Duke coming to have tea with us?" said Jeanne
a little anxiously.
"Oh, yes; I'm expecting him at half-past four. He had to go for a
ride with the two Du Buits. They're coming to tea here, too," said
"Gone for a ride with the two Du Buits? But when?" cried Marie
"He can't be," said Marie. "My brother went to the Du Buits' house
after lunch, to see Andre and Georges. They went for a drive this
morning, and won't be back till late to-night."
"Well, but—but why did the Duke tell me so?" said Germaine,
knitting her brow with a puzzled air.
"If I were you, I should inquire into this thoroughly. Dukes—well,
we know what dukes are—it will be just as well to keep an eye on
him," said Jeanne maliciously.
Germaine flushed quickly; and her eyes flashed. "Thank you. I have
every confidence in Jacques. I am absolutely sure of him," she said
"Oh, well—if you're sure, it's all right," said Jeanne.
The ringing of the telephone-bell made a fortunate diversion.
Germaine rushed to it, clapped the receiver to her ear, and cried:
"Hello, is that you, Pierre? . . . Oh, it's Victoire, is it? . . .
Ah, some presents have come, have they? . . . Well, well, what are
they? . . . What! a paper-knife—another paper-knife! . . . Another
Louis XVI. inkstand—oh, bother! . . . Who are they from? . . . Oh,
from the Countess Rudolph and the Baron de Valery." Her voice rose
high, thrilling with pride.
Then she turned her face to her friends, with the receiver still at
her ear, and cried: "Oh, girls, a pearl necklace too! A large one!
The pearls are big ones!"
"How jolly!" said Marie.
"Who sent it?" said Germaine, turning to the telephone again. "Oh,
a friend of papa's," she added in a tone of disappointment. "Never
mind, after all it's a pearl necklace. You'll be sure and lock the
doors carefully, Victoire, won't you? And lock up the necklace in the
secret cupboard. . . . Yes; thanks very much, Victoire. I shall see
She hung up the receiver, and came away from the telephone
"It's preposterous!" she said pettishly. "Papa's friends and
relations give me marvellous presents, and all the swells send me
paper-knives. It's all Jacques' fault. He's above all this kind of
thing. The Faubourg Saint-Germain hardly knows that we're engaged."
"He doesn't go about advertising it," said Jeanne, smiling.
"You're joking, but all the same what you say is true," said
Germaine. "That's exactly what his cousin Madame de Relzieres said to
me the other day at the At Home she gave in my honour—wasn't it,
Sonia?" And she walked to the window, and, turning her back on them,
stared out of it.
"She HAS got her mouth full of that At Home," said Jeanne to Marie
in a low voice.
There was an awkward silence. Marie broke it:
"Speaking of Madame de Relzieres, do you know that she is on pins
and needles with anxiety? Her son is fighting a duel to-day," she
"With whom?" said Sonia.
"No one knows. She got hold of a letter from the seconds," said
"My mind is quite at rest about Relzieres," said Germaine. "He's a
first-class swordsman. No one could beat him."
Sonia did not seem to share her freedom from anxiety. Her forehead
was puckered in little lines of perplexity, as if she were puzzling
out some problem; and there was a look of something very like fear in
her gentle eyes.
"Wasn't Relzieres a great friend of your fiance at one time?" said
"A great friend? I should think he was," said Germaine. "Why, it
was through Relzieres that we got to know Jacques."
"Where was that?" said Marie.
"Here—in this very chateau," said Germaine.
"Actually in his own house?" said Marie, in some surprise.
"Yes; actually here. Isn't life funny?" said Germaine. "If, a few
months after his father's death, Jacques had not found himself hard-
up, and obliged to dispose of this chateau, to raise the money for
his expedition to the South Pole; and if papa and I had not wanted an
historic chateau; and lastly, if papa had not suffered from
rheumatism, I should not be calling myself in a month from now the
Duchess of Charmerace."
"Now what on earth has your father's rheumatism got to do with your
being Duchess of Charmerace?" cried Jeanne.
"Everything," said Germaine. "Papa was afraid that this chateau was
damp. To prove to papa that he had nothing to fear, Jacques, en grand
seigneur, offered him his hospitality, here, at Charmerace, for three
"That was truly ducal," said Marie.
"But he is always like that," said Sonia.
"Oh, he's all right in that way, little as he cares about society,"
said Germaine. "Well, by a miracle my father got cured of his
rheumatism here. Jacques fell in love with me; papa made up his mind
to buy the chateau; and I demanded the hand of Jacques in marriage."
"You did? But you were only sixteen then," said Marie, with some
"Yes; but even at sixteen a girl ought to know that a duke is a
duke. I did," said Germaine. "Then since Jacques was setting out for
the South Pole, and papa considered me much too young to get married,
I promised Jacques to wait for his return."
"Why, it was everything that's romantic!" cried Marie.
"Romantic? Oh, yes," said Germaine; and she pouted. "But between
ourselves, if I'd known that he was going to stay all that time at
the South Pole—"
"That's true," broke in Marie. "To go away for three years and stay
away seven—at the end of the world."
"All Germaine's beautiful youth," said Jeanne, with her malicious
"Thanks!" said Germaine tartly.
"Well, you ARE twenty-three. It's the flower of one's age," said
"Not quite twenty-three," said Germaine hastily. "And look at the
wretched luck I've had. The Duke falls ill and is treated at
Montevideo. As soon as he recovers, since he's the most obstinate
person in the world, he resolves to go on with the expedition. He
sets out; and for an age, without a word of warning, there's no more
news of him—no news of any kind. For six months, you know, we
believed him dead."
"Dead? Oh, how unhappy you must have been!" said Sonia.
"Oh, don't speak of it! For six months I daren't put on a light
frock," said Germaine, turning to her.
"A lot she must have cared for him," whispered Jeanne to Marie.
"Fortunately, one fine day, the letters began again. Three months
ago a telegram informed us that he was coming back; and at last the
Duke returned," said Germaine, with a theatrical air.
"The Duke returned," cried Jeanne, mimicking her.
"Never mind. Fancy waiting nearly seven years for one's fiance.
That was constancy," said Sonia.
"Oh, you're a sentimentalist, Mlle. Kritchnoff," said Jeanne, in a
tone of mockery. "It was the influence of the castle."
"What do you mean?" said Germaine.
"Oh, to own the castle of Charmerace and call oneself Mlle.
Gournay- Martin—it's not worth doing. One MUST become a duchess,"
"Yes, yes; and for all this wonderful constancy, seven years of it,
Germaine was on the point of becoming engaged to another man," said
"And he a mere baron," said Jeanne, laughing.
"What? Is that true?" said Sonia.
"Didn't you know, Mlle. Kritchnoff? She nearly became engaged to
the Duke's cousin, the Baron de Relzieres. It was not nearly so
"Oh, it's all very well to laugh at me; but being the cousin and
heir of the Duke, Relzieres would have assumed the title, and I
should have been Duchess just the same," said Germaine triumphantly.
"Evidently that was all that mattered," said Jeanne. "Well, dear, I
must be off. We've promised to run in to see the Comtesse de
Grosjean. You know the Comtesse de Grosjean?"
She spoke with an air of careless pride, and rose to go.
"Only by name. Papa used to know her husband on the Stock Exchange
when he was still called simply M. Grosjean. For his part, papa
preferred to keep his name intact," said Germaine, with quiet pride.
"Intact? That's one way of looking at it. Well, then, I'll see you
in Paris. You still intend to start to-morrow?" said Jeanne.
"Yes; to-morrow morning," said Germaine.
Jeanne and Marie slipped on their dust-coats to the accompaniment
of chattering and kissing, and went out of the room.
As she closed the door on them, Germaine turned to Sonia, and said:
"I do hate those two girls! They're such horrible snobs."
"Oh, they're good-natured enough," said Sonia.
"Good-natured? Why, you idiot, they're just bursting with envy of
me—bursting!" said Germaine. "Well, they've every reason to be," she
added confidently, surveying herself in a Venetian mirror with a
petted child's self-content.
Sonia went back to her table, and once more began putting wedding-
cards in their envelopes and addressing them. Germaine moved
restlessly about the room, fidgeting with the bric-a-brac on the
cabinets, shifting the pieces about, interrupting Sonia to ask
whether she preferred this arrangement or that, throwing herself into
a chair to read a magazine, getting up in a couple of minutes to
straighten a picture on the wall, throwing out all the while idle
questions not worth answering. Ninety-nine human beings would have
been irritated to exasperation by her fidgeting; Sonia endured it
with a perfect patience. Five times Germaine asked her whether she
should wear her heliotrope or her pink gown at a forthcoming dinner
at Madame de Relzieres'. Five times Sonia said, without the slightest
variation in her tone, "I think you look better in the pink." And all
the while the pile of addressed envelopes rose steadily.
Presently the door opened, and Alfred stood on the threshold.
"Two gentlemen have called to see you, miss," he said.
"Ah, the two Du Buits," cried Germaine.
"They didn't give their names, miss."
"A gentleman in the prime of life and a younger one?" said
"I thought so. Show them in."
"Yes, miss. And have you any orders for me to give Victoire when we
get to Paris?" said Alfred.
"No. Are you starting soon?"
"Yes, miss. We're all going by the seven o'clock train. It's a long
way from here to Paris; we shall only reach it at nine in the
morning. That will give us just time to get the house ready for you
by the time you get there to-morrow evening," said Alfred.
"Is everything packed?"
"Yes, miss—everything. The cart has already taken the heavy
luggage to the station. All you'll have to do is to see after your
"That's all right. Show M. du Buit and his brother in," said
She moved to a chair near the window, and disposed herself in an
attitude of studied, and obviously studied, grace.
As she leant her head at a charming angle back against the tall
back of the chair, her eyes fell on the window, and they opened wide.
"Why, whatever's this?" she cried, pointing to it.
"Whatever's what?" said Sonia, without raising her eyes from the
envelope she was addressing.
"Why, the window. Look! one of the panes has been taken out. It
looks as if it had been cut."
"So it has—just at the level of the fastening," said Sonia. And
the two girls stared at the gap.
"Haven't you noticed it before?" said Germaine.
"No; the broken glass must have fallen outside," said Sonia.
The noise of the opening of the door drew their attention from the
window. Two figures were advancing towards them—a short, round,
tubby man of fifty-five, red-faced, bald, with bright grey eyes,
which seemed to be continually dancing away from meeting the eyes of
any other human being. Behind him came a slim young man, dark and
grave. For all the difference in their colouring, it was clear that
they were father and son: their eyes were set so close together. The
son seemed to have inherited, along with her black eyes, his mother's
nose, thin and aquiline; the nose of the father started thin from the
brow, but ended in a scarlet bulb eloquent of an exhaustive
acquaintance with the vintages of the world.
Germaine rose, looking at them with an air of some surprise and
uncertainty: these were not her friends, the Du Buits.
The elder man, advancing with a smiling bonhomie, bowed, and said
in an adenoid voice, ingratiating of tone: "I'm M. Charolais, young
ladies—M. Charolais—retired brewer—chevalier of the Legion of
Honour—landowner at Rennes. Let me introduce my son." The young man
bowed awkwardly. "We came from Rennes this morning, and we lunched at
"Shall I order tea for them?" whispered Sonia.
"Gracious, no!" said Germaine sharply under her breath; then,
louder, she said to M. Charolais, "And what is your object in
"We asked to see your father," said M. Charolais, smiling with
broad amiability, while his eyes danced across her face, avoiding any
meeting with hers. "The footman told us that M. Gournay-Martin was
out, but that his daughter was at home. And we were unable, quite
unable, to deny ourselves the pleasure of meeting you." With that he
sat down; and his son followed his example.
Sonia and Germaine, taken aback, looked at one another in some
"What a fine chateau, papa!" said the young man.
"Yes, my boy; it's a very fine chateau," said M. Charolais, looking
round the hall with appreciative but greedy eyes.
There was a pause.
"It's a very fine chateau, young ladies," said M. Charolais.
"Yes; but excuse me, what is it you have called about?" said
M. Charolais crossed his legs, leant back in his chair, thrust his
thumbs into the arm-holes of his waistcoat, and said: "Well, we've
come about the advertisement we saw in the RENNES ADVERTISER, that M.
Gournay-Martin wanted to get rid of a motor-car; and my son is always
saying to me, 'I should like a motor-car which rushes the hills,
papa.' He means a sixty horse-power."
"We've got a sixty horse-power; but it's not for sale. My father is
even using it himself to-day," said Germaine.
"Perhaps it's the car we saw in the stable-yard," said M.
"No; that's a thirty to forty horse-power. It belongs to me. But if
your son really loves rushing hills, as you say, we have a hundred
horse-power car which my father wants to get rid of. Wait; where's
the photograph of it, Sonia? It ought to be here somewhere."
The two girls rose, went to a table set against the wall beyond the
window, and began turning over the papers with which it was loaded in
the search for the photograph. They had barely turned their backs,
when the hand of young Charolais shot out as swiftly as the tongue of
a lizard catching a fly, closed round the silver statuette on the top
of the cabinet beside him, and flashed it into his jacket pocket.
Charolais was watching the two girls; one would have said that he
had eyes for nothing else, yet, without moving a muscle of his face,
set in its perpetual beaming smile, he hissed in an angry whisper,
"Drop it, you idiot! Put it back!"
The young man scowled askance at him.
"Curse you! Put it back!" hissed Charolais.
The young man's arm shot out with the same quickness, and the
statuette stood in its place.
There was just the faintest sigh of relief from Charolais, as
Germaine turned and came to him with the photograph in her hand. She
gave it to him.
"Ah, here we are," he said, putting on a pair of gold-rimmed pince-
nez. "A hundred horse-power car. Well, well, this is something to
talk over. What's the least you'll take for it?"
"_I_ have nothing to do with this kind of thing," cried Germaine.
"You must see my father. He will be back from Rennes soon. Then you
can settle the matter with him."
M. Charolais rose, and said: "Very good. We will go now, and come
back presently. I'm sorry to have intruded on you, young ladies—
taking up your time like this—"
"Not at all—not at all," murmured Germaine politely.
"Good-bye—good-bye," said M. Charolais; and he and his son went to
the door, and bowed themselves out.
"What creatures!" said Germaine, going to the window, as the door
closed behind the two visitors. "All the same, if they do buy the
hundred horse-power, papa will be awfully pleased. It is odd about
that pane. I wonder how it happened. It's odd too that Jacques hasn't
come back yet. He told me that he would be here between half- past
four and five."
"And the Du Buits have not come either," said Sonia. "But it's
hardly five yet."
"Yes; that's so. The Du Buits have not come either. What on earth
are you wasting your time for?" she added sharply, raising her voice.
"Just finish addressing those letters while you're waiting."
"They're nearly finished," said Sonia.
"Nearly isn't quite. Get on with them, can't you!" snapped
Sonia went back to the writing-table; just the slightest deepening
of the faint pink roses in her cheeks marked her sense of Germaine's
rudeness. After three years as companion to Germaine Gournay-Martin,
she was well inured to millionaire manners; they had almost lost the
power to move her.
Germaine dropped into a chair for twenty seconds; then flung out of
"Ten minutes to five!" she cried. "Jacques is late. It's the first
time I've ever known him late."
She went to the window, and looked across the wide stretch of
meadow-land and woodland on which the chateau, set on the very crown
of the ridge, looked down. The road, running with the irritating
straightness of so many of the roads of France, was visible for a
full three miles. It was empty.
"Perhaps the Duke went to the Chateau de Relzieres to see his
cousin—though I fancy that at bottom the Duke does not care very
much for the Baron de Relzieres. They always look as though they
detested one another," said Sonia, without raising her eyes from the
letter she was addressing.
"You've noticed that, have you?" said Germaine. "Now, as far as
Jacques is concerned—he's—he's so indifferent. None the less, when
we were at the Relzieres on Thursday, I caught him quarrelling with
Paul de Relzieres."
"Quarrelling?" said Sonia sharply, with a sudden uneasiness in air
and eyes and voice.
"Yes; quarrelling. And they said good-bye to one another in the
"But surely they shook hands?" said Sonia.
"Not a bit of it. They bowed as if each of them had swallowed a
"Why—then—then—" said Sonia, starting up with a frightened air;
and her voice stuck in her throat.
"Then what?" said Germaine, a little startled by her panic-stricken
"The duel! Monsieur de Relzieres' duel!" cried Sonia.
"What? You don't think it was with Jacques?"
"I don't know—but this quarrel—the Duke's manner this
morning—the Du Buits' drive—" said Sonia.
"Of course—of course! It's quite possible—in fact it's certain!"
"It's horrible!" gasped Sonia. "Consider—just consider! Suppose
something happened to him. Suppose the Duke—"
"It's me the Duke's fighting about!" cried Germaine proudly, with a
little skipping jump of triumphant joy.
Sonia stared through her without seeing her. Her face was a dead
white—fear had chilled the lustre from her skin; her breath panted
through her parted lips; and her dilated eyes seemed to look on some
Germaine pirouetted about the hall at the very height of triumph.
To have a Duke fighting a duel about her was far beyond the wildest
dreams of snobbishness. She chuckled again and again, and once she
clapped her hands and laughed aloud.
"He's fighting a swordsman of the first class—an invincible
swordsman—you said so yourself," Sonia muttered in a tone of
anguish. "And there's nothing to be done—nothing."
She pressed her hands to her eyes as if to shut out a hideous
Germaine did not hear her; she was staring at herself in a mirror,
and bridling to her own image.
Sonia tottered to the window and stared down at the road along
which must come the tidings of weal or irremediable woe. She kept
passing her hand over her eyes as if to clear their vision.
Suddenly she started, and bent forward, rigid, all her being
concentrated in the effort to see.
Then she cried: "Mademoiselle Germaine! Look! Look!"
"What is it?" said Germaine, coming to her side.
"A horseman! Look! There!" said Sonia, waving a hand towards the
"Yes; and isn't he galloping!" said Germaine.
"It's he! It's the Duke!" cried Sonia.
"Do you think so?" said Germaine doubtfully.
"I'm sure of it—sure!"
"Well, he gets here just in time for tea," said Germaine in a tone
of extreme satisfaction. "He knows that I hate to be kept waiting. He
said to me, 'I shall be back by five at the latest.' And here he is."
"It's impossible," said Sonia. "He has to go all the way round the
park. There's no direct road; the brook is between us."
"All the same, he's coming in a straight line," said Germaine.
It was true. The horseman had left the road and was galloping
across the meadows straight for the brook. In twenty seconds he
reached its treacherous bank, and as he set his horse at it, Sonia
covered her eyes.
"He's over!" said Germaine. "My father gave three hundred guineas
for that horse."
Sonia, in a sudden revulsion of feeling, in a reaction from her
fears, slipped back and sat down at the tea-table, panting quickly,
struggling to keep back the tears of relief. She did not see the Duke
gallop up the slope, dismount, and hand over his horse to the groom
who came running to him. There was still a mist in her eyes to blur
his figure as he came through the window.
"If it's for me, plenty of tea, very little cream, and three lumps
of sugar," he cried in a gay, ringing voice, and pulled out his
watch. "Five to the minute—that's all right." And he bent down, took
Germaine's hand, and kissed it with an air of gallant devotion.
If he had indeed just fought a duel, there were no signs of it in
his bearing. His air, his voice, were entirely careless. He was a man
whose whole thought at the moment was fixed on his tea and his
He drew a chair near the tea-table for Germaine; sat down himself;
and Sonia handed him a cup of tea with so shaky a hand that the spoon
clinked in the saucer.
"You've been fighting a duel?" said Germaine.
"What! You've heard already?" said the Duke in some surprise.
"I've heard," said Germaine. "Why did you fight it?"
"You're not wounded, your Grace?" said Sonia anxiously.
"Not a scratch," said the Duke, smiling at her.
"Will you be so good as to get on with those wedding-cards, Sonia,"
said Germaine sharply; and Sonia went back to the writing-table.
Turning to the Duke, Germaine said, "Did you fight on my account?"
"Would you be pleased to know that I had fought on your account?"
said the Duke; and there was a faint mocking light in his eyes, far
too faint for the self-satisfied Germaine to perceive.
"Yes. But it isn't true. You've been fighting about some woman,"
said Germaine petulantly.
"If I had been fighting about a woman, it could only be you," said
"Yes, that is so. Of course. It could hardly be about Sonia, or my
maid," said Germaine. "But what was the reason of the duel?"
"Oh, the reason of it was entirely childish," said the Duke. "I was
in a bad temper; and De Relzieres said something that annoyed me."
"Then it wasn't about me; and if it wasn't about me, it wasn't
really worth while fighting," said Germaine in a tone of acute
The mocking light deepened a little in the Duke's eyes.
"Yes. But if I had been killed, everybody would have said, 'The
Duke of Charmerace has been killed in a duel about Mademoiselle
Gournay- Martin.' That would have sounded very fine indeed," said the
Duke; and a touch of mockery had crept into his voice.
"Now, don't begin trying to annoy me again," said Germaine
"The last thing I should dream of, my dear girl," said the Duke,
"And De Relzieres? Is he wounded?" said Germaine.
"Poor dear De Relzieres: he won't be out of bed for the next six
months," said the Duke; and he laughed lightly and gaily.
"Good gracious!" cried Germaine.
"It will do poor dear De Relzieres a world of good. He has a touch
of enteritis; and for enteritis there is nothing like rest," said the
Sonia was not getting on very quickly with the wedding-cards.
Germaine was sitting with her back to her; and over her shoulder
Sonia could watch the face of the Duke—an extraordinarily mobile
face, changing with every passing mood. Sometimes his eyes met hers;
and hers fell before them. But as soon as they turned away from her
she was watching him again, almost greedily, as if she could not see
enough of his face in which strength of will and purpose was mingled
with a faint, ironic scepticism, and tempered by a fine air of race.
He finished his tea; then he took a morocco case from his pocket,
and said to Germaine, "It must be quite three days since I gave you
He opened the case, disclosed a pearl pendant, and handed it to
"Oh, how nice!" she cried, taking it.
She took it from the case, saying that it was a beauty. She showed
it to Sonia; then she put it on and stood before a mirror admiring
the effect. To tell the truth, the effect was not entirely desirable.
The pearls did not improve the look of her rather coarse brown skin;
and her skin added nothing to the beauty of the pearls. Sonia saw
this, and so did the Duke. He looked at Sonia's white throat. She met
his eyes and blushed. She knew that the same thought was in both their
minds; the pearls would have looked infinitely better there.
Germaine finished admiring herself; she was incapable even of
suspecting that so expensive a pendant could not suit her perfectly.
The Duke said idly: "Goodness! Are all those invitations to the
"That's only down to the letter V," said Germaine proudly.
"And there are twenty-five letters in the alphabet! You must be
inviting the whole world. You'll have to have the Madeleine enlarged.
It won't hold them all. There isn't a church in Paris that will," said
"Won't it be a splendid marriage!" said Germaine. "There'll be
something like a crush. There are sure to be accidents."
"If I were you, I should have careful arrangements made," said the
"Oh, let people look after themselves. They'll remember it better
if they're crushed a little," said Germaine.
There was a flicker of contemptuous wonder in the Duke's eyes. But
he only shrugged his shoulders, and turning to Sonia, said, "Will you
be an angel and play me a little Grieg, Mademoiselle Kritchnoff? I
heard you playing yesterday. No one plays Grieg like you."
"Excuse me, Jacques, but Mademoiselle Kritchnoff has her work to
do," said Germaine tartly.
"Five minutes' interval—just a morsel of Grieg, I beg," said the
Duke, with an irresistible smile.
"All right," said Germaine grudgingly. "But I've something
important to talk to you about."
"By Jove! So have I. I was forgetting. I've the last photograph I
took of you and Mademoiselle Sonia." Germaine frowned and shrugged
her shoulders. "With your light frocks in the open air, you look like
two big flowers," said the Duke.
"You call that important!" cried Germaine.
"It's very important—like all trifles," said the Duke, smiling.
"Look! isn't it nice?" And he took a photograph from his pocket, and
held it out to her.
"Nice? It's shocking! We're making the most appalling faces," said
Germaine, looking at the photograph in his hand.
"Well, perhaps you ARE making faces," said the Duke seriously,
considering the photograph with grave earnestness. "But they're not
appalling faces—not by any means. You shall be judge, Mademoiselle
Sonia. The faces—well, we won't talk about the faces—but the
outlines. Look at the movement of your scarf." And he handed the
photograph to Sonia.
"Jacques!" said Germaine impatiently.
"Oh, yes, you've something important to tell me. What is it?" said
the Duke, with an air of resignation; and he took the photograph from
Sonia and put it carefully back in his pocket.
"Victoire has telephoned from Paris to say that we've had a paper-
knife and a Louis Seize inkstand given us," said Germaine.
"Hurrah!" cried the Duke in a sudden shout that made them both
"And a pearl necklace," said Germaine.
"Hurrah!" cried the Duke.
"You're perfectly childish," said Germaine pettishly. "I tell you
we've been given a paper-knife, and you shout 'hurrah!' I say we've
been given a pearl necklace, and you shout 'hurrah!' You can't have
the slightest sense of values."
"I beg your pardon. This pearl necklace is from one of your
father's friends, isn't it?" said the Duke.
"Yes; why?" said Germaine.
"But the inkstand and the paper-knife must be from the Faubourg
Saint-Germain, and well on the shabby side?" said the Duke.
"Well then, my dear girl, what are you complaining about? They
balance; the equilibrium is restored. You can't have everything,"
said the Duke; and he laughed mischievously.
Germaine flushed, and bit her lip; her eyes sparkled.
"You don't care a rap about me," she said stormily.
"But I find you adorable," said the Duke.
"You keep annoying me," said Germaine pettishly. "And you do it on
purpose. I think it's in very bad taste. I shall end by taking a
dislike to you—I know I shall."
"Wait till we're married for that, my dear girl," said the Duke;
and he laughed again, with a blithe, boyish cheerfulness, which
deepened the angry flush in Germaine's cheeks.
"Can't you be serious about anything?" she cried.
"I am the most serious man in Europe," said the Duke.
Germaine went to the window and stared out of it sulkily.
The Duke walked up and down the hall, looking at the pictures of
some of his ancestors—somewhat grotesque persons—with humorous
appreciation. Between addressing the envelopes Sonia kept glancing at
him. Once he caught her eye, and smiled at her. Germaine's back was
eloquent of her displeasure. The Duke stopped at a gap in the line of
pictures in which there hung a strip of old tapestry.
"I can never understand why you have left all these ancestors of
mine staring from the walls and have taken away the quite admirable
and interesting portrait of myself," he said carelessly.
Germaine turned sharply from the window; Sonia stopped in the
middle of addressing an envelope; and both the girls stared at him in
"There certainly was a portrait of me where that tapestry hangs.
What have you done with it?" said the Duke.
"You're making fun of us again," said Germaine.
"Surely your Grace knows what happened," said Sonia.
"We wrote all the details to you and sent you all the papers three
years ago. Didn't you get them?" said Germaine.
"Not a detail or a newspaper. Three years ago I was in the
neighbourhood of the South Pole, and lost at that," said the Duke.
"But it was most dramatic, my dear Jacques. All Paris was talking
of it," said Germaine. "Your portrait was stolen."
"Stolen? Who stole it?" said the Duke.
Germaine crossed the hall quickly to the gap in the line of
"I'll show you," she said.
She drew aside the piece of tapestry, and in the middle of the
panel over which the portrait of the Duke had hung he saw written in
chalk the words:
"What do you think of that autograph?" said Germaine.
"'Arsene Lupin?'" said the Duke in a tone of some bewilderment.
"He left his signature. It seems that he always does so," said
Sonia in an explanatory tone.
"But who is he?" said the Duke.
"Arsene Lupin? Surely you know who Arsene Lupin is?" said Germaine
"I haven't the slightest notion," said the Duke.
"Oh, come! No one is as South-Pole as all that!" cried Germaine.
"You don't know who Lupin is? The most whimsical, the most audacious,
and the most genial thief in France. For the last ten years he has
kept the police at bay. He has baffled Ganimard, Holmlock Shears, the
great English detective, and even Guerchard, whom everybody says is
the greatest detective we've had in France since Vidocq. In fact, he's
our national robber. Do you mean to say you don't know him?"
"Not even enough to ask him to lunch at a restaurant," said the
Duke flippantly. "What's he like?"
"Like? Nobody has the slightest idea. He has a thousand disguises.
He has dined two evenings running at the English Embassy."
"But if nobody knows him, how did they learn that?" said the Duke,
with a puzzled air.
"Because the second evening, about ten o'clock, they noticed that
one of the guests had disappeared, and with him all the jewels of the
"All of them?" said the Duke.
"Yes; and Lupin left his card behind him with these words scribbled
"'This is not a robbery; it is a restitution. You took the Wallace
collection from us.'"
"But it was a hoax, wasn't it?" said the Duke.
"No, your Grace; and he has done better than that. You remember the
affair of the Daray Bank—the savings bank for poor people?" said
Sonia, her gentle face glowing with a sudden enthusiastic animation.
"Let's see," said the Duke. "Wasn't that the financier who doubled
his fortune at the expense of a heap of poor wretches and ruined two
"Yes; that's the man," said Sonia. "And Lupin stripped Daray's
house and took from him everything he had in his strong-box. He didn't
leave him a sou of the money. And then, when he'd taken it from him,
he distributed it among all the poor wretches whom Daray had ruined."
"But this isn't a thief you're talking about—it's a
philanthropist," said the Duke.
"A fine sort of philanthropist!" broke in Germaine in a peevish
tone. "There was a lot of philanthropy about his robbing papa, wasn't
"Well," said the Duke, with an air of profound reflection, "if you
come to think of it, that robbery was not worthy of this national
hero. My portrait, if you except the charm and beauty of the face
itself, is not worth much."
"If you think he was satisfied with your portrait, you're very much
mistaken. All my father's collections were robbed," said Germaine.
"Your father's collections?" said the Duke. "But they're better
guarded than the Bank of France. Your father is as careful of them as
the apple of his eye."
"That's exactly it—he was too careful of them. That's why Lupin
"This is very interesting," said the Duke; and he sat down on a
couch before the gap in the pictures, to go into the matter more at
his ease. "I suppose he had accomplices in the house itself?"
"Yes, one accomplice," said Germaine.
"Who was that?" asked the Duke.
"Papa!" said Germaine.
"Oh, come! what on earth do you mean?" said the Duke. "You're
getting quite incomprehensible, my dear girl."
"Well, I'll make it clear to you. One morning papa received a
letter—but wait. Sonia, get me the Lupin papers out of the bureau."
Sonia rose from the writing-table, and went to a bureau, an
admirable example of the work of the great English maker,
Chippendale. It stood on the other side of the hall between an
Oriental cabinet and a sixteenth-century Italian cabinet—for all the
world as if it were standing in a crowded curiosity shop—with the
natural effect that the three pieces, by their mere incongruity, took
something each from the beauty of the other. Sonia raised the flap of
the bureau, and taking from one of the drawers a small portfolio,
turned over the papers in it and handed a letter to the Duke.
"This is the envelope," she said. "It's addressed to M. Gournay-
Martin, Collector, at the Chateau de Charmerace, Ile-et-Vilaine."
The Duke opened the envelope and took out a letter.
"It's an odd handwriting," he said.
"Read it—carefully," said Germaine.
It was an uncommon handwriting. The letters of it were small, but
perfectly formed. It looked the handwriting of a man who knew exactly
what he wanted to say, and liked to say it with extreme precision. The
"Please forgive my writing to you without our having
been introduced to one another; but I flatter myself
that you know me, at any rate, by name."
"There is in the drawing-room next your hall a
Gainsborough of admirable quality which affords me
infinite pleasure. Your Goyas in the same drawing-room
are also to my liking, as well as your Van Dyck. In the
further drawing-room I note the Renaissance cabinets—
a marvellous pair—the Flemish tapestry, the Fragonard,
the clock signed Boulle, and various other objects of
less importance. But above all I have set my heart on
that coronet which you bought at the sale of the
Marquise de Ferronaye, and which was formerly worn by
the unfortunate Princesse de Lamballe. I take the
greatest interest in this coronet: in the first place,
on account of the charming and tragic memories which it
calls up in the mind of a poet passionately fond of
history, and in the second place—though it is hardly
worth while talking about that kind of thing—on
account of its intrinsic value. I reckon indeed that
the stones in your coronet are, at the very lowest,
worth half a million francs."
"I beg you, my dear sir, to have these different
objects properly packed up, and to forward them,
addressed to me, carriage paid, to the Batignolles
Station. Failing this, I shall Proceed to remove them
myself on the night of Thursday, August 7th."
"Please pardon the slight trouble to which I am putting
you, and believe me,"
"Yours very sincerely,"
"P.S.—It occurs to me that the pictures have not glass
before them. It would be as well to repair this
omission before forwarding them to me, and I am sure
that you will take this extra trouble cheerfully. I am
aware, of course, that some of the best judges declare
that a picture loses some of its quality when seen
through glass. But it preserves them, and we should
always be ready and willing to sacrifice a portion of
our own pleasure for the benefit of posterity. France
demands it of us.—A. L."
The Duke laughed, and said, "Really, this is extraordinarily funny.
It must have made your father laugh."
"Laugh?" said Germaine. "You should have seen his face. He took it
seriously enough, I can tell you."
"Not to the point of forwarding the things to Batignolles, I hope,"
said the Duke.
"No, but to the point of being driven wild," said Germaine. "And
since the police had always been baffled by Lupin, he had the
brilliant idea of trying what soldiers could do. The Commandant at
Rennes is a great friend of papa's; and papa went to him, and told
him about Lupin's letter and what he feared. The colonel laughed at
him; but he offered him a corporal and six soldiers to guard his
collection, on the night of the seventh. It was arranged that they
should come from Rennes by the last train so that the burglars should
have no warning of their coming. Well, they came, seven picked
men—men who had seen service in Tonquin. We gave them supper; and
then the corporal posted them in the hall and the two drawing-rooms
where the pictures and things were. At eleven we all went to bed,
after promising the corporal that, in the event of any fight with the
burglars, we would not stir from our rooms. I can tell you I felt
awfully nervous. I couldn't get to sleep for ages and ages. Then, when
I did, I did not wake till morning. The night had passed absolutely
quietly. Nothing out of the common had happened. There had not been
the slightest noise. I awoke Sonia and my father. We dressed as
quickly as we could, and rushed down to the drawing-room."
She paused dramatically.
"Well?" said the Duke.
"Well, it was done."
"What was done?" said the Duke.
"Everything," said Germaine. "Pictures had gone, tapestries had
gone, cabinets had gone, and the clock had gone."
"And the coronet too?" said the Duke.
"Oh, no. That was at the Bank of France. And it was doubtless to
make up for not getting it that Lupin stole your portrait. At any
rate he didn't say that he was going to steal it in his letter."
"But, come! this is incredible. Had he hypnotized the corporal and
the six soldiers? Or had he murdered them all?" said the Duke.
"Corporal? There wasn't any corporal, and there weren't any
soldiers. The corporal was Lupin, and the soldiers were part of his
gang," said Germaine.
"I don't understand," said the Duke. "The colonel promised your
father a corporal and six men. Didn't they come?"
"They came to the railway station all right," said Germaine. "But
you know the little inn half-way between the railway station and the
chateau? They stopped to drink there, and at eleven o'clock next
morning one of the villagers found all seven of them, along with the
footman who was guiding them to the chateau, sleeping like logs in
the little wood half a mile from the inn. Of course the innkeeper
could not explain when their wine was drugged. He could only tell us
that a motorist, who had stopped at the inn to get some supper, had
called the soldiers in and insisted on standing them drinks. They had
seemed a little fuddled before they left the inn, and the motorist had
insisted on driving them to the chateau in his car. When the drug took
effect he simply carried them out of it one by one, and laid them in
the wood to sleep it off."
"Lupin seems to have made a thorough job of it, anyhow," said the
"I should think so," said Germaine. "Guerchard was sent down from
Paris; but he could not find a single clue. It was not for want of
trying, for he hates Lupin. It's a regular fight between them, and so
far Lupin has scored every point."
"He must be as clever as they make 'em," said the Duke.
"He is," said Germaine. "And do you know, I shouldn't be at all
surprised if he's in the neighbourhood now."
"What on earth do you mean?" said the Duke.
"I'm not joking," said Germaine. "Odd things are happening. Some
one has been changing the place of things. That silver statuette
now—it was on the cabinet, and we found it moved to the piano. Yet
nobody had touched it. And look at this window. Some one has broken a
pane in it just at the height of the fastening."
"The deuce they have!" said the Duke.
The Duke rose, came to the window, and looked at the broken pane.
He stepped out on to the terrace and looked at the turf; then he came
back into the room.
"This looks serious," he said. "That pane has not been broken at
all. If it had been broken, the pieces of glass would be lying on the
turf. It has been cut out. We must warn your father to look to his
"I told you so," said Germaine. "I said that Arsene Lupin was in
"Arsene Lupin is a very capable man," said the Duke, smiling. "But
there's no reason to suppose that he's the only burglar in France or
even in Ile-et-Vilaine."
"I'm sure that he's in the neighbourhood. I have a feeling that he
is," said Germaine stubbornly.
The Duke shrugged his shoulders, and said a smile: "Far be it from
me to contradict you. A woman's intuition is always—well, it's
always a woman's intuition."
He came back into the hall, and as he did so the door opened and a
shock-headed man in the dress of a gamekeeper stood on the threshold.
"There are visitors to see you, Mademoiselle Germaine," he said, in
a very deep bass voice.
"What! Are you answering the door, Firmin?" said Germaine.
"Yes, Mademoiselle Germaine: there's only me to do it. All the
servants have started for the station, and my wife and I are going to
see after the family to-night and to-morrow morning. Shall I show
these gentlemen in?"
"Who are they?" said Germaine.
"Two gentlemen who say they have an appointment."
"What are their names?" said Germaine.
"They are two gentlemen. I don't know what their names are. I've no
memory for names."
"That's an advantage to any one who answers doors," said the Duke,
smiling at the stolid Firmin.
"Well, it can't be the two Charolais again. It's not time for them
to come back. I told them papa would not be back yet," said Germaine.
"No, it can't be them, Mademoiselle Germaine," said Firmin, with
"Very well; show them in," she said.
Firmin went out, leaving the door open behind him; and they heard
his hob-nailed boots clatter and squeak on the stone floor of the
"Charolais?" said the Duke idly. "I don't know the name. Who are
"A little while ago Alfred announced two gentlemen. I thought they
were Georges and Andre du Buit, for they promised to come to tea. I
told Alfred to show them in, and to my surprise there appeared two
horrible provincials. I never—Oh!"
She stopped short, for there, coming through the door, were the two
Charolais, father and son.
M. Charolais pressed his motor-cap to his bosom, and bowed low.
"Once more I salute you, mademoiselle," he said.
His son bowed, and revealed behind him another young man.
"My second son. He has a chemist's shop," said M. Charolais, waving
a large red hand at the young man.
The young man, also blessed with the family eyes, set close
together, entered the hall and bowed to the two girls. The Duke
raised his eyebrows ever so slightly.
"I'm very sorry, gentlemen," said Germaine, "but my father has not
"Please don't apologize. There is not the slightest need," said M.
Charolais; and he and his two sons settled themselves down on three
chairs, with the air of people who had come to make a considerable
For a moment, Germaine, taken aback by their coolness, was
speechless; then she said hastily: "Very likely he won't be back for
another hour. I shouldn't like you to waste your time."
"Oh, it doesn't matter," said M. Charolais, with an indulgent air;
and turning to the Duke, he added, "However, while we're waiting, if
you're a member of the family, sir, we might perhaps discuss the
least you will take for the motor-car."
"I'm sorry," said the Duke, "but I have nothing to do with it."
Before M. Charolais could reply the door opened, and Firmin's deep
"Will you please come in here, sir?"
A third young man came into the hall.
"What, you here, Bernard?" said M. Charolais. "I told you to wait
at the park gates."
"I wanted to see the car too," said Bernard.
"My third son. He is destined for the Bar," said M. Charolais, with
a great air of paternal pride.
"But how many are there?" said Germaine faintly.
Before M. Charolais could answer, Firmin once more appeared on the
"The master's just come back, miss," he said.
"Thank goodness for that!" said Germaine; and turning to M.
Charolais, she added, "If you will come with me, gentlemen, I will
take you to my father, and you can discuss the price of the car at
As she spoke she moved towards the door. M. Charolais and his sons
rose and made way for her. The father and the two eldest sons made
haste to follow her out of the room. But Bernard lingered behind,
apparently to admire the bric-a-brac on the cabinets. With infinite
quickness he grabbed two objects off the nearest, and followed his
brothers. The Duke sprang across the hall in three strides, caught
him by the arm on the very threshold, jerked him back into the hall,
and shut the door.
"No you don't, my young friend," he said sharply.
"Don't what?" said Bernard, trying to shake off his grip.
"You've taken a cigarette-case," said the Duke.
"No, no, I haven't—nothing of the kind!" stammered Bernard.
The Duke grasped the young man's left wrist, plunged his hand into
the motor-cap which he was carrying, drew out of it a silver
cigarette-case, and held it before his eyes.
Bernard turned pale to the lips. His frightened eyes seemed about
to leap from their sockets.
"It—it—was a m-m-m-mistake," he stammered.
The Duke shifted his grip to his collar, and thrust his hand into
the breast-pocket of his coat. Bernard, helpless in his grip, and
utterly taken aback by his quickness, made no resistance.
The Duke drew out a morocco case, and said: "Is this a mistake
"Heavens! The pendant!" cried Sonia, who was watching the scene
with parted lips and amazed eyes.
Bernard dropped on his knees and clasped his hands.
"Forgive me!" he cried, in a choking voice. "Forgive me! Don't tell
any one! For God's sake, don't tell any one!"
And the tears came streaming from his eyes.
"You young rogue!" said the Duke quietly.
"I'll never do it again—never! Oh, have pity on me! If my father
knew! Oh, let me off!" cried Bernard.
The Duke hesitated, and looked down on him, frowning and pulling at
his moustache. Then, more quickly than one would have expected from
so careless a trifler, his mind was made up.
"All right," he said slowly. "Just for this once . . . be off with
you." And he jerked him to his feet and almost threw him into the
"Thanks! . . . oh, thanks!" said Bernard.
The Duke shut the door and looked at Sonia, breathing quickly.
"Well? Did you ever see anything like that? That young fellow will
go a long way. The cheek of the thing! Right under our very eyes! And
this pendant, too: it would have been a pity to lose it. Upon my word,
I ought to have handed him over to the police."
"No, no!" cried Sonia. "You did quite right to let him off—quite
The Duke set the pendant on the ledge of the bureau, and came down
the hall to Sonia.
"What's the matter?" he said gently. "You're quite pale."
"It has upset me . . . that unfortunate boy," said Sonia; and her
eyes were swimming with tears.
"Do you pity the young rogue?" said the Duke.
"Yes; it's dreadful. His eyes were so terrified, and so boyish.
And, to be caught like that . . . stealing . . . in the act. Oh, it's
"Come, come, how sensitive you are!" said the Duke, in a soothing,
almost caressing tone. His eyes, resting on her charming, troubled
face, were glowing with a warm admiration.
"Yes; it's silly," said Sonia; "but you noticed his eyes—the
hunted look in them? You pitied him, didn't you? For you are kind at
"Why at bottom?" said the Duke.
"Oh, I said at bottom because you look sarcastic, and at first
sight you're so cold. But often that's only the mask of those who have
suffered the most. . . . They are the most indulgent," said Sonia
slowly, hesitating, picking her words.
"Yes, I suppose they are," said the Duke thoughtfully.
"It's because when one has suffered one understands. . . . Yes: one
understands," said Sonia.
There was a pause. The Duke's eyes still rested on her face. The
admiration in them was mingled with compassion.
"You're very unhappy here, aren't you?" he said gently.
"Me? Why?" said Sonia quickly.
"Your smile is so sad, and your eyes so timid," said the Duke
slowly. "You're just like a little child one longs to protect. Are
you quite alone in the world?"
His eyes and tones were full of pity; and a faint flush mantled
"Yes, I'm alone," she said.
"But have you no relations—no friends?" said the Duke.
"No," said Sonia.
"I don't mean here in France, but in your own country. . . . Surely
you have some in Russia?"
"No, not a soul. You see, my father was a Revolutionist. He died in
Siberia when I was a baby. And my mother, she died too—in Paris. She
had fled from Russia. I was two years old when she died."
"It must be hard to be alone like that," said the Duke.
"No," said Sonia, with a faint smile, "I don't mind having no
relations. I grew used to that so young . . . so very young. But what
is hard—but you'll laugh at me—"
"Heaven forbid!" said the Duke gravely.
"Well, what is hard is, never to get a letter . . . an envelope
that one opens . . . from some one who thinks about one—"
She paused, and then added gravely: "But I tell myself that it's
nonsense. I have a certain amount of philosophy."
She smiled at him—an adorable child's smile.
The Duke smiled too. "A certain amount of philosophy," he said
softly. "You look like a philosopher!"
As they stood looking at one another with serious eyes, almost with
eyes that probed one another's souls, the drawing-room door flung
open, and Germaine's harsh voice broke on their ears.
"You're getting quite impossible, Sonia!" she cried. "It's
absolutely useless telling you anything. I told you particularly to
pack my leather writing-case in my bag with your own hand. I happen
to open a drawer, and what do I see? My leather writing-case."
"I'm sorry," said Sonia. "I was going—"
"Oh, there's no need to bother about it. I'll see after it myself,"
said Germaine. "But upon my word, you might be one of our guests,
seeing how easily you take things. You're negligence personified."
"Come, Germaine . . . a mere oversight," said the Duke, in a
"Now, excuse me, Jacques; but you've got an unfortunate habit of
interfering in household matters. You did it only the other day. I
can no longer say a word to a servant—"
"Germaine!" said the Duke, in sharp protest.
Germaine turned from him to Sonia, and pointed to a packet of
envelopes and some letters, which Bernard Charolais had knocked off
the table, and said, "Pick up those envelopes and letters, and bring
everything to my room, and be quick about it!"
She flung out of the room, and slammed the door behind her.
Sonia seemed entirely unmoved by the outburst: no flush of
mortification stained her cheeks, her lips did not quiver. She
stooped to pick up the fallen papers.
"No, no; let me, I beg you," said the Duke, in a tone of distress.
And dropping on one knee, he began to gather together the fallen
papers. He set them on the table, and then he said: "You mustn't mind
what Germaine says. She's—she's—she's all right at heart. It's her
manner. She's always been happy, and had everything she wanted. She's
been spoiled, don't you know. Those kind of people never have any
consideration for any one else. You mustn't let her outburst hurt
"Oh, but I don't. I don't really," protested Sonia.
"I'm glad of that," said the Duke. "It isn't really worth
He drew the envelopes and unused cards into a packet, and handed
them to her.
"There!" he said, with a smile. "That won't be too heavy for you."
"Thank you," said Sonia, taking it from him.
"Shall I carry them for you?" said the Duke.
"No, thank you, your Grace," said Sonia.
With a quick, careless, almost irresponsible movement, he caught
her hand, bent down, and kissed it. A great wave of rosy colour flowed
over her face, flooding its whiteness to her hair and throat. She
stood for a moment turned to stone; she put her hand to her heart.
Then on hasty, faltering feet she went to the door, opened it, paused
on the threshold, turned and looked back at him, and vanished.
The Duke stood for a while staring thoughtfully at the door through
which Sonia had passed, a faint smile playing round his lips. He
crossed the hall to the Chippendale bureau, took a cigarette from a
box which stood on the ledge of it, beside the morocco case which
held the pendant, lighted it, and went slowly out on to the terrace.
He crossed it slowly, paused for a moment on the edge of it, and
looked across the stretch of country with musing eyes, which saw
nothing of its beauty. Then he turned to the right, went down a
flight of steps to the lower terrace, crossed the lawn, and took a
narrow path which led into the heart of a shrubbery of tall deodoras.
In the middle of it he came to one of those old stone benches,
moss-covered and weather-stained, which adorn the gardens of so many
French chateaux. It faced a marble basin from which rose the slender
column of a pattering fountain. The figure of a Cupid danced joyously
on a tall pedestal to the right of the basin. The Duke sat down on the
bench, and was still, with that rare stillness which only comes of
nerves in perfect harmony, his brow knitted in careful thought. Now
and again the frown cleared from his face, and his intent features
relaxed into a faint smile, a smile of pleasant memory. Once he rose,
walked round the fountains frowning, came back to the bench, and sat
down again. The early September dusk was upon him when at last he rose
and with quick steps took his way through the shrubbery, with the air
of a man whose mind, for good or ill, was at last made up.
When he came on to the upper terrace his eyes fell on a group which
stood at the further corner, near the entrance of the chateau, and he
sauntered slowly up to it.
In the middle of it stood M. Gournay-Martin, a big, round, flabby
hulk of a man. He was nearly as red in the face as M. Charolais; and
he looked a great deal redder owing to the extreme whiteness of the
whiskers which stuck out on either side of his vast expanse of cheek.
As he came up, it struck the Duke as rather odd that he should have
the Charolais eyes, set close together; any one who did not know that
they were strangers to one another might have thought it a family
The millionaire was waving his hands and roaring after the manner
of a man who has cultivated the art of brow-beating those with whom he
does business; and as the Duke neared the group, he caught the words:
"No; that's the lowest I'll take. Take it or leave it. You can say
Yes, or you can say Good-bye; and I don't care a hang which."
"It's very dear," said M. Charolais, in a mournful tone.
"Dear!" roared M. Gournay-Martin. "I should like to see any one
else sell a hundred horse-power car for eight hundred pounds. Why, my
good sir, you're having me!"
"No, no," protested M. Charolais feebly.
"I tell you you're having me," roared M. Gournay-Martin. "I'm
letting you have a magnificent car for which I paid thirteen hundred
pounds for eight hundred! It's scandalous the way you've beaten me
"No, no," protested M. Charolais.
He seemed frightened out of his life by the vehemence of the big
"You wait till you've seen how it goes," said M. Gournay-Martin.
"Eight hundred is very dear," said M. Charolais.
"Come, come! You're too sharp, that's what you are. But don't say
any more till you've tried the car."
He turned to his chauffeur, who stood by watching the struggle with
an appreciative grin on his brown face, and said: "Now, Jean, take
these gentlemen to the garage, and run them down to the station. Show
them what the car can do. Do whatever they ask you— everything."
He winked at Jean, turned again to M. Charolais, and said: "You
know, M. Charolais, you're too good a man of business for me. You're
hot stuff, that's what you are—hot stuff. You go along and try the
The four Charolais murmured good-bye in deep depression, and went
off with Jean, wearing something of the air of whipped dogs. When
they had gone round the corner the millionaire turned to the Duke and
said, with a chuckle: "He'll buy the car all right—had him fine!"
"No business success of yours could surprise me," said the Duke
blandly, with a faint, ironical smile.
M. Gournay-Martin's little pig's eyes danced and sparkled; and the
smiles flowed over the distended skin of his face like little ripples
over a stagnant pool, reluctantly. It seemed to be too tightly
stretched for smiles.
"The car's four years old," he said joyfully. "He'll give me eight
hundred for it, and it's not worth a pipe of tobacco. And eight
hundred pounds is just the price of a little Watteau I've had my eye
on for some time—a first-class investment."
They strolled down the terrace, and through one of the windows into
the hall. Firmin had lighted the lamps, two of them. They made but a
small oasis of light in a desert of dim hall. The millionaire let
himself down very gingerly into an Empire chair, as if he feared,
with excellent reason, that it might collapse under his weight.
"Well, my dear Duke," he said, "you don't ask me the result of my
official lunch or what the minister said."
"Is there any news?" said the Duke carelessly.
"Yes. The decree will be signed to-morrow. You can consider
yourself decorated. I hope you feel a happy man," said the
millionaire, rubbing his fat hands together with prodigious
"Oh, charmed—charmed," said the Duke, with entire indifference.
"As for me, I'm delighted—delighted," said the millionaire. "I was
extremely keen on your being decorated. After that, and after a
volume or two of travels, and after you've published your
grandfather's letters with a good introduction, you can begin to
think of the Academy."
"The Academy!" said the Duke, startled from his usual coolness.
"But I've no title to become an Academician."
"How, no title?" said the millionaire solemnly; and his little eyes
opened wide. "You're a duke."
"There's no doubt about that," said the Duke, watching him with
"I mean to marry my daughter to a worker—a worker, my dear Duke,"
said the millionaire, slapping his big left hand with his bigger
right. "I've no prejudices—not I. I wish to have for son-in-law a
duke who wears the Order of the Legion of Honour, and belongs to the
Academic Francaise, because that is personal merit. I'm no snob."
A gentle, irrepressible laugh broke from the Duke.
"What are you laughing at?" said the millionaire, and a sudden
lowering gloom overspread his beaming face.
"Nothing—nothing," said the Duke quietly. "Only you're so full of
"I've startled you, have I? I thought I should. It's true that I'm
full of surprises. It's my knowledge. I understand so much. I
understand business, and I love art, pictures, a good bargain, bric-
a-brac, fine tapestry. They're first-class investments. Yes,
certainly I do love the beautiful. And I don't want to boast, but I
understand it. I have taste, and I've something better than taste; I
have a flair, the dealer's flair."
"Yes, your collections, especially your collection in Paris, prove
it," said the Duke, stifling a yawn.
"And yet you haven't seen the finest thing I have—the coronet of
the Princesse de Lamballe. It's worth half a million francs."
"So I've heard," said the Duke, a little wearily. "I don't wonder
that Arsene Lupin envied you it."
The Empire chair creaked as the millionaire jumped.
"Don't speak of the swine!" he roared. "Don't mention his name
"Germaine showed me his letter," said the Duke. "It is amusing."
"His letter! The blackguard! I just missed a fit of apoplexy from
it," roared the millionaire. "I was in this very hall where we are
now, chatting quietly, when all at once in comes Firmin, and hands me
He was interrupted by the opening of the door. Firmin came clumping
down the room, and said in his deep voice, "A letter for you, sir."
"Thank you," said the millionaire, taking the letter, and, as he
fitted his eye-glass into his eye, he went on, "Yes, Firmin brought
me a letter of which the handwriting,"—he raised the envelope he was
holding to his eyes, and bellowed, "Good heavens!"
"What's the matter?" said the Duke, jumping in his chair at the
sudden, startling burst of sound.
"The handwriting!—the handwriting!—it's THE SAME HANDWRITING!"
gasped the millionaire. And he let himself fall heavily backwards
against the back of his chair.
There was a crash. The Duke had a vision of huge arms and legs
waving in the air as the chair-back gave. There was another crash.
The chair collapsed. The huge bulk banged to the floor.
The laughter of the Duke rang out uncontrollably. He caught one of
the waving arms, and jerked the flabby giant to his feet with an ease
which seemed to show that his muscles were of steel.
"Come," he said, laughing still. "This is nonsense! What do you
mean by the same handwriting? It can't be."
"It is the same handwriting. Am I likely to make a mistake about
it?" spluttered the millionaire. And he tore open the envelope with
an air of frenzy.
He ran his eyes over it, and they grew larger and larger—they grew
almost of an average size.
"Listen," he said "listen:"
"My collection of pictures, which I had the pleasure of starting
three years ago with some of your own, only contains, as far as Old
Masters go, one Velasquez, one Rembrandt, and three paltry Rubens. You
have a great many more. Since it is a shame such masterpieces should
be in your hands, I propose to appropriate them; and I shall set
about a respectful acquisition of them in your Paris house tomorrow
"Yours very sincerely,"
"He's humbugging," said the Duke.
"Wait! wait!" gasped the millionaire. "There's a postscript.
"P.S.—You must understand that since you have been keeping the
coronet of the Princesse de Lamballe during these three years, I shall
avail myself of the same occasion to compel you to restore that piece
of jewellery to me.—A. L."
"The thief! The scoundrel! I'm choking!" gasped the millionaire,
clutching at his collar.
To judge from the blackness of his face, and the way he staggered
and dropped on to a couch, which was fortunately stronger than the
chair, he was speaking the truth.
"Firmin! Firmin!" shouted the Duke. "A glass of water! Quick! Your
He rushed to the side of the millionaire, who gasped: "Telephone!
Telephone to the Prefecture of Police! Be quick!"
The Duke loosened his collar with deft fingers; tore a Van Loo fan
from its case hanging on the wall, and fanned him furiously. Firmin
came clumping into the room with a glass of water in his hand.
The drawing-room door opened, and Germaine and Sonia, alarmed by
the Duke's shout, hurried in.
"Quick! Your smelling-salts!" said the Duke.
Sonia ran across the hall, opened one of the drawers in the
Oriental cabinet, and ran to the millionaire with a large bottle of
smelling- salts in her hand. The Duke took it from her, and applied it
to the millionaire's nose. The millionaire sneezed thrice with
terrific violence. The Duke snatched the glass from Firmin and dashed
the water into his host's purple face. The millionaire gasped and
Germaine stood staring helplessly at her gasping sire.
"Whatever's the matter?" she said.
"It's this letter," said the Duke. "A letter from Lupin."
"I told you so—I said that Lupin was in the neighbourhood," cried
"Firmin—where's Firmin?" said the millionaire, dragging himself
upright. He seemed to have recovered a great deal of his voice. "Oh,
there you are!"
He jumped up, caught the gamekeeper by the shoulder, and shook him
"This letter. Where did it come from? Who brought it?" he roared.
"It was in the letter-box—the letter-box of the lodge at the
bottom of the park. My wife found it there," said Firmin, and he
twisted out of the millionaire's grasp.
"Just as it was three years ago," roared the millionaire, with an
air of desperation. "It's exactly the same coup. Oh, what a
catastrophe! What a catastrophe!"
He made as if to tear out his hair; then, remembering its
"Now, come, it's no use losing your head," said the Duke, with
quiet firmness. "If this letter isn't a hoax—"
"Hoax?" bellowed the millionaire. "Was it a hoax three years ago?"
"Very good," said the Duke. "But if this robbery with which you're
threatened is genuine, it's just childish."
"How?" said the millionaire.
"Look at the date of the letter—Sunday, September the third. This
letter was written to-day."
"Yes. Well, what of it?" said the millionaire.
"Look at the letter: 'I shall set about a respectful acquisition of
them in your Paris house to-morrow morning '—to-morrow morning."
"Yes, yes; 'to-morrow morning'—what of it?" said the millionaire.
"One of two things," said the Duke. "Either it's a hoax, and we
needn't bother about it; or the threat is genuine, and we have the
time to stop the robbery." "Of course we have. Whatever was I
thinking of?" said the millionaire. And his anguish cleared from his
"For once in a way our dear Lupin's fondness for warning people
will have given him a painful jar," said the Duke.
"Come on! let me get at the telephone," cried the millionaire.
"But the telephone's no good," said Sonia quickly.
"No good! Why?" roared the millionaire, dashing heavily across the
room to it.
"Look at the time," said Sonia; "the telephone doesn't work as late
as this. It's Sunday."
The millionaire stopped dead.
"It's true. It's appalling," he groaned.
"But that doesn't matter. You can always telegraph," said Germaine.
"But you can't. It's impossible," said Sonia. "You can't get a
message through. It's Sunday; and the telegraph offices shut at
"Oh, what a Government!" groaned the millionaire. And he sank down
gently on a chair beside the telephone, and mopped the beads of
anguish from his brow. They looked at him, and they looked at one
another, cudgelling their brains for yet another way of communicating
with the Paris police.
"Hang it all!" said the Duke. "There must be some way out of the
"What way?" said the millionaire.
The Duke did not answer. He put his hands in his pockets and walked
impatiently up and down the hall. Germaine sat down on a chair. Sonia
put her hands on the back of a couch, and leaned forward, watching
him. Firmin stood by the door, whither he had retired to be out of the
reach of his excited master, with a look of perplexity on his stolid
face. They all watched the Duke with the air of people waiting for an
oracle to deliver its message. The millionaire kept mopping the beads
of anguish from his brow. The more he thought of his impending loss,
the more freely he perspired. Germaine's maid, Irma, came to the door
leading into the outer hall, which Firmin, according to his usual
custom, had left open, and peered in wonder at the silent group.
"I have it!" cried the Duke at last. "There is a way out."
"What is it?" said the millionaire, rising and coming to the middle
of the hall.
"What time is it?" said the Duke, pulling out his watch.
The millionaire pulled out his watch. Germaine pulled out hers.
Firmin, after a struggle, produced from some pocket difficult of
access an object not unlike a silver turnip. There was a brisk
dispute between Germaine and the millionaire about which of their
watches was right. Firmin, whose watch apparently did not agree with
the watch of either of them, made his deep voice heard above theirs.
The Duke came to the conclusion that it must be a few minutes past
"It's seven or a few minutes past," he said sharply. "Well, I'm
going to take a car and hurry off to Paris. I ought to get there, bar
accidents, between two and three in the morning, just in time to
inform the police and catch the burglars in the very midst of their
burglary. I'll just get a few things together."
So saying, he rushed out of the hall.
"Excellent! excellent!" said the millionaire. "Your young man is a
man of resource, Germaine. It seems almost a pity that he's a duke.
He'd do wonders in the building trade. But I'm going to Paris too,
and you're coming with me. I couldn't wait idly here, to save my
life. And I can't leave you here, either. This scoundrel may be going
to make a simultaneous attempt on the chateau—not that there's much
here that I really value. There's that statuette that moved, and the
pane cut out of the window. I can't leave you two girls with burglars
in the house. After all, there's the sixty horse-power and the thirty
horse-power car—there'll be lots of room for all of us."
"Oh, but it's nonsense, papa; we shall get there before the
servants," said Germaine pettishly. "Think of arriving at an empty
house in the dead of night."
"Nonsense!" said the millionaire. "Hurry off and get ready. Your
bag ought to be packed. Where are my keys? Sonia, where are my
keys—the keys of the Paris house?"
"They're in the bureau," said Sonia.
"Well, see that I don't go without them. Now hurry up. Firmin, go
and tell Jean that we shall want both cars. I will drive one, the
Duke the other. Jean must stay with you and help guard the chateau."
So saying he bustled out of the hall, driving the two girls before
Hardly had the door closed behind the millionaire when the head of
M. Charolais appeared at one of the windows opening on to the
terrace. He looked round the empty hall, whistled softly, and stepped
inside. Inside of ten seconds his three sons came in through the
windows, and with them came Jean, the millionaire's chauffeur.
"Take the door into the outer hall, Jean," said M. Charolais, in a
low voice. "Bernard, take that door into the drawing-room. Pierre and
Louis, help me go through the drawers. The whole family is going to
Paris, and if we're not quick we shan't get the cars."
"That comes of this silly fondness for warning people of a coup,"
growled Jean, as he hurried to the door of the outer hall. "It would
have been so simple to rob the Paris house without sending that
infernal letter. It was sure to knock them all silly."
"What harm can the letter do, you fool?" said M. Charolais. "It's
Sunday. We want them knocked silly for to-morrow, to get hold of the
coronet. Oh, to get hold of that coronet! It must be in Paris. I've
been ransacking this chateau for hours."
Jean opened the door of the outer hall half an inch, and glued his
eyes to it. Bernard had done the same with the door opening into the
drawing-room. M. Charolais, Pierre, and Louis were opening drawers,
ransacking them, and shutting them with infinite quickness and
"Bureau! Which is the bureau? The place is stuffed with bureaux!"
growled M. Charolais. "I must have those keys."
"That plain thing with the brass handles in the middle on the
left— that's a bureau," said Bernard softly.
"Why didn't you say so?" growled M. Charolais.
He dashed to it, and tried it. It was locked.
"Locked, of course! Just my luck! Come and get it open, Pierre. Be
The son he had described as an engineer came quickly to the bureau,
fitting together as he came the two halves of a small jemmy. He
fitted it into the top of the flap. There was a crunch, and the old
lock gave. He opened the flap, and he and M. Charolais pulled open
drawer after drawer.
"Quick! Here's that fat old fool!" said Jean, in a hoarse, hissing
He moved down the hall, blowing out one of the lamps as he passed
it. In the seventh drawer lay a bunch of keys. M. Charolais snatched
it up, glanced at it, took a bunch of keys from his own pocket, put
it in the drawer, closed it, closed the flap, and rushed to the
window. Jean and his sons were already out on the terrace.
M. Charolais was still a yard from the window when the door into
the outer hall opened and in came M. Gournay-Martin.
He caught a glimpse of a back vanishing through the window, and
bellowed: "Hi! A man! A burglar! Firmin! Firmin!"
He ran blundering down the hall, tangled his feet in the fragments
of the broken chair, and came sprawling a thundering cropper, which
knocked every breath of wind out of his capacious body. He lay flat
on his face for a couple of minutes, his broad back wriggling
convulsively—a pathetic sight!—in the painful effort to get his
breath back. Then he sat up, and with perfect frankness burst into
tears. He sobbed and blubbered, like a small child that has hurt
itself, for three or four minutes. Then, having recovered his
magnificent voice, he bellowed furiously: "Firmin! Firmin!
Then he rose painfully to his feet, and stood staring at the open
Presently he roared again: "Firmin! Firmin! Charmerace!
He kept looking at the window with terrified eyes, as though he
expected somebody to step in and cut his throat from ear to ear.
"Firmin! Firmin! Charmerace! Charmerace!" he bellowed again.
The Duke came quietly into the hall, dressed in a heavy motor-coat,
his motor-cap on his head, and carrying a kit-bag in his hand.
"Did I hear you call?" he said.
"Call?" said the millionaire. "I shouted. The burglars are here
already. I've just seen one of them. He was bolting through the
The Duke raised his eyebrows.
"Nerves," he said gently—"nerves."
"Nerves be hanged!" said the millionaire. "I tell you I saw him as
plainly as I see you."
"Well, you can't see me at all, seeing that you're lighting an acre
and a half of hall with a single lamp," said the Duke, still in a
tone of utter incredulity.
"It's that fool Firmin! He ought to have lighted six. Firmin!
Firmin!" bellowed the millionaire.
They listened for the sonorous clumping of the promoted
gamekeeper's boots, but they did not hear it. Evidently Firmin was
still giving his master's instructions about the cars to Jean.
"Well, we may as well shut the windows, anyhow," said the Duke,
proceeding to do so. "If you think Firmin would be any good, you
might post him in this hall with a gun to-night. There could be no
harm in putting a charge of small shot into the legs of these
ruffians. He has only to get one of them, and the others will go for
their lives. Yet I don't like leaving you and Germaine in this big
house with only Firmin to look after you."
"I shouldn't like it myself, and I'm not going to chance it,"
growled the millionaire. "We're going to motor to Paris along with
you, and leave Jean to help Firmin fight these burglars. Firmin's all
right—he's an old soldier. He fought in '70. Not that I've much
belief in soldiers against this cursed Lupin, after the way he dealt
with that corporal and his men three years ago."
"I'm glad you're coming to Paris," said the Duke. "It'll be a
weight off my mind. I'd better drive the limousine, and you take the
"That won't do," said the millionaire. "Germaine won't go in the
limousine. You know she has taken a dislike to it."
"Nevertheless, I'd better bucket on to Paris, and let you follow
slowly with Germaine. The sooner I get to Paris the better for your
collection. I'll take Mademoiselle Kritchnoff with me, and, if you
like, Irma, though the lighter I travel the sooner I shall get
"No, I'll take Irma and Germaine," said the millionaire. "Germaine
would prefer to have Irma with her, in case you had an accident. She
wouldn't like to get to Paris and have to find a fresh maid."
The drawing-room door opened, and in came Germaine, followed by
Sonia and Irma. They wore motor-cloaks and hoods and veils. Sonia and
Irma were carrying hand-bags.
"I think it's extremely tiresome your dragging us off to Paris like
this in the middle of the night," said Germaine pettishly.
"Do you?" said the millionaire. "Well, then, you'll be interested
to hear that I've just seen a burglar here in this very room. I
frightened him, and he bolted through the window on to the terrace."
"He was greenish-pink, slightly tinged with yellow," said the Duke
"Greenish-pink? Oh, do stop your jesting, Jacques! Is this a time
for idiocy?" cried Germaine, in a tone of acute exasperation.
"It was the dim light which made your father see him in those
colours. In a bright light, I think he would have been an Alsatian
blue," said the Duke suavely.
"You'll have to break yourself of this silly habit of trifling, my
dear Duke, if ever you expect to be a member of the Academie
Francaise," said the millionaire with some acrimony. "I tell you I
did see a burglar."
"Yes, yes. I admitted it frankly. It was his colour I was talking
about," said the Duke, with an ironical smile.
"Oh, stop your idiotic jokes! We're all sick to death of them!"
said Germaine, with something of the fine fury which so often
distinguished her father.
"There are times for all things," said the millionaire solemnly.
"And I must say that, with the fate of my collection and of the
coronet trembling in the balance, this does not seem to me a season
for idle jests."
"I stand reproved," said the Duke; and he smiled at Sonia.
"My keys, Sonia—the keys of the Paris house," said the
Sonia took her own keys from her pocket and went to the bureau. She
slipped a key into the lock and tried to turn it. It would not turn;
and she bent down to look at it.
"Why—why, some one's been tampering with the lock! It's broken!"
"I told you I'd seen a burglar!" cried the millionaire
triumphantly. "He was after the keys."
Sonia drew back the flap of the bureau and hastily pulled open the
drawer in which the keys had been.
"They're here!" she cried, taking them out of the drawer and
holding them up.
"Then I was just in time," said the millionaire. "I startled him in
the very act of stealing the keys."
"I withdraw! I withdraw!" said the Duke. "You did see a burglar,
evidently. But still I believe he was greenish-pink. They often are.
However, you'd better give me those keys, Mademoiselle Sonia, since
I'm to get to Paris first. I should look rather silly if, when I got
there, I had to break into the house to catch the burglars."
Sonia handed the keys to the Duke. He contrived to take her little
hand, keys and all, into his own, as he received them, and squeezed
it. The light was too dim for the others to see the flush which
flamed in her face. She went back and stood beside the bureau.
"Now, papa, are you going to motor to Paris in a thin coat and
linen waistcoat? If we're going, we'd better go. You always do keep us
waiting half an hour whenever we start to go anywhere," said Germaine
The millionaire bustled out of the room. With a gesture of
impatience Germaine dropped into a chair. Irma stood waiting by the
drawing-room door. Sonia sat down by the bureau.
There came a sharp patter of rain against the windows.
"Rain! It only wanted that! It's going to be perfectly beastly!"
"Oh, well, you must make the best of it. At any rate you're well
wrapped up, and the night is warm enough, though it is raining," said
the Duke. "Still, I could have wished that Lupin confined his
operations to fine weather." He paused, and added cheerfully, "But,
after all, it will lay the dust."
They sat for three or four minutes in a dull silence, listening to
the pattering of the rain against the panes. The Duke took his
cigarette-case from his pocket and lighted a cigarette.
Suddenly he lost his bored air; his face lighted up; and he said
joyfully: "Of course, why didn't I think of it? Why should we start
from a pit of gloom like this? Let us have the proper illumination
which our enterprise deserves."
With that he set about lighting all the lamps in the hall. There
were lamps on stands, lamps on brackets, lamps on tables, and lamps
which hung from the roof—old-fashioned lamps with new reservoirs,
new lamps of what is called chaste design, brass lamps, silver lamps,
and lamps in porcelain. The Duke lighted them one after another,
patiently, missing none, with a cold perseverance. The operation was
punctuated by exclamations from Germaine. They were all to the effect
that she could not understand how he could be such a fool. The Duke
paid no attention whatever to her. His face illumined with boyish
glee, he lighted lamp after lamp.
Sonia watched him with a smiling admiration of the childlike
enthusiasm with which he performed the task. Even the stolid face of
the ox-eyed Irma relaxed into grins, which she smoothed quickly out
with a respectful hand.
The Duke had just lighted the twenty-second lamp when in bustled
"What's this? What's this?" he cried, stopping short, blinking.
"Just some more of Jacques' foolery!" cried Germaine in tones of
the last exasperation.
"But, my dear Duke!—my dear Duke! The oil!—the oil!" cried the
millionaire, in a tone of bitter distress. "Do you think it's my
object in life to swell the Rockefeller millions? We never have more
than six lamps burning unless we are holding a reception."
"I think it looks so cheerful," said the Duke, looking round on his
handiwork with a beaming smile of satisfaction. "But where are the
cars? Jean seems a deuce of a time bringing them round. Does he
expect us to go to the garage through this rain? We'd better hurry
him up. Come on; you've got a good carrying voice."
He caught the millionaire by the arm, hurried him through the outer
hall, opened the big door of the chateau, and said: "Now shout!"
The millionaire looked at him, shrugged his shoulders, and said:
"You don't beat about the bush when you want anything."
"Why should I?" said the Duke simply. "Shout, my good chap—shout!"
The millionaire raised his voice in a terrific bellow of "Jean!
Jean! Firmin! Firmin!"
There was no answer.
The night was very black; the rain pattered in their faces.
Again the millionaire bellowed: "Jean! Firmin! Firmin! Jean!"
No answer came out of the darkness, though his bellow echoed and
re- echoed among the out-buildings and stables away on the left.
He turned and looked at the Duke and said uneasily, "What on earth
can they be doing?"
"I can't conceive," said the Duke. "I suppose we must go and hunt
"What! in this darkness, with these burglars about?" said the
millionaire, starting back.
"If we don't, nobody else will," said the Duke. "And all the time
that rascal Lupin is stealing nearer and nearer your pictures. So
buck up, and come along!"
He seized the reluctant millionaire by the arm and drew him down
the steps. They took their way to the stables. A dim light shone from
the open door of the motor-house. The Duke went into it first, and
"Well, I'll be hanged!" he cried,
Instead of three cars the motor-house held but one—the hundred
horse-power Mercrac. It was a racing car, with only two seats. On
them sat two figures, Jean and Firmin.
"What are you sitting there for? You idle dogs!" bellowed the
Neither of the men answered, nor did they stir. The light from the
lamp gleamed on their fixed eyes, which stared at their infuriated
"What on earth is this?" said the Duke; and seizing the lamp which
stood beside the car, he raised it so that its light fell on the two
figures. Then it was clear what had happened: they were trussed like
two fowls, and gagged.
The Duke pulled a penknife from his pocket, opened the blade,
stepped into the car and set Firmin free. Firmin coughed and spat and
swore. The Duke cut the bonds of Jean.
"Well," said the Duke, in a tone of cutting irony, "what new game
is this? What have you been playing at?"
"It was those Charolais—those cursed Charolais!" growled Firmin.
"They came on us unawares from behind," said Jean.
"They tied us up, and gagged us—the swine!" said Firmin.
"And then—they went off in the two cars," said Jean.
"Went off in the two cars?" cried the millionaire, in blank
The Duke burst into a shout of laughter.
"Well, your dear friend Lupin doesn't do things by halves," he
cried. "This is the funniest thing I ever heard of."
"Funny!" howled the millionaire. "Funny! Where does the fun come
in? What about my pictures and the coronet?"
The Duke laughed his laugh out; then changed on the instant to a
man of action.
"Well, this means a change in our plans," he said. "I must get to
Paris in this car here."
"It's such a rotten old thing," said the millionaire. "You'll never
"Never mind," said the Duke. "I've got to do it somehow. I daresay
it's better than you think. And after all, it's only a matter of two
hundred miles." He paused, and then said in an anxious tone: "All the
same I don't like leaving you and Germaine in the chateau.— these
rogues have probably only taken the cars out of reach just to prevent
your getting to Paris. They'll leave them in some field and come
"You're not going to leave us behind. I wouldn't spend the night in
the chateau for a million francs. There's always the train," said the
"The train! Twelve hours in the train—with all those changes! You
don't mean that you will actually go to Paris by train?" said the
"I do," said the millionaire. "Come along—I must go and tell
Germaine; there's no time to waste," and he hurried off to the
"Get the lamps lighted, Jean, and make sure that the tank's full.
As for the engine, I must humour it and trust to luck. I'll get her to
Paris somehow," said the Duke.
He went back to the chateau, and Firmin followed him.
When the Duke came into the great hall he found Germaine and her
father indulging in recriminations. She was declaring that nothing
would induce her to make the journey by train; her father was
declaring that she should. He bore down her opposition by the mere
force of his magnificent voice.
When at last there came a silence, Sonia said quietly: "But is
there a train? I know there's a train at midnight; but is there one
"A time-table—where's a time-table?" said the millionaire.
"Now, where did I see a time-table?" said the Duke. "Oh, I know;
there's one in the drawer of that Oriental cabinet." Crossing to the
cabinet, he opened the drawer, took out the time-table, and handed it
to M. Gournay-Martin.
The millionaire took it and turned over the leaves quickly, ran his
eye down a page, and said, "Yes, thank goodness, there is a train.
There's one at a quarter to nine."
"And what good is it to us? How are we to get to the station?" said
They looked at one another blankly. Firmin, who had followed the
Duke into the hall, came to the rescue.
"There's the luggage-cart," he said.
"The luggage-cart!" cried Germaine contemptuously.
"The very thing!" said the millionaire. "I'll drive it myself. Off
you go, Firmin; harness a horse to it."
Firmin went clumping out of the hall.
It was perhaps as well that he went, for the Duke asked what time
it was; and since the watches of Germaine and her father differed
still, there ensued an altercation in which, had Firmin been there,
he would doubtless have taken part.
The Duke cut it short by saying: "Well, I don't think I'll wait to
see you start for the station. It won't take you more than half an
hour. The cart is light. You needn't start yet. I'd better get off as
soon as the car is ready. It isn't as though I could trust it."
"One moment," said Germaine. "Is there a dining-car on the train?
I'm not going to be starved as well as have my night's rest cut to
"Of course there isn't a dining-car," snapped her father. "We must
eat something now, and take something with us."
"Sonia, Irma, quick! Be off to the larder and see what you can
find. Tell Mother Firmin to make an omelette. Be quick!"
Sonia went towards the door of the hall, followed by Irma.
"Good-night, and bon voyage, Mademoiselle Sonia," said the Duke.
"Good-night, and bon voyage, your Grace," said Sonia.
The Duke opened the door of the hall for her; and as she went out,
she said anxiously, in a low voice: "Oh, do—do be careful. I hate to
think of your hurrying to Paris on a night like this. Please be
"I will be careful," said the Duke.
The honk of the motor-horn told him that Jean had brought the car
to the door of the chateau. He came down the room, kissed Germaine's
hands, shook hands with the millionaire, and bade them good-night.
Then he went out to the car. They heard it start; the rattle of it
grew fainter and fainter down the long avenue and died away.
M. Gournay-Martin arose, and began putting out lamps. As he did so,
he kept casting fearful glances at the window, as if he feared lest,
now that the Duke had gone, the burglars should dash in upon him.
There came a knock at the door, and Jean appeared on the threshold.
"His Grace told me that I was to come into the house, and help
Firmin look after it," he said.
The millionaire gave him instructions about the guarding of the
house. Firmin, since he was an old soldier, was to occupy the post of
honour, and guard the hall, armed with his gun. Jean was to guard the
two drawing-rooms, as being less likely points of attack. He also was
to have a gun; and the millionaire went with him to the gun-room and
gave him one and a dozen cartridges. When they came back to the hall,
Sonia called them into the dining-room; and there, to the
accompaniment of an unsubdued grumbling from Germaine at having to eat
cold food at eight at night, they made a hasty but excellent meal,
since the chef had left an elaborate cold supper ready to be served.
They had nearly finished it when Jean came in, his gun on his arm,
to say that Firmin had harnessed the horse to the luggage-cart, and
it was awaiting them at the door of the chateau.
"Send him in to me, and stand by the horse till we come out," said
Firmin came clumping in.
The millionaire gazed at him solemnly, and said: "Firmin, I am
relying on you. I am leaving you in a position of honour and danger-
-a position which an old soldier of France loves."
Firmin did his best to look like an old soldier of France. He
pulled himself up out of the slouch which long years of loafing
through woods with a gun on his arm had given him. He lacked also the
old soldier of France's fiery gaze. His eyes were lack-lustre.
"I look for anything, Firmin—burglary, violence, an armed
assault," said the millionaire.
"Don't be afraid, sir. I saw the war of '70," said Firmin boldly,
rising to the occasion.
"Good!" said the millionaire. "I confide the chateau to you. I
trust you with my treasures."
He rose, and saying "Come along, we must be getting to the
station," he led the way to the door of the chateau.
The luggage-cart stood rather high, and they had to bring a chair
out of the hall to enable the girls to climb into it. Germaine did
not forget to give her real opinion of the advantages of a seat
formed by a plank resting on the sides of the cart. The millionaire
climbed heavily up in front, and took the reins.
"Never again will I trust only to motor-cars. The first thing I'll
do after I've made sure that my collections are safe will be to buy
carriages—something roomy," he said gloomily, as he realized the
discomfort of his seat.
He turned to Jean and Firmin, who stood on the steps of the chateau
watching the departure of their master, and said: "Sons of France, be
The cart bumped off into the damp, dark night.
Jean and Firmin watched it disappear into the darkness. Then they
came into the chateau and shut the door.
Firmin looked at Jean, and said gloomily: "I don't like this. These
burglars stick at nothing. They'd as soon cut your throat as look at
"It can't be helped," said Jean. "Besides, you've got the post of
honour. You guard the hall. I'm to look after the drawing-rooms.
They're not likely to break in through the drawing-rooms. And I shall
lock the door between them and the hall."
"No, no; you won't lock that door!" cried Firmin.
"But I certainly will," said Jean. "You'd better come and get a
They went to the gun-room, Firmin still protesting against the
locking of the door between the drawing-rooms and the hall. He chose
his gun; and they went into the kitchen. Jean took two bottles of
wine, a rich-looking pie, a sweet, and carried them to the drawing-
room. He came back into the hall, gathered together an armful of
papers and magazines, and went back to the drawing-room. Firmin kept
trotting after him, like a little dog with a somewhat heavy footfall.
On the threshold of the drawing-room Jean paused and said: "The
important thing with burglars is to fire first, old cock. Good-
night. Pleasant dreams."
He shut the door and turned the key. Firmin stared at the decorated
panels blankly. The beauty of the scheme of decoration did not, at
the moment, move him to admiration.
He looked fearfully round the empty hall and at the windows, black
against the night. Under the patter of the rain he heard footsteps—
distinctly. He went hastily clumping down the hall, and along the
passage to the kitchen.
His wife was setting his supper on the table.
"My God!" he said. "I haven't been so frightened since '70." And he
mopped his glistening forehead with a dish-cloth. It was not a clean
dish-cloth; but he did not care.
"Frightened? What of?" said his wife.
"Burglars! Cut-throats!" said Firmin.
He told her of the fears of M. Gournay-Martin, and of his own
appointment to the honourable and dangerous post of guard of the
"God save us!" said his wife. "You lock the door of that beastly
hall, and come into the kitchen. Burglars won't bother about the
"But the master's treasures!" protested Firmin. "He confided them
to me. He said so distinctly."
"Let the master look after his treasures himself," said Madame
Firmin, with decision. "You've only one throat; and I'm not going to
have it cut. You sit down and eat your supper. Go and lock that door
Firmin locked the door of the hall; then he locked the door of the
kitchen; then he sat down, and began to eat his supper. His appetite
was hearty, but none the less he derived little pleasure from the
meal. He kept stopping with the food poised on his fork, midway
between the plate and his mouth, for several seconds at a time, while
he listened with straining ears for the sound of burglars breaking in
the windows of the hall. He was much too far from those windows to
hear anything that happened to them, but that did not prevent him from
straining his ears. Madame Firmin ate her supper with an air of
perfect ease. She felt sure that burglars would not bother with the
Firmin's anxiety made him terribly thirsty. Tumbler after tumbler
of wine flowed down the throat for which he feared. When he had
finished his supper he went on satisfying his thirst. Madame Firmin
lighted his pipe for him, and went and washed up the supper-dishes in
the scullery. Then she came back, and sat down on the other side of
the hearth, facing him. About the middle of his third bottle of wine,
Firmin's cold, relentless courage was suddenly restored to him. He
began to talk firmly about his duty to his master, his resolve to die,
if need were, in defence of his interests, of his utter contempt for
burglars—probably Parisians. But he did not go into the hall.
Doubtless the pleasant warmth of the kitchen fire held him in his
He had described to his wife, with some ferocity, the cruel manner
in which he would annihilate the first three burglars who entered the
hall, and was proceeding to describe his method of dealing with the
fourth, when there came a loud knocking on the front door of the
Stricken silent, turned to stone, Firmin sat with his mouth open,
in the midst of an unfinished word. Madame Firmin scuttled to the
kitchen door she had left unlocked on her return from the scullery,
and locked it. She turned, and they stared at one another.
The heavy knocker fell again and again and again. Between the
knocking there was a sound like the roaring of lions. Husband and
wife stared at one another with white faces. Firmin picked up his gun
with trembling hands, and the movement seemed to set his teeth
chattering. They chattered like castanets.
The knocking still went on, and so did the roaring.
It had gone on at least for five minutes, when a slow gleam of
comprehension lightened Madame Firmin's face.
"I believe it's the master's voice," she said.
"The master's voice!" said Firmin, in a hoarse, terrified whisper.
"Yes," said Madame Firmin. And she unlocked the thick door and
opened it a few inches.
The barrier removed, the well-known bellow of the millionaire came
distinctly to their ears. Firmin's courage rushed upon him in full
flood. He clumped across the room, brushed his wife aside, and
trotted to the door of the chateau. He unlocked it, drew the bolts,
and threw it open. On the steps stood the millionaire, Germaine, and
Sonia. Irma stood at the horse's head.
"What the devil have you been doing?" bellowed the millionaire.
"What do you keep me standing in the rain for? Why didn't you let me
"B-b-b-burglars—I thought you were b-b-b-burglars," stammered
"Burglars!" howled the millionaire. "Do I sound like a burglar?"
At the moment he did not; he sounded more like a bull of Bashan. He
bustled past Firmin to the door of the hall,
"Here! What's this locked for?" he bellowed.
"I—I—locked it in case burglars should get in while I was opening
the front door," stammered Firmin.
The millionaire turned the key, opened the door, and went into the
hall. Germaine followed him. She threw off her dripping coat, and
said with some heat: "I can't conceive why you didn't make sure that
there was a train at a quarter to nine. I will not go to Paris to-
night. Nothing shall induce me to take that midnight train!"
"Nonsense!" said the millionaire. "Nonsense—you'll have to go!
Where's that infernal time-table?" He rushed to the table on to which
he had thrown the time-table after looking up the train, snatched it
up. and looked at the cover. "Why, hang it!" he cried. "It's for
"Oh!" cried Germaine, almost in a scream. "It's incredible! It's
one of Jacques' jokes!"
The morning was gloomy, and the police-station with its bare,
white- washed walls—their white expanse was only broken by
notice-boards to which were pinned portraits of criminals with details
of their appearance, their crime, and the reward offered for their
apprehension—with its shabby furniture, and its dingy fireplace,
presented a dismal and sordid appearance entirely in keeping with the
September grey. The inspector sat at his desk, yawning after a night
which had passed without an arrest. He was waiting to be relieved. The
policeman at the door and the two policemen sitting on a bench by the
wall yawned in sympathy.
The silence of the street was broken by the rattle of an uncommonly
noisy motor-car. It stopped before the door of the police-station,
and the eyes of the inspector and his men turned, idly expectant, to
the door of the office.
It opened, and a young man in motor-coat and cap stood on the
He looked round the office with alert eyes, which took in
everything, and said, in a brisk, incisive voice: "I am the Duke of
Charmerace. I am here on behalf of M. Gournay-Martin. Last evening he
received a letter from Arsene Lupin saying he was going to break into
his Paris house this very morning."
At the name of Arsene Lupin the inspector sprang from his chair,
the policemen from their bench. On the instant they were wide awake,
attentive, full of zeal.
"The letter, your Grace!" said the inspector briskly.
The Duke pulled off his glove, drew the letter from the breast-
pocket of his under-coat, and handed it to the inspector.
The inspector glanced through it, and said. "Yes, I know the
handwriting well." Then he read it carefully, and added, "Yes, yes:
it's his usual letter."
"There's no time to be lost," said the Duke quickly. "I ought to
have been here hours ago-hours. I had a break-down. I'm afraid I'm
too late as it is."
"Come along, your Grace-come along, you" said the inspector
The four of them hurried out of the office and down the steps of
the police-station. In the roadway stood a long grey racing-car, caked
with muds—grey mud, brown mud, red mud—from end to end. It looked
as if it had brought samples of the soil of France from many
"Come along; I'll take you in the car. Your men can trot along
beside us," said the Duke to the inspector.
He slipped into the car, the inspector jumped in and took the seat
beside him, and they started. They went slowly, to allow the two
policemen to keep up with them. Indeed, the car could not have made
any great pace, for the tyre of the off hind-wheel was punctured and
In three minutes they came to the Gournay-Martin house, a wide-
fronted mass of undistinguished masonry, in an undistinguished row of
exactly the same pattern. There were no signs that any one was living
in it. Blinds were drawn, shutters were up over all the windows, upper
and lower. No smoke came from any of its chimneys, though indeed it
was full early for that.
Pulling a bunch of keys from his pocket, the Duke ran up the steps.
The inspector followed him. The Duke looked at the bunch, picked out
the latch-key, and fitted it into the lock. It did not open it. He
drew it out and tried another key and another. The door remained
"Let me, your Grace," said the inspector. "I'm more used to it. I
shall be quicker."
The Duke handed the keys to him, and, one after another, the
inspector fitted them into the lock. It was useless. None of them
opened the door.
"They've given me the wrong keys," said the Duke, with some
vexation. "Or no—stay—I see what's happened. The keys have been
"Changed?" said the inspector. "When? Where?"
"Last night at Charmerace," said the Duke. "M. Gournay-Martin
declared that he saw a burglar slip out of one of the windows of the
hall of the chateau, and we found the lock of the bureau in which the
keys were kept broken."
The inspector seized the knocker, and hammered on the door.
"Try that door there," he cried to his men, pointing to a side-door
on the right, the tradesmen's entrance, giving access to the back of
the house. It was locked. There came no sound of movement in the
house in answer to the inspector's knocking.
"Where's the concierge?" he said.
The Duke shrugged his shoulders. "There's a housekeeper, too—a
woman named Victoire," he said. "Let's hope we don't find them with
their throats cut."
"That isn't Lupin's way," said the inspector. "They won't have come
to much harm."
"It's not very likely that they'll be in a position to open doors,"
said the Duke drily.
"Hadn't we better have it broken open and be done with it?"
The inspector hesitated.
"People don't like their doors broken open," he said. "And M.
"Oh, I'll take the responsibility of that," said the Duke.
"Oh, if you say so, your Grace," said the inspector, with a brisk
relief. "Henri, go to Ragoneau, the locksmith in the Rue Theobald.
Bring him here as quickly as ever you can get him."
"Tell him it's a couple of louis if he's here inside of ten
minutes," said the Duke.
The policeman hurried off. The inspector bent down and searched the
steps carefully. He searched the roadway. The Duke lighted a
cigarette and watched him. The house of the millionaire stood next
but one to the corner of a street which ran at right angles to the
one in which it stood, and the corner house was empty. The inspector
searched the road, then he went round the corner. The other policeman
went along the road, searching in the opposite direction. The Duke
leant against the door and smoked on patiently. He showed none of the
weariness of a man who has spent the night in a long and anxious drive
in a rickety motor-car. His eyes were bright and clear; he looked as
fresh as if he had come from his bed after a long night's rest. If he
had not found the South Pole, he had at any rate brought back fine
powers of endurance from his expedition in search of it.
The inspector came back, wearing a disappointed air.
"Have you found anything?" said the Duke.
"Nothing," said the inspector.
He came up the steps and hammered again on the door. No one
answered his knock. There was a clatter of footsteps, and Henri and
the locksmith, a burly, bearded man, his bag of tools slung over his
shoulder, came hurrying up. He was not long getting to work, but it
was net an easy job. The lock was strong. At the end of five minutes
he said that he might spend an hour struggling with the lock itself;
should he cut away a piece of the door round it?
"Cut away," said the Duke.
The locksmith changed his tools, and in less than three minutes he
had cut away a square piece from the door, a square in which the lock
was fixed, and taken it bodily away.
The door opened. The inspector drew his revolver, and entered the
house. The Duke followed him. The policemen drew their revolvers, and
followed the Duke. The big hall was but dimly lighted. One of the
policemen quickly threw back the shutters of the windows and let in
the light. The hall was empty, the furniture in perfect order; there
were no signs of burglary there.
"The concierge?" said the inspector, and his men hurried through
the little door on the right which opened into the concierge's rooms.
In half a minute one of them came out and said: "Gagged and bound, and
his wife too."
"But the rooms which were to be plundered are upstairs," said the
Duke—"the big drawing-rooms on the first floor. Come on; we may be
just in time. The scoundrels may not yet have got away."
He ran quickly up the stairs, followed by the inspector, and
hurried along the corridor to the door of the big drawing-room. He
threw it open, and stopped dead on the threshold. He had arrived too
The room was in disorder. Chairs were overturned, there were empty
spaces on the wall where the finest pictures of the millionaire had
been hung. The window facing the door was wide open. The shutters
were broken; one of them was hanging crookedly from only its bottom
hinge. The top of a ladder rose above the window-sill, and beside it,
astraddle the sill, was an Empire card-table, half inside the room,
half out. On the hearth-rug, before a large tapestry fire- screen,
which masked the wide fireplace, built in imitation of the big, wide
fireplaces of our ancestors, and rose to the level of the
chimney-piece-a magnificent chimney-piece in carved oak-were some
chairs tied together ready to be removed.
The Duke and the inspector ran to the window, and looked down into
the garden. It was empty. At the further end of it, on the other side
of its wall, rose the scaffolding of a house a-building. The burglars
had found every convenience to their hand-a strong ladder, an egress
through the door in the garden wall, and then through the gap formed
by the house in Process of erection, which had rendered them
independent of the narrow passage between the Walls of the gardens,
which debouched into a side-street on the right.
The Duke turned from the window, glanced at the wall opposite,
then, as if something had caught his eye, went quickly to it.
"Look here," he said, and he pointed to the middle of one of the
empty spaces in which a picture had hung.
There, written neatly in blue chalk, were the words:
"This is a job for Guerchard," said the inspector. "But I had
better get an examining magistrate to take the matter in hand first."
And he ran to the telephone.
The Duke opened the folding doors which led into the second
drawing- room. The shutters of the windows were open, and it was plain
that Arsene Lupin had plundered it also of everything that had struck
his fancy. In the gaps between the pictures on the walls was again the
signature "Arsene Lupin."
The inspector was shouting impatiently into the telephone, bidding
a servant wake her master instantly. He did not leave the telephone
till he was sure that she had done so, that her master was actually
awake, and had been informed of the crime. The Duke sat down in an
easy chair and waited for him.
When he had finished telephoning, the inspector began to search the
two rooms for traces of the burglars. He found nothing, not even a
When he had gone through the two rooms he said, "The next thing to
do is to find the house-keeper. She may be sleeping still—she may
not even have heard the noise of the burglars."
"I find all this extremely interesting," said the Duke; and he
followed the inspector out of the room.
The inspector called up the two policemen, who had been freeing the
concierge and going through the rooms on the ground-floor. They did
not then examine any more of the rooms on the first floor to discover
if they also had been plundered. They went straight up to the top of
the house, the servants' quarters.
The inspector called, "Victoire! Victoire!" two or three times; but
there was no answer.
They opened the door of room after room and looked in, the
inspector taking the rooms on the right, the policemen the rooms on
"Here we are," said one of the policemen." This room's been
recently occupied." They looked in, and saw that the bed was unmade.
Plainly Victoire had slept in it.
"Where can she be?" said the Duke.
"Be?" said the inspector. "I expect she's with the burglars—an
"I gather that M. Gournay-Martin had the greatest confidence in
her," said the Duke.
"He'll have less now," said the inspector drily. "It's generally
the confidential ones who let their masters down."
The inspector and his men set about a thorough search of the house.
They found the other rooms undisturbed. In half an hour they had
established the fact that the burglars had confined their attention
to the two drawing-rooms. They found no traces of them; and they did
not find Victoire. The concierge could throw no light on her
disappearance. He and his wife had been taken by surprise in their
sleep and in the dark.
They had been gagged and bound, they declared, without so much as
having set eyes on their assailants. The Duke and the inspector came
back to the plundered drawing-room.
The inspector looked at his watch and went to the telephone.
"I must let the Prefecture know," he said.
"Be sure you ask them to send Guerchard," said the Duke.
"Guerchard?" said the inspector doubtfully.
"M. Formery, the examining magistrate, does not get on very well
"What sort of a man is M. Formery? Is he capable?" said the Duke.
"Oh, yes—yes. He's very capable," said the inspector quickly. "But
he doesn't have very good luck."
"M. Gournay-Martin particularly asked me to send for Guerchard if I
arrived too late, and found the burglary already committed," said the
Duke. "It seems that there is war to the knife between Guerchard and
this Arsene Lupin. In that case Guerchard will leave no stone unturned
to catch the rascal and recover the stolen treasures. M.
Gournay-Martin felt that Guerchard was the man for this piece of work
very strongly indeed."
"Very good, your Grace," said the inspector. And he rang up the
Prefecture of Police.
The Duke heard him report the crime and ask that Guerchard should
be sent. The official in charge at the moment seemed to make some
The Duke sprang to his feet, and said in an anxious tone, "Perhaps
I'd better speak to him myself,"
He took his place at the telephone and said, "I am the Duke of
Charmerace. M. Gournay-Martin begged me to secure the services of M.
Guerchard. He laid the greatest stress on my securing them, if on
reaching Paris I found that the crime had already been committed."
The official at the other end of the line hesitated. He did not
refuse on the instant as he had refused the inspector. It may be that
he reflected that M. Gournay-Martin was a millionaire and a man of
influence; that the Duke of Charmerace was a Duke; that he, at any
rate, had nothing whatever to gain by running counter to their wishes.
He said that Chief-Inspector Guerchard was not at the Prefecture, that
he was off duty; that he would send down two detectives, who were on
duty, at once, and summon Chief-Inspector Guerchard with all speed.
The Duke thanked him and rang off.
"That's all right," he said cheerfully, turning to the inspector.
"What time will M. Formery be here?"
"Well, I don't expect him for another hour," said the inspector.
"He won't come till he's had his breakfast. He always makes a good
breakfast before setting out to start an inquiry, lest he shouldn't
find time to make one after he's begun it."
"Breakfast—breakfast—that's a great idea," said the Duke. "Now
you come to remind me, I'm absolutely famished. I got some supper on
my way late last night; but I've had nothing since. I suppose nothing
interesting will happen till M. Formery comes; and I may as well get
some food. But I don't want to leave the house. I think I'll see what
the concierge can do for me."
So saying, he went downstairs and interviewed the concierge. The
concierge seemed to be still doubtful whether he was standing on his
head or his heels, but he undertook to supply the needs of the Duke.
The Duke gave him a louis, and he hurried off to get food from a
The Duke went upstairs to the bathroom and refreshed himself with a
cold bath. By the time he had bathed and dressed the concierge had a
meal ready for him in the dining-room. He ate it with the heartiest
appetite. Then he sent out for a barber and was shaved.
He then repaired to the pillaged drawing-room, disposed himself in
the most restful attitude on a sofa, and lighted an excellent cigar.
In the middle of it the inspector came to him. He was not wearing a
very cheerful air; and he told the Duke that he had found no clue to
the perpetrators of the crime, though M. Dieusy and M. Bonavent, the
detectives from the Prefecture of Police, had joined him in the
The Duke was condoling with him on this failure when they heard a
knocking at the front door, and then voices on the stairs.
"Ah! Here is M. Formery!" said the inspector cheerfully. "Now we
can get on."
The examining magistrate came into the room. He was a plump and
pink little man, with very bright eyes. His bristly hair stood up
straight all over his head, giving it the appearance of a broad,
dapple-grey clothes-brush. He appeared to be of the opinion that
Nature had given the world the toothbrush as a model of what a
moustache should be; and his own was clipped to that pattern.
"The Duke of Charmerace, M. Formery," said the inspector.
The little man bowed and said, "Charmed, charmed to make your
acquaintance, your Grace—though the occasion—the occasion is
somewhat painful. The treasures of M. Gournay-Martin are known to all
the world. France will deplore his losses." He paused, and added
hastily, "But we shall recover them—we shall recover them."
The Duke rose, bowed, and protested his pleasure at making the
acquaintance of M. Formery.
"Is this the scene of the robbery, inspector?" said M. Formery; and
he rubbed his hands together with a very cheerful air.
"Yes, sir," said the inspector. "These two rooms seem to be the
only ones touched, though of course we can't tell till M.
Gournay-Martin arrives. Jewels may have been stolen from the
"I fear that M. Gournay-Martin won't be of much help for some
days," said the Duke. "When I left him he was nearly distracted; and
he won't be any better after a night journey to Paris from Charmerace.
But probably these are the only two rooms touched, for in them M.
Gournay-Martin had gathered together the gems of his collection. Over
the doors hung some pieces of Flemish tapestry—marvels—the
composition admirable—the colouring delightful."
"It is easy to see that your Grace was very fond of them," said M.
"I should think so," said the Duke. "I looked on them as already
belonging to me, for my father-in-law was going to give them to me as
a wedding present."
"A great loss—a great loss. But we will recover them, sooner or
later, you can rest assured of it. I hope you have touched nothing in
this room. If anything has been moved it may put me off the scent
altogether. Let me have the details, inspector."
The inspector reported the arrival of the Duke at the
police-station with Arsene Lupin's letter to M. Gournay-Martin; the
discovery that the keys had been changed and would not open the door
of the house; the opening of it by the locksmith; the discovery of the
concierge and his wife gagged and bound.
"Probably accomplices," said M. Formery.
"Does Lupin always work with accomplices?" said the Duke. "Pardon
my ignorance—but I've been out of France for so long—before he
attained to this height of notoriety."
"Lupin—why Lupin?" said M. Formery sharply.
"Why, there is the letter from Lupin which my future father-in-law
received last night; its arrival was followed by the theft of his two
swiftest motor-cars; and then, these signatures on the wall here,"
said the Duke in some surprise at the question.
"Lupin! Lupin! Everybody has Lupin on the brain!" said M. Formery
impatiently. "I'm sick of hearing his name. This letter and these
signatures are just as likely to be forgeries as not."
"I wonder if Guerchard will take that view," said the Duke.
"Guerchard? Surely we're not going to be cluttered up with
Guerchard. He has Lupin on the brain worse than any one else."
"But M. Gournay-Martin particularly asked me to send for Guerchard
if I arrived too late to prevent the burglary. He would never forgive
me if I had neglected his request: so I telephoned for him— to the
Prefecture of Police," said the Duke.
"Oh, well, if you've already telephoned for him. But it was
unnecessary—absolutely unnecessary," said M. Formery sharply.
"I didn't know," said the Duke politely.
"Oh, there was no harm in it—it doesn't matter," said M. Formery
in a discontented tone with a discontented air.
He walked slowly round the room, paused by the windows, looked at
the ladder, and scanned the garden:
"Arsene Lupin," he said scornfully. "Arsene Lupin doesn't leave
traces all over the place. There's nothing but traces. Are we going
to have that silly Lupin joke all over again?"
"I think, sir, that this time joke is the word, for this is a
burglary pure and simple," said the inspector.
"Yes, it's plain as daylight," said M. Formery "The burglars came
in by this window, and they went out by it."
He crossed the room to a tall safe which stood before the unused
door. The safe was covered with velvet, and velvet curtains hung
before its door. He drew the curtains, and tried the handle of the
door of the safe. It did not turn; the safe was locked.
"As far as I can see, they haven't touched this," said M. Formery.
"Thank goodness for that," said the Duke. "I believe, or at least
my fiancee does, that M. Gournay-Martin keeps the most precious thing
in his collection in that safe—the coronet."
"What! the famous coronet of the Princesse de Lamballe?" said M.
"Yes," said the Duke.
"But according to your report, inspector, the letter signed 'Lupin'
announced that he was going to steal the coronet also."
"It did—in so many words," said the Duke.
"Well, here is a further proof that we're not dealing with Lupin.
That rascal would certainly have put his threat into execution, M.
Formery," said the inspector.
"Who's in charge of the house?" said M. Formery.
"The concierge, his wife, and a housekeeper—a woman named
Victoire," said the inspector.
"I'll see to the concierge and his wife presently. I've sent one of
your men round for their dossier. When I get it I'll question them.
You found them gagged and bound in their bedroom?"
"Yes, M. Formery; and always this imitation of Lupin—a yellow gag,
blue cords, and the motto, 'I take, therefore I am,' on a scrap of
cardboard—his usual bag of tricks."
"Then once again they're going to touch us up in the papers. It's
any odds on it," said M. Formery gloomily. "Where's the housekeeper?
I should like to see her."
"The fact is, we don't know where she is," said the inspector.
"You don't know where she is?" said M. Formery.
"We can't find her anywhere," said the inspector.
"That's excellent, excellent. We've found the accomplice," said M.
Formery with lively delight; and he rubbed his hands together. "At
least, we haven't found her, but we know her."
"I don't think that's the case," said the Duke. "At least, my
future father-in-law and my fiancee had both of them the greatest
confidence in her. Yesterday she telephoned to us at the Chateau de
Charmerace. All the jewels were left in her charge, and the wedding
presents as they were sent in."
"And these jewels and wedding presents—have they been stolen too?"
said M. Formery.
"They don't seem to have been touched," said the Duke, "though of
course we can't tell till M. Gournay-Martin arrives. As far as I can
see, the burglars have only touched these two drawing-rooms."
"That's very annoying," said M. Formery.
"I don't find it so," said the Duke, smiling.
"I was looking at it from the professional point of view," said M.
Formery. He turned to the inspector and added, "You can't have
searched thoroughly. This housekeeper must be somewhere about—if
she's really trustworthy. Have you looked in every room in the
"In every room—under every bed—in every corner and every
cupboard," said the inspector.
"Bother!" said M. Formery. "Are there no scraps of torn clothes, no
blood-stains, no traces of murder, nothing of interest?"
"Nothing!" said the inspector.
"But this is very regrettable," said M. Formery. "Where did she
sleep? Was her bed unmade?"
"Her room is at the top of the house," said the inspector. "The bed
had been slept in, but she does not appear to have taken away any of
"Extraordinary! This is beginning to look a very complicated
business," said M. Formery gravely.
"Perhaps Guerchard will be able to throw a little more light on
it," said the Duke.
M. Formery frowned and said, "Yes, yes. Guerchard is a good
assistant in a business like this. A little visionary, a little
fanciful—wrong-headed, in fact; but, after all, he IS Guerchard.
Only, since Lupin is his bugbear, he's bound to find some means of
muddling us up with that wretched animal. You're going to see Lupin
mixed up with all this to a dead certainty, your Grace."
The Duke looked at the signatures on the wall. "It seems to me that
he is pretty well mixed up with it already," he said quietly.
"Believe me, your Grace, in a criminal affair it is, above all
things, necessary to distrust appearances. I am growing more and more
confident that some ordinary burglars have committed this crime and
are trying to put us off the scent by diverting our attention to
The Duke stooped down carelessly and picked up a book which had
fallen from a table.
"Excuse me, but please—please—do not touch anything," said M.
"Why, this is odd," said the Duke, staring at the floor.
"What is odd?" said M. Formery.
"Well, this book looks as if it had been knocked off the table by
one of the burglars. And look here; here's a footprint under it—a
footprint on the carpet," said the Duke.
M. Formery and the inspector came quickly to the spot. There, where
the book had fallen, plainly imprinted on the carpet, was a white
footprint. M. Formery and the inspector stared at it.
"It looks like plaster. How did plaster get here?" said M. Formery,
frowning at it.
"Well, suppose the robbers came from the garden," said the Duke.
"Of course they came from the garden, your Grace. Where else should
they come from?" said M. Formery, with a touch of impatience in his
"Well, at the end of the garden they're building a house," said the
"Of course, of course," said M. Formery, taking him up quickly.
"The burglars came here with their boots covered with plaster. They've
swept away all the other marks of their feet from the carpet; but
whoever did the sweeping was too slack to lift up that book and sweep
under it. This footprint, however, is not of great importance, though
it is corroborative of all the other evidence we have that they came
and went by the garden. There's the ladder, and that table half out of
the window. Still, this footprint may turn out useful, after all. You
had better take the measurements of it, inspector. Here's a foot-rule
for you. I make a point of carrying this foot- rule about with me,
your Grace. You would be surprised to learn how often it has come in
He took a little ivory foot-rule from his waist-coat pocket, and
gave it to the inspector, who fell on his knees and measured the
footprint with the greatest care.
"I must take a careful look at that house they're building. I shall
find a good many traces there, to a dead certainty," said M. Formery.
The inspector entered the measurements of the footprint in his
note- book. There came the sound of a knocking at the front door.
"I shall find footprints of exactly the same dimensions as this one
at the foot of some heap of plaster beside that house," said M.
Former; with an air of profound conviction, pointing through the
window to the house building beyond the garden.
A policeman opened the door of the drawing-room and saluted.
"If you please, sir, the servants have arrived from Charmerace," he
"Let them wait in the kitchen and the servants' offices," said M.
Formery. He stood silent, buried in profound meditation, for a couple
of minutes. Then he turned to the Duke and said, "What was that you
said about a theft of motor-cars at Charmerace?"
"When he received the letter from Arsene Lupin, M. Gournay-Martin
decided to start for Paris at once," said the Duke. "But when we sent
for the cars we found that they had just been stolen. M.
Gournay-Martin's chauffeur and another servant were in the garage
gagged and bound. Only an old car, a hundred horse-power Mercrac, was
left. I drove it to Paris, leaving M. Gournay-Martin and his family to
come on by train."
"Very important—very important indeed," said M. Formery. He
thought for a moment, and then added. "Were the motor-cars the only
things stolen? Were there no other thefts?"
"Well, as a matter of fact, there was another theft, or rather an
attempt at theft," said the Duke with some hesitation. "The rogues
who stole the motor-cars presented themselves at the chateau under
the name of Charolais—a father and three sons—on the pretext of
buying the hundred-horse-power Mercrac. M. Gournay-Martin had
advertised it for sale in the Rennes Advertiser. They were waiting in
the big hall of the chateau, which the family uses as the chief
living-room, for the return of M. Gournay-Martin. He came; and as
they left the hall one of them attempted to steal a pendant set with
pearls which I had given to Mademoiselle Gournay-Martin half an hour
before. I caught him in the act and saved the pendant."
"Good! good! Wait—we have one of the gang—wait till I question
him," said M. Formery, rubbing his hands; and his eyes sparkled with
"Well, no; I'm afraid we haven't," said the Duke in an apologetic
"What! We haven't? Has he escaped from the police? Oh, those
country police!" cried M. Formery.
"No; I didn't charge him with the theft," said the Duke.
"You didn't charge him with the theft?" cried M. Formery,
"No; he was very young and he begged so hard. I had the pendant. I
let him go," said the Duke.
"Oh, your Grace, your Grace! Your duty to society!" cried M.
"Yes, it does seem to have been rather weak," said the Duke; "but
there you are. It's no good crying over spilt milk."
M. Formery folded his arms and walked, frowning, backwards and
forwards across the room.
He stopped, raised his hand with a gesture commanding attention,
and said, "I have no hesitation in saying that there is a
connection—an intimate connection—between the thefts at Charmerace
and this burglary!"
The Duke and the inspector gazed at him with respectful eyes—at
least, the eyes of the inspector were respectful; the Duke's eyes
"I am gathering up the threads," said M. Formery. "Inspector, bring
up the concierge and his wife. I will question them on the scene of
the crime. Their dossier should be here. If it is, bring it up with
them; if not, no matter; bring them up without it."
The inspector left the drawing-room. M. Formery plunged at once
into frowning meditation.
"I find all this extremely interesting," said the Duke.
"Charmed! Charmed!" said M. Formery, waving his hand with an
absent- minded air.
The inspector entered the drawing-room followed by the concierge
and his wife. He handed a paper to M. Formery. The concierge, a
bearded man of about sixty, and his wife, a somewhat bearded woman of
about fifty-five, stared at M. Formery with fascinated, terrified
eyes. He sat down in a chair, crossed his legs, read the paper
through, and then scrutinized them keenly.
"Well, have you recovered from your adventure?" he said.
"Oh, yes, sir," said the concierge. "They hustled us a bit, but
they did not really hurt us."
"Nothing to speak of, that is," said his wife. "But all the same,
it's a disgraceful thing that an honest woman can't sleep in peace in
her bed of a night without being disturbed by rascals like that. And
if the police did their duty things like this wouldn't happen. And I
don't care who hears me say it."
"You say that you were taken by surprise in your sleep?" said M.
Formery. "You say you saw nothing, and heard nothing?"
"There was no time to see anything or hear anything. They trussed
us up like greased lightning," said the concierge.
"But the gag was the worst," said the wife. "To lie there and not
be able to tell the rascals what I thought about them!"
"Didn't you hear the noise of footsteps in the garden?" said M.
"One can't hear anything that happens in the garden from our
bedroom," said the concierge.
"Even the night when Mlle. Germaine's great Dane barked from twelve
o'clock till seven in the morning, all the household was kept awake
except us; but bless you, sir, we slept like tops," said his wife
"If they sleep like that it seems rather a waste of time to have
gagged them," whispered the Duke to the inspector.
The inspector grinned, and whispered scornfully, "Oh, them common
folks; they do sleep like that, your Grace."
"Didn't you hear any noise at the front door?" said M. Formery.
"No, we heard no noise at the door," said the concierge.
"Then you heard no noise at all the whole night?" said M. Formery.
"Oh, yes, sir, we heard noise enough after we'd been gagged," said
"Now, this is important," said M. Formery. "What kind of a noise
"Well, it was a bumping kind of noise," said the concierge. "And
there was a noise of footsteps, walking about the room."
"What room? Where did these noises come from?" said M. Formery.
"From the room over our heads—the big drawing-room," said the
"Didn't you hear any noise of a struggle, as if somebody was being
dragged about—no screaming or crying?" said M. Formery.
The concierge and his wife looked at one another with inquiring
"No, I didn't," said the concierge.
"Neither did I," said his wife.
M. Formery paused. Then he said, "How long have you been in the
service of M. Gournay-Martin?"
"A little more than a year," said the concierge.
M. Formery looked at the paper in his hand, frowned, and said
severely, "I see you've been convicted twice, my man."
"Yes, sir, but—"
"My husband's an honest man, sir—perfectly honest," broke in his
wife. "You've only to ask M. Gournay-Martin; he'll—"
"Be so good as to keep quiet, my good woman," said M. Formery; and,
turning to her husband, he went on: "At your first conviction you
were sentenced to a day's imprisonment with costs; at your second
conviction you got three days' imprisonment."
"I'm not going to deny it, sir," said the concierge; "but it was an
"Honourable?" said M. Formery.
"The first time, I was a gentleman's servant, and I got a day's
imprisonment for crying, 'Hurrah for the General Strike!'—on the
first of May."
"You were a valet? In whose service?" said M. Formery.
"In the service of M. Genlis, the Socialist leader."
"And your second conviction?" said M. Formery.
"It was for having cried in the porch of Ste. Clotilde, 'Down with
the cows!'—meaning the police, sir," said the concierge.
"And were you in the service of M. Genlis then?" said M. Formery.
"No, sir; I was in the service of M. Bussy-Rabutin, the Royalist
"You don't seem to have very well-defined political convictions,"
said M. Formery.
"Oh, yes, sir, I have," the concierge protested. "I'm always
devoted to my masters; and I have the same opinions that they
"Very good; you can go," said M. Formery.
The concierge and his wife left the room, looking as if they did
not quite know whether to feel relieved or not.
"Those two fools are telling the exact truth, unless I'm very much
mistaken," said M. Formery.
"They look honest enough people," said the Duke.
"Well, now to examine the rest of the house," said M. Formery.
"I'll come with you, if I may," said the Duke.
"By all means, by all means," said M. Formery.
"I find it all so interesting," said the Duke,
Leaving a policeman on guard at the door of the drawing-room M.
Formery, the Duke, and the inspector set out on their tour of
inspection. It was a long business, for M. Formery examined every
room with the most scrupulous care—with more care, indeed, than he
had displayed in his examination of the drawing-rooms. In particular
he lingered long in the bedroom of Victoire, discussing the
possibilities of her having been murdered and carried away by the
burglars along with their booty. He seemed, if anything, disappointed
at finding no blood-stains, but to find real consolation in the
thought that she might have been strangled. He found the inspector in
entire agreement with every theory he enunciated, and he grew more and
more disposed to regard him as a zealous and trustworthy officer. Also
he was not at all displeased at enjoying this opportunity of
impressing the Duke with his powers of analysis and synthesis. He was
unaware that, as a rule, the Duke's eyes did not usually twinkle as
they twinkled during this solemn and deliberate progress through the
house of M. Gournay- Martin. M. Formery had so exactly the air of a
sleuthhound; and he was even noisier.
Having made this thorough examination of the house, M. Formery went
out into the garden and set about examining that. There were
footprints on the turf about the foot of the ladder, for the grass
was close-clipped, and the rain had penetrated and softened the soil;
but there were hardly as many footprints as might have been expected,
seeing that the burglars must have made many journeys in the course of
robbing the drawing-rooms of so many objects of art, some of them of
considerable weight. The footprints led to a path of hard gravel; and
M. Formery led the way down it, out of the door in the wall at the
bottom of the garden, and into the space round the house which was
As M. Formery had divined, there was a heap, or, to be exact, there
were several heaps of plaster about the bottom of the scaffolding.
Unfortunately, there were also hundreds of footprints. M. Formery
looked at them with longing eyes; but he did not suggest that the
inspector should hunt about for a set of footprints of the size of
the one he had so carefully measured on the drawing-room carpet.
While they were examining the ground round the half-built house a
man came briskly down the stairs from the second floor of the house
of M. Gournay-Martin. He was an ordinary-looking man, almost
insignificant, of between forty and fifty, and of rather more than
middle height. He had an ordinary, rather shapeless mouth, an
ordinary nose, an ordinary chin, an ordinary forehead, rather low,
and ordinary ears. He was wearing an ordinary top-hat, by no means
new. His clothes were the ordinary clothes of a fairly well-to-do
citizen; and his boots had been chosen less to set off any
slenderness his feet might possess than for their comfortable
roominess. Only his eyes relieved his face from insignificance. They
were extraordinarily alert eyes, producing in those on whom they
rested the somewhat uncomfortable impression that the depths of their
souls were being penetrated. He was the famous Chief-Inspector
Guerchard, head of the Detective Department of the Prefecture of
Police, and sworn foe of Arsene Lupin.
The policeman at the door of the drawing-room saluted him briskly.
He was a fine, upstanding, red-faced young fellow, adorned by a rich
black moustache of extraordinary fierceness.
"Shall I go and inform M. Formery that you have come, M.
Guerchard?" he said.
"No, no; there's no need to take the trouble," said Guerchard in a
gentle, rather husky voice. "Don't bother any one about me—I'm of no
"Oh, come, M. Guerchard," protested the policeman.
"Of no importance," said M. Guerchard decisively. "For the present,
M. Formery is everything. I'm only an assistant."
He stepped into the drawing-room and stood looking about it,
curiously still. It was almost as if the whole of his being was
concentrated in the act of seeing—as if all the other functions of
his mind and body were in suspension.
"M. Formery and the inspector have just been up to examine the
housekeeper's room. It's right at the top of the house—on the second
floor. You take the servants' staircase. Then it's right at the end of
the passage on the left. Would you like me to take you up to it, sir?"
said the policeman eagerly. His heart was in his work.
"Thank you, I know where it is—I've just come from it," said
A grin of admiration widened the already wide mouth of the
policeman, and showed a row of very white, able-looking teeth.
"Ah, M. Guerchard!" he said, "you're cleverer than all the
examining magistrates in Paris put together!"
"You ought not to say that, my good fellow. I can't prevent you
thinking it, of course; but you ought not to say it," said Guerchard
with husky gentleness; and the faintest smile played round the
corners of his mouth.
He walked slowly to the window, and the policeman walked with him.
"Have you noticed this, sir?" said the policeman, taking hold of
the top of the ladder with a powerful hand. "It's probable that the
burglars came in and went away by this ladder."
"Thank you," said Guerchard.
"They have even left this card-table on the window-sill," said the
policeman; and he patted the card-table with his other powerful hand.
"Thank you, thank you," said Guerchard.
"They don't think it's Lupin's work at all," said the policeman.
"They think that Lupin's letter announcing the burglary and these
signatures on the walls are only a ruse."
"Is that so?" said Guerchard.
"Is there any way I can help you, sir?" said policeman.
"Yes," said Guerchard. "Take up your post outside that door and
admit no one but M. Formery, the inspector, Bonavent, or Dieusy,
without consulting me." And he pointed to the drawing-room door.
"Shan't I admit the Duke of Charmerace? He's taking a great
interest in this affair," said the policeman.
"The Duke of Charmerace? Oh, yes—admit the Duke of Charmerace,"
The policeman went to his post of responsibility, a proud man.
Hardly had the door closed behind him when Guerchard was all
activity—activity and eyes. He examined the ladder, the gaps on the
wall from which the pictures had been taken, the signatures of Arsene
Lupin. The very next thing he did was to pick up the book which the
Duke had set on the top of the footprint again, to preserve it; and he
measured, pacing it, the distance between the footprint and the
The result of this measuring did not appear to cause him any
satisfaction, for he frowned, measured the distance again, and then
stared out of the window with a perplexed air, thinking hard. It was
curious that, when he concentrated himself on a process of reasoning,
his eves seemed to lose something of their sharp brightness and grew a
At last he seemed to come to some conclusion. He turned away from
the window, drew a small magnifying-glass from his pocket, dropped on
his hands and knees, and began to examine the surface of the carpet
with the most minute care.
He examined a space of it nearly six feet square, stopped, and
gazed round the room. His eyes rested on the fireplace, which he could
see under the bottom of the big tapestried fire-screen which was
raised on legs about a foot high, fitted with big casters. His eyes
filled with interest; without rising, he crawled quickly across the
room, peeped round the edge of the screen and rose, smiling.
He went on to the further drawing-room and made the same careful
examination of it, again examining a part of the surface of the
carpet with his magnifying-glass. He came back to the window to which
the ladder had been raised and examined very carefully the broken
shutter. He whistled softly to himself, lighted a cigarette, and leant
against the side of the window. He looked out of it, with dull eyes
which saw nothing, the while his mind worked upon the facts he had
He had stood there plunged in reflection for perhaps ten minutes,
when there came a sound of voices and footsteps on the stairs. He
awoke from his absorption, seemed to prick his ears, then slipped a
leg over the window-ledge, and disappeared from sight down the
The door opened, and in came M. Formery, the Duke, and the
inspector. M. Formery looked round the room with eyes which seemed to
expect to meet a familiar sight, then walked to the other drawing-room
and looked round that. He turned to the policeman, who had stepped
inside the drawing-room, and said sharply, "M. Guerchard is not here."
"I left him here," said the policeman. "He must have disappeared.
He's a wonder."
"Of course," said M. Formery. "He has gone down the ladder to
examine that house they're building. He's just following in our
tracks and doing all over again the work we've already done. He might
have saved himself the trouble. We could have told him all he wants to
know. But there! He very likely would not be satisfied till he had
seen everything for himself."
"He may see something which we have missed," said the Duke.
M. Formery frowned, and said sharply "That's hardly likely. I don't
think that your Grace realizes to what a perfection constant practice
brings one's power of observation. The inspector and I will cheerfully
eat anything we've missed—won't we, inspector?" And he laughed
heartily at his joke.
"It might always prove a large mouthful," said the Duke with an
M. Formery assumed his air of profound reflection, and walked a few
steps up and down the room, frowning:
"The more I think about it," he said, "the clearer it grows that we
have disposed of the Lupin theory. This is the work of far less
expert rogues than Lupin. What do you think, inspector?"
"Yes; I think you have disposed of that theory, sir," said the
inspector with ready acquiescence.
"All the same, I'd wager anything that we haven't disposed of it to
the satisfaction of Guerchard," said M. Formery.
"Then he must be very hard to satisfy," said the Duke.
"Oh, in any other matter he's open to reason," said M. Formery;
"but Lupin is his fixed idea; it's an obsession—almost a mania."
"But yet he never catches him," said the Duke.
"No; and he never will. His very obsession by Lupin hampers him. It
cramps his mind and hinders its working," said M. Formery.
He resumed his meditative pacing, stopped again, and said:
"But considering everything, especially the absence of any traces
of violence, combined with her entire disappearance, I have come to
another conclusion. Victoire is the key to the mystery. She is the
accomplice. She never slept in her bed. She unmade it to put us off
the scent. That, at any rate, is something gained, to have found the
accomplice. We shall have this good news, at least, to tell M,
Gournay-Martin on his arrival."
"Do you really think that she's the accomplice?" said the Duke.
"I'm dead sure of it," said M. Formery. "We will go up to her room
and make another thorough examination of it."
Guerchard's head popped up above the window-sill:
"My dear M. Formery," he said, "I beg that you will not take the
M. Formery's mouth opened: "What! You, Guerchard?" he stammered.
"Myself," said Guerchard; and he came to the top of the ladder and
slipped lightly over the window-sill into the room.
He shook hands with M. Formery and nodded to the inspector. Then he
looked at the Duke with an air of inquiry.
"Let me introduce you," said M. Formery. "Chief-Inspector
Guerchard, head of the Detective Department—the Duke of Charmerace."
The Duke shook hands with Guerchard, saying, "I'm delighted to make
your acquaintance, M. Guerchard. I've been expecting your coming with
the greatest interest. Indeed it was I who begged the officials at the
Prefecture of Police to put this case in your hands. I insisted on
"What were you doing on that ladder?" said M. Formery, giving
Guerchard no time to reply to the Duke.
"I was listening," said Guerchard simply—"listening. I like to
hear people talk when I'm engaged on a case. It's a distraction—and
it helps. I really must congratulate you, my dear M. Formery, on the
admirable manner in which you have conducted this inquiry."
M. Formery bowed, and regarded him with a touch of suspicion.
"There are one or two minor points on which we do not agree, but on
the whole your method has been admirable," said Guerchard.
"Well, about Victoire," said M. Formery. "You're quite sure that an
examination, a more thorough examination, of her room, is
"Yes, I think so," said Guerchard. "I have just looked at it
The door opened, and in came Bonavent, one of the detectives who
had come earlier from the Prefecture. In his hand he carried a scrap
He saluted Guerchard, and said to M. Formery, "I have just found
this scrap of cloth on the edge of the well at the bottom of the
garden. The concierge's wife tells me that it has been torn from
"I feared it," said M. Formery, taking the scrap of cloth from Mm.
"I feared foul play. We must go to the well at once, send some one
down it, or have it dragged."
He was moving hastily to the door, when Guerchard said, in his
husky, gentle voice, "I don't think there is any need to look for
Victoire in the well."
"But this scrap of cloth," said M. Formery, holding it out to him.
"Yes, yes, that scrap of cloth," said Guerchard. And, turning to
the Duke, he added, "Do you know if there's a dog or cat in the house,
your Grace? I suppose that, as the fiance of Mademoiselle Gournay-
Martin, you are familiar with the house?"
"What on earth—" said M. Formery.
"Excuse me," interrupted Guerchard. "But this is important—very
"Yes, there is a cat," said the Duke. "I've seen a cat at the door
of the concierge's rooms."
"It must have been that cat which took this scrap of cloth to the
edge of the well," said Guerchard gravely.
"This is ridiculous—preposterous!" cried M. Formery, beginning to
flush. "Here we're dealing with a most serious crime—a murder—the
murder of Victoire—and you talk about cats!"
"Victoire has not been murdered," said Guerchard; and his husky
voice was gentler than ever, only just audible.
"But we don't know that—we know nothing of the kind," said M.
"I do," said Guerchard.
"You?" said M. Formery.
"Yes," said Guerchard.
"Then how do you explain her disappearance?"
"If she had disappeared I shouldn't explain it," said Guerchard.
"But since she has disappeared?" cried M. Formery, in a tone of
"She hasn't," said Guerchard.
"You know nothing about it!" cried M. Formery, losing his temper.
"Yes, I do," said Guerchard, with the same gentleness.
"Come, do you mean to say that you know where she is?" cried M.
"Certainly," said Guerchard.
"Do you mean to tell us straight out that you've seen her?" cried
"Oh, yes; I've seen her," said Guerchard.
"You've seen her—when?" cried M. Formery.
Guerchard paused to consider. Then he said gently:
"It must have been between four and five minutes ago."
"But hang it all, you haven't been out of this room!" cried M.
"No, I haven't," said Guerchard.
"And you've seen her?" cried M. Formery.
"Yes," said Guerchard, raising his voice a little.
"Well, why the devil don't you tell us where she is? Tell us!"
cried M. Formery, purple with exasperation.
"But you won't let me get a word out of my mouth," protested
Guerchard with aggravating gentleness.
"Well, speak!" cried M. Formery; and he sank gasping on to a chair.
"Ah, well, she's here," said Guerchard.
"Here! How did she GET here?" said M. Formery.
"On a mattress," said Guerchard.
M. Formery sat upright, almost beside himself, glaring furiously at
"What do you stand there pulling all our legs for?" he almost
"Look here," said Guerchard.
He walked across the room to the fireplace, pushed the chairs which
stood bound together on the hearth-rug to one side of the fireplace,
and ran the heavy fire-screen on its casters to the other side of it,
revealing to their gaze the wide, old-fashioned fireplace itself. The
iron brazier which held the coals had been moved into the corner, and
a mattress lay on the floor of the fireplace. On the mattress lay the
figure of a big, middle-aged woman, half-dressed. There was a yellow
gag in her mouth; and her hands and feet were bound together with blue
"She is sleeping soundly," said Guerchard. He stooped and picked up
a handkerchief, and smelt it. "There's the handkerchief they
chloroformed her with. It still smells of chloroform."
They stared at him and the sleeping woman.
"Lend a hand, inspector," he said. "And you too, Bonavent. She
looks a good weight."
The three of them raised the mattress, and carried it and the
sleeping woman to a broad couch, and laid them on it. They staggered
under their burden, for truly Victoire was a good weight.
M. Formery rose, with recovered breath, but with his face an even
richer purple. His eyes were rolling in his head, as if they were not
under proper control.
He turned on the inspector and cried savagely, "You never examined
the fireplace, inspector!"
"No, sir," said the downcast inspector.
"It was unpardonable—absolutely unpardonable!" cried M. Formery.
"How is one to work with subordinates like this?"
"It was an oversight," said Guerchard.
M. Formery turned to him and said, "You must admit that it was
materially impossible for me to see her."
"It was possible if you went down on all fours," said Guerchard.
"On all fours?" said M. Formery.
"Yes; on all fours you could see her heels sticking out beyond the
mattress," said Guerchard simply.
M. Formery shrugged his shoulders: "That screen looked as if it had
stood there since the beginning of the summer," he said.
"The first thing, when you're dealing with Lupin, is to distrust
appearances," said Guerchard.
"Lupin!" cried M. Formery hotly. Then he bit his lip and was
He walked to the side of the couch and looked down on the sleeping
Victoire, frowning: "This upsets everything," he said. "With these
new conditions, I've got to begin all over again, to find a new
explanation of the affair. For the moment—for the moment, I'm thrown
completely off the track. And you, Guerchard?"
"Oh, well," said Guerchard, "I have an idea or two about the matter
"Do you really mean to say that it hasn't thrown you off the track
too?" said M. Formery, with a touch of incredulity in his tone.
"Well, no—not exactly," said Guerchard. "I wasn't on that track,
"No, of course not—of course not. You were on the track of Lupin,"
said M. Formery; and his contemptuous smile was tinged with malice.
The Duke looked from one to the other of them with curious,
searching eyes: "I find all this so interesting," he said.
"We do not take much notice of these checks; they do not depress us
for a moment," said M. Formery, with some return of his old
grandiloquence. "We pause hardly for an instant; then we begin to
"It's perfectly splendid of you," said the Duke, and his limpid
eyes rested on M. Formery's self-satisfied face in a really
affectionate gaze; they might almost be said to caress it.
Guerchard looked out of the window at a man who was carrying a hod-
full of bricks up one of the ladders set against the scaffolding of
the building house. Something in this honest workman's simple task
seemed to amuse him, for he smiled.
Only the inspector, thinking of the unexamined fireplace, looked
"We shan't get anything out of this woman till she wakes," said M.
Formery, "When she does, I shall question her closely and fully. In
the meantime, she may as well be carried up to her bedroom to sleep
off the effects of the chloroform."
Guerchard turned quickly: "Not her own bedroom, I think," he said
"Certainly not—of course, not her own bedroom," said M. Formery
"And I think an officer at the door of whatever bedroom she does
sleep in," said Guerchard.
"Undoubtedly—most necessary," said M. Formery gravely. "See to it,
inspector. You can take her away."
The inspector called in a couple of policemen, and with their aid
he and Bonavent raised the sleeping woman, a man at each corner of the
mattress, and bore her from the room.
"And now to reconstruct," said M. Formery; and he folded his arms
and plunged into profound reflection.
The Duke and Guerchard watched him in silence.
In carrying out Victoire, the inspector had left the door of the
drawing-room open. After he had watched M. Formery reflect for two
minutes, Guerchard faded—to use an expressive Americanism—through
it. The Duke felt in the breast-pocket of his coat, murmured softly,
"My cigarettes," and followed him.
He caught up Guerchard on the stairs and said, "I will come with
you, if I may, M. Guerchard. I find all these investigations
extraordinarily interesting. I have been observing M. Formery's
methods—I should like to watch yours, for a change."
"By all means," said Guerchard. "And there are several things I
want to hear about from your Grace. Of course it might be an advantage
to discuss them together with M. Formery, but—" and he hesitated.
"It would be a pity to disturb M. Formery in the middle of the
process of reconstruction," said the Duke; and a faint, ironical
smile played round the corners of his sensitive lips.
Guerchard looked at him quickly: "Perhaps it would," he said.
They went through the house, out of the back door, and into the
garden. Guerchard moved about twenty yards from the house, then he
stopped and questioned the Duke at great length. He questioned him
first about the Charolais, their appearance, their actions,
especially about Bernard's attempt to steal the pendant, and the
theft of the motor-cars.
"I have been wondering whether M. Charolais might not have been
Arsene Lupin himself," said the Duke.
"It's quite possible," said Guerchard. "There seem to be no limits
whatever to Lupin's powers of disguising himself. My colleague,
Ganimard, has come across him at least three times that he knows of,
as a different person. And no single time could he be sure that it
was the same man. Of course, he had a feeling that he was in contact
with some one he had met before, but that was all. He had no
certainty. He may have met him half a dozen times besides without
knowing him. And the photographs of him—they're all different.
Ganimard declares that Lupin is so extraordinarily successful in his
disguises because he is a great actor. He actually becomes for the
time being the person he pretends to be. He thinks and feels
absolutely like that person. Do you follow me?"
"Oh, yes; but he must be rather fluid, this Lupin," said the Duke;
and then he added thoughtfully, "It must be awfully risky to come so
often into actual contact with men like Ganimard and you."
"Lupin has never let any consideration of danger prevent him doing
anything that caught his fancy. He has odd fancies, too. He's a
humourist of the most varied kind—grim, ironic, farcical, as the
mood takes him. He must be awfully trying to live with," said
"Do you think humourists are trying to live with?" said the Duke,
in a meditative tone. "I think they brighten life a good deal; but of
course there are people who do not like them—the middle-classes."
"Yes, yes, they're all very well in their place; but to live with
they must be trying," said Guerchard quickly.
He went on to question the Duke closely and at length about the
household of M. Gournay-Martin, saying that Arsene Lupin worked with
the largest gang a burglar had ever captained, and it was any odds
that he had introduced one, if not more, of that gang into it.
Moreover, in the case of a big affair like this, Lupin himself often
played two or three parts under as many disguises.
"If he was Charolais, I don't see how he could be one of M.
Gournay- Martin's household, too," said the Duke in some perplexity.
"I don't say that he WAS Charolais," said Guerchard. "It is quite a
moot point. On the whole, I'm inclined to think that he was not. The
theft of the motor-cars was a job for a subordinate. He would hardly
bother himself with it."
The Duke told him all that he could remember about the
millionaire's servants—and, under the clever questioning of the
detective, he was surprised to find how much he did remember—all
kinds of odd details about them which he had scarcely been aware of
The two of them, as they talked, afforded an interesting contrast:
the Duke, with his air of distinction and race, his ironic
expression, his mobile features, his clear enunciation and well-
modulated voice, his easy carriage of an accomplished fencer—a
fencer with muscles of steel—seemed to be a man of another kind from
the slow-moving detective, with his husky voice, his common, slurring
enunciation, his clumsily moulded features, so ill adapted to the
expression of emotion and intelligence. It was a contrast almost
between the hawk and the mole, the warrior and the workman. Only in
their eyes were they alike; both of them had the keen, alert eyes of
observers. Perhaps the most curious thing of all was that, in spite of
the fact that he had for so much of his life been an idler, trifling
away his time in the pursuit of pleasure, except when he had made his
expedition to the South Pole, the Duke gave one the impression of
being a cleverer man, of a far finer brain, than the detective who had
spent so much of his life sharpening his wits on the more intricate
problems of crime.
When Guerchard came to the end of his questions, the Duke said:
"You have given me a very strong feeling that it is going to be a
deuce of a job to catch Lupin. I don't wonder that, so far, you have
none of you laid hands on him."
"But we have!" cried Guerchard quickly. "Twice Ganimard has caught
him. Once he had him in prison, and actually brought him to trial.
Lupin became another man, and was let go from the very dock."
"Really? It sounds absolutely amazing," said the Duke.
"And then, in the affair of the Blue Diamond, Ganimard caught him
again. He has his weakness, Lupin—it's women. It's a very common
weakness in these masters of crime. Ganimard and Holmlock Shears, in
that affair, got the better of him by using his love for a woman—
'the fair-haired lady,' she was called—to nab him."
"A shabby trick," said the Duke.
"Shabby?" said Guerchard in a tone of utter wonder. "How can
anything be shabby in the case of a rogue like this?"
"Perhaps not—perhaps not—still—" said the Duke, and stopped.
The expression of wonder faded from Guerchard's face, and he went
on, "Well, Holmlock Shears recovered the Blue Diamond, and Ganimard
nabbed Lupin. He held him for ten minutes, then Lupin escaped."
"What became of the fair-haired lady?" said the Duke.
"I don't know. I have heard that she is dead," said Guerchard. "Now
I come to think of it, I heard quite definitely that she died."
"It must be awful for a woman to love a man like Lupin—the
constant, wearing anxiety," said the Duke thoughtfully.
"I dare say. Yet he can have his pick of sweethearts. I've been
offered thousands of francs by women—women of your Grace's world and
wealthy Viennese—to make them acquainted with Lupin," said Guerchard.
"You don't surprise me," said the Duke with his ironic smile.
"Women never do stop to think—where one of their heroes is concerned.
And did you do it?"
"How could I? If I only could! If I could find Lupin entangled with
a woman like Ganimard did—well—" said Guerchard between his teeth.
"He'd never get out of YOUR clutches," said the Duke with
"I think not—I think not," said Guerchard grimly. "But come, I may
as well get on."
He walked across the turf to the foot of the ladder and looked at
the footprints round it. He made but a cursory examination of them,
and took his way down the garden-path, out of the door in the wall
into the space about the house that was building. He was not long
examining it, and he went right through it out into the street on
which the house would face when it was finished. He looked up and
down it, and began to retrace his footsteps.
"I've seen all I want to see out here. We may as well go back to
the house," he said to the Duke.
"I hope you've seen what you expected to see," said the Duke.
"Exactly what I expected to see—exactly," said Guerchard.
"That's as it should be," said the Duke.
They went back to the house and found M. Formery in the drawing-
room, still engaged in the process of reconstruction.
"The thing to do now is to hunt the neighbourhood for witnesses of
the departure of the burglars with their booty. Loaded as they were
with such bulky objects, they must have had a big conveyance.
Somebody must have noticed it. They must have wondered why it was
standing in front of a half-built house. Somebody may have actually
seen the burglars loading it, though it was so early in the morning.
Bonavent had better inquire at every house in the street on which
that half-built house faces. Did you happen to notice the name of
it?" said M. Formery.
"It's Sureau Street," said Guerchard. "But Dieusy has been hunting
the neighbourhood for some one who saw the burglars loading their
conveyance, or saw it waiting to be loaded, for the last hour."
"Good," said M. Formery. "We are getting on."
M. Formery was silent. Guerchard and the Duke sat down and lighted
"You found plenty of traces," said M. Formery, waving his hand
towards the window.
"Yes; I've found plenty of traces," said Guerchard.
"Of Lupin?" said M. Formery, with a faint sneer.
"No; not of Lupin," said Guerchard.
A smile of warm satisfaction illumined M. Formery's face:
"What did I tell you?" he said. "I'm glad that you've changed your
mind about that."
"I have hardly changed my mind," said Guerchard, in his husky,
There came a loud knocking on the front door, the sound of excited
voices on the stairs. The door opened, and in burst M. Gournay-
Martin. He took one glance round the devastated room, raised his
clenched hands towards the ceiling, and bellowed, "The scoundrels!
the dirty scoundrels!" And his voice stuck in his throat. He tottered
across the room to a couch, dropped heavily to it, gazed round the
scene of desolation, and burst into tears.
Germaine and Sonia came into the room. The Duke stepped forward to
"Do stop crying, papa. You're as hoarse as a crow as it is," said
Germaine impatiently. Then, turning on the Duke with a frown, she
said: "I think that joke of yours about the train was simply
disgraceful, Jacques. A joke's a joke, but to send us out to the
station on a night like last night, through all that heavy rain, when
you knew all the time that there was no quarter-to-nine train— it was
"I really don't know what you're talking about," said the Duke
quietly. "Wasn't there a quarter-to-nine train?"
"Of course there wasn't," said Germaine. "The time-table was years
old. I think it was the most senseless attempt at a joke I ever heard
"It doesn't seem to me to be a joke at all," said the Duke quietly.
"At any rate, it isn't the kind of a joke I make—it would be
detestable. I never thought to look at the date of the time-table. I
keep a box of cigarettes in that drawer, and I have noticed the
time-table there. Of course, it may have been lying there for years.
It was stupid of me not to look at the date."
"I said it was a mistake. I was sure that his Grace would not do
anything so unkind as that," said Sonia.
The Duke smiled at her.
"Well, all I can say is, it was very stupid of you not to look at
the date," said Germaine.
M. Gournay-Martin rose to his feet and wailed, in the most
heartrending fashion: "My pictures! My wonderful pictures! Such
investments! And my cabinets! My Renaissance cabinets! They can't be
replaced! They were unique! They were worth a hundred and fifty
M. Formery stepped forward with an air and said, "I am distressed,
M. Gournay-Martin—truly distressed by your loss. I am M. Formery,
"It is a tragedy, M. Formery—a tragedy!" groaned the millionaire.
"Do not let it upset you too much. We shall find your
masterpieces— we shall find them. Only give us time," said M. Formery
in a tone of warm encouragement.
The face of the millionaire brightened a little.
"And, after all, you have the consolation, that the burglars did
not get hold of the gem of your collection. They have not stolen the
coronet of the Princesse de Lambalie," said M. Formery.
"No," said the Duke. "They have not touched this safe. It is
"What has that got to do with it?" growled the millionaire quickly.
"That safe is empty."
"Empty . . . but your coronet?" cried the Duke.
"Good heavens! Then they HAVE stolen it," cried the millionaire
hoarsely, in a panic-stricken voice.
"But they can't have—this safe hasn't been touched," said the
"But the coronet never was in that safe. It was—have they entered
my bedroom?" said the millionaire.
"No," said M. Formery.
"They don't seem to have gone through any of the rooms except these
two," said the Duke.
"Ah, then my mind is at rest about that. The safe in my bedroom has
only two keys. Here is one." He took a key from his waistcoat pocket
and held it out to them. "And the other is in this safe."
The face of M. Formery was lighted up with a splendid satisfaction.
He might have rescued the coronet with his own hands. He cried
triumphantly, "There, you see!"
"See? See?" cried the millionaire in a sudden bellow. "I see that
they have robbed me—plundered me. Oh, my pictures! My wonderful
pictures! Such investments!"
They stood round the millionaire observing his anguish, with eyes
in which shone various degrees of sympathy. As if no longer able to
bear the sight of such woe, Sonia slipped out of the room.
The millionaire lamented his loss and abused the thieves by turns,
but always at the top of his magnificent voice.
Suddenly a fresh idea struck him. He clapped his hand to his brow
and cried: "That eight hundred pounds! Charolais will never buy the
Mercrac now! He was not a bona fide purchaser!"
The Duke's lips parted slightly and his eyes opened a trifle wider
than their wont. He turned sharply on his heel, and almost sprang
into the other drawing-room. There he laughed at his ease.
M. Formery kept saying to the millionaire: "Be calm, M. Gournay-
Martin. Be calm! We shall recover your masterpieces. I pledge you my
word. All we need is time. Have patience. Be calm!"
His soothing remonstrances at last had their effect. The
millionaire grew calm:
"Guerchard?" he said. "Where is Guerchard?"
M. Formery presented Guerchard to him.
"Are you on their track? Have you a clue?" said the millionaire.
"I think," said M. Formery in an impressive tone, "that we may now
proceed with the inquiry in the ordinary way."
He was a little piqued by the millionaire's so readily turning from
him to the detective. He went to a writing-table, set some sheets of
paper before him, and prepared to make notes on the answers to his
questions. The Duke came back into the drawing-room; the inspector
was summoned. M. Gournay-Martin sat down on a couch with his hands on
his knees and gazed gloomily at M. Formery. Germaine, who was sitting
on a couch near the door, waiting with an air of resignation for her
father to cease his lamentations, rose and moved to a chair nearer the
writing-table. Guerchard kept moving restlessly about the room, but
noiselessly. At last he came to a standstill, leaning against the wall
behind M. Formery.
M. Formery went over all the matters about which he had already
questioned the Duke. He questioned the millionaire and his daughter
about the Charolais, the theft of the motor-cars, and the attempted
theft of the pendant. He questioned them at less length about the
composition of their household—the servants and their characters. He
elicited no new fact.
He paused, and then he said, carelessly as a mere matter of
routine: "I should like to know, M. Gournay-Martin, if there has ever
been any other robbery committed at your house?"
"Three years ago this scoundrel Lupin—" the millionaire began
"Yes, yes; I know all about that earlier burglary. But have you
been robbed since?" said M. Formery, interrupting him.
"No, I haven't been robbed since that burglary; but my daughter
has," said the millionaire.
"Your daughter?" said M. Formery.
"Yes; I have been robbed two or three times during the last three
years," said Germaine.
"Dear me! But you ought to have told us about this before. This is
extremely interesting, and most important," said M. Formery, rubbing
his hands, "I suppose you suspect Victoire?"
"No, I don't," said Germaine quickly. "It couldn't have been
Victoire. The last two thefts were committed at the chateau when
Victoire was in Paris in charge of this house."
M. Formery seemed taken aback, and he hesitated, consulting his
notes. Then he said: "Good—good. That confirms my hypothesis."
"What hypothesis?" said M. Gournay-Martin quickly.
"Never mind—never mind," said M. Formery solemnly. And, turning to
Germaine, he went on: "You say, Mademoiselle, that these thefts began
about three years ago?"
"Yes, I think they began about three years ago in August."
"Let me see. It was in the month of August, three years ago, that
your father, after receiving a threatening letter like the one he
received last night, was the victim of a burglary?" said M. Formery.
"Yes, it was—the scoundrels!" cried the millionaire fiercely.
"Well, it would be interesting to know which of your servants
entered your service three years ago," said M. Formery.
"Victoire has only been with us a year at the outside," said
"Only a year?" said M. Formery quickly, with an air of some
vexation. He paused and added, "Exactly—exactly. And what was the
nature of the last theft of which you were the victim?"
"It was a pearl brooch—not unlike the pendant which his Grace gave
me yesterday," said Germaine.
"Would you mind showing me that pendant? I should like to see it,"
said M. Formery.
"Certainly—show it to him, Jacques. You have it, haven't you?"
said Germaine, turning to the Duke.
"Me? No. How should I have it?" said the Duke in some surprise.
"Haven't you got it?"
"I've only got the case—the empty case," said Germaine, with a
"The empty case?" said the Duke, with growing surprise.
"Yes," said Germaine. "It was after we came back from our useless
journey to the station. I remembered suddenly that I had started
without the pendant. I went to the bureau and picked up the case; and
it was empty."
"One moment—one moment," said M. Formery. "Didn't you catch this
young Bernard Charolais with this case in his hands, your Grace?"
"Yes," said the Duke. "I caught him with it in his pocket."
"Then you may depend upon it that the young rascal had slipped the
pendant out of its case and you only recovered the empty case from
him," said M. Formery triumphantly.
"No," said the Duke. "That is not so. Nor could the thief have been
the burglar who broke open the bureau to get at the keys. For long
after both of them were out of the house I took a cigarette from the
box which stood on the bureau beside the case which held the pendant.
And it occurred to me that the young rascal might have played that
very trick on me. I opened the case and the pendant was there."
"It has been stolen!" cried the millionaire; "of course it has been
"Oh, no, no," said the Duke. "It hasn't been stolen. Irma, or
perhaps Mademoiselle Kritchnoff, has brought it to Paris for
"Sonia certainly hasn't brought it. It was she who suggested to me
that you had seen it lying on the bureau, and slipped it into your
pocket," said Germaine quickly.
"Then it must be Irma," said the Duke.
"We had better send for her and make sure," said M. Formery.
"Inspector, go and fetch her."
The inspector went out of the room and the Duke questioned Germaine
and her father about the journey, whether it had been very
uncomfortable, and if they were very tired by it. He learned that
they had been so fortunate as to find sleeping compartments on the
train, so that they had suffered as little as might be from their
night of travel.
M. Formery looked through his notes; Guerchard seemed to be going
to sleep where he stood against the wall.
The inspector came back with Irma. She wore the frightened, half-
defensive, half-defiant air which people of her class wear when
confronted by the authorities. Her big, cow's eyes rolled uneasily.
"Oh, Irma—" Germaine began.
M. Formery cut her short, somewhat brusquely. "Excuse me, excuse
me. I am conducting this inquiry," he said. And then, turning to Irma,
he added, "Now, don't be frightened, Mademoiselle Irma; I want to ask
you a question or two. Have you brought up to Paris the pendant which
the Duke of Charmerace gave your mistress yesterday?"
"Me, sir? No, sir. I haven't brought the pendant," said Irma.
"You're quite sure?" said M. Formery.
"Yes, sir; I haven't seen the pendant. Didn't Mademoiselle Germaine
leave it on the bureau?" said Irma.
"How do you know that?" said M. Formery.
"I heard Mademoiselle Germaine say that it had been on the bureau.
I thought that perhaps Mademoiselle Kritchnoff had put it in her bag."
"Why should Mademoiselle Kritchnoff put it in her bag?" said the
"To bring it up to Paris for Mademoiselle Germaine," said Irma.
"But what made you think that?" said Guerchard, suddenly
"Oh, I thought Mademoiselle Kritchnoff might have put it in her bag
because I saw her standing by the bureau," said Irma.
"Ah, and the pendant was on the bureau?" said M. Formery.
"Yes, sir," said Irma.
There was a silence. Suddenly the atmosphere of the room seemed to
have become charged with an oppression—a vague menace. Guerchard
seemed to have become wide awake again. Germaine and the Duke looked
at one another uneasily.
"Have you been long in the service of Mademoiselle Gournay-Martin?"
said M. Formery.
"Six months, sir," said Irma.
"Very good, thank you. You can go," said M. Formery. "I may want
you again presently."
Irma went quickly out of the room with an air of relief.
M. Formery scribbled a few words on the paper before him and then
said: "Well, I will proceed to question Mademoiselle Kritchnoff."
"Mademoiselle Kritchnoff is quite above suspicion," said the Duke
"Oh, yes, quite," said Germaine.
"How long has Mademoiselle Kritchnoff been in your service,
Mademoiselle?" said Guerchard.
"Let me think," said Germaine, knitting her brow.
"Can't you remember?" said M. Formery.
"Just about three years," said Germaine.
"That's exactly the time at which the thefts began," said M.
"Yes," said Germaine, reluctantly.
"Ask Mademoiselle Kritchnoff to come here, inspector," said M.
"Yes, sir," said the inspector.
"I'll go and fetch her—I know where to find her," said the Duke
quickly, moving toward the door.
"Please, please, your Grace," protested Guerchard. "The inspector
will fetch her."
The Duke turned sharply and looked at him: "I beg your pardon, but
do you—" he said.
"Please don't be annoyed, your Grace," Guerchard interrupted. "But
M. Formery agrees with me—it would be quite irregular."
"Yes, yes, your Grace," said M. Formery. "We have our method of
procedure. It is best to adhere to it—much the best. It is the
result of years of experience of the best way of getting the truth."
"Just as you please," said the Duke, shrugging his shoulders.
The inspector came into the room: "Mademoiselle Kritchnoff will be
here in a moment. She was just going out."
"She was going out?" said M. Formery. "You don't mean to say you're
letting members of the household go out?"
"No, sir," said the inspector. "I mean that she was just asking if
she might go out."
M. Formery beckoned the inspector to him, and said to him in a
voice too low for the others to hear:
"Just slip up to her room and search her trunks."
"There is no need to take the trouble," said Guerchard, in the same
low voice, but with sufficient emphasis.
"No, of course not. There's no need to take the trouble," M.
Formery repeated after him.
The door opened, and Sonia came in. She was still wearing her
travelling costume, and she carried her cloak on her arm. She stood
looking round her with an air of some surprise; perhaps there was
even a touch of fear in it. The long journey of the night before did
not seem to have dimmed at all her delicate beauty. The Duke's eyes
rested on her in an inquiring, wondering, even searching gaze. She
looked at him, and her own eyes fell.
"Will you come a little nearer. Mademoiselle?" said M. Formery.
"There are one or two questions—"
"Will you allow me?" said Guerchard, in a tone of such deference
that it left M. Formery no grounds for refusal.
M. Formery flushed and ground his teeth. "Have it your own way!" he
"Mademoiselle Kritchnoff," said Guerchard, in a tone of the most
good-natured courtesy, "there is a matter on which M. Formery needs
some information. The pendant which the Duke of Charmerace gave
Mademoiselle Gournay-Martin yesterday has been stolen."
"Stolen? Are you sure?" said Sonia in a tone of mingled surprise
"Quite sure," said Guerchard. "We have exactly determined the
conditions under which the theft was committed. But we have every
reason to believe that the culprit, to avoid detection, has hidden
the pendant in the travelling-bag or trunk of somebody else in order
"My bag is upstairs in my bedroom, sir," Sonia interrupted quickly.
"Here is the key of it."
In order to free her hands to take the key from her wrist-bag, she
set her cloak on the back of a couch. It slipped off it, and fell to
the ground at the feet of the Duke, who had not returned to his place
beside Germaine. While she was groping in her bag for the key, and all
eyes were on her, the Duke, who had watched her with a curious
intentness ever since her entry into the room, stooped quietly down
and picked up the cloak. His hand slipped into the pocket of it; his
fingers touched a hard object wrapped in tissue- paper. They closed
round it, drew it from the pocket, and, sheltered by the cloak,
transferred it to his own. He set the cloak on the back of the sofa,
and very softly moved back to his place by Germaine's side. No one in
the room observed the movement, not even Guerchard: he was watching
Sonia too intently.
Sonia found the key, and held it out to Guerchard.
He shook his head and said: "There is no reason to search your
bag— none whatever. Have you any other luggage?"
She shrank back a little from his piercing eyes, almost as if their
gaze scared her.
"Yes, my trunk . . . it's upstairs in my bedroom too . . . open."
She spoke in a faltering voice, and her troubled eyes could not
meet those of the detective.
"You were going out, I think," said Guerchard gently.
"I was asking leave to go out. There is some shopping that must be
done," said Sonia.
"You do not see any reason why Mademoiselle Kritchnoff should not
go out, M. Formery, do you?" said Guerchard.
"Oh, no, none whatever; of course she can go out," said M. Formery.
Sonia turned round to go.
"One moment," said Guerchard, coming for-ward. "You've only got
that wrist-bag with you?"
"Yes," said Sonia. "I have my money and my handkerchief in it." And
she held it out to him.
Guerchard's keen eyes darted into it; and he muttered, "No point in
looking in that. I don't suppose any one would have had the
audacity—" and he stopped.
Sonia made a couple of steps toward the door, turned, hesitated,
came back to the couch, and picked up her cloak.
There was a sudden gleam in Guerchard's eyes—a gleam of
understanding, expectation, and triumph. He stepped forward, and
holding out his hands, said: "Allow me."
"No, thank you," said Sonia. "I'm not going to put it on."
"No . . . but it's possible . . . some one may have . . . have you
felt in the pockets of it? That one, now? It seems as if that one—"
He pointed to the pocket which had held the packet.
Sonia started back with an air of utter dismay; her eyes glanced
wildly round the room as if seeking an avenue of escape; her fingers
closed convulsively on the pocket.
"But this is abominable!" she cried. "You look as if—"
"I beg you, mademoiselle," interrupted Guerchard. "We are sometimes
"Really, Mademoiselle Sonia," broke in the Duke, in a singularly
clear and piercing tone, "I cannot see why you should object to this
"Oh, but—but—" gasped Sonia, raising her terror-stricken eyes to
The Duke seemed to hold them with his own; and he said in the same
clear, piercing voice, "There isn't the slightest reason for you to
Sonia let go of the cloak, and Guerchard, his face all alight with
triumph, plunged his hand into the pocket. He drew it out empty, and
stared at it, while his face fell to an utter, amazed blankness.
"Nothing? nothing?" he muttered under his breath. And he stared at
his empty hand as if he could not believe his eyes.
By a violent effort he forced an apologetic smile on his face, and
said to Sonia: "A thousand apologies, mademoiselle."
He handed the cloak to her. Sonia took it and turned to go. She
took a step towards the door, and tottered.
The Duke sprang forward and caught her as she was falling.
"Do you feel faint?" he said in an anxious voice.
"Thank you, you just saved me in time," muttered Sonia.
"I'm really very sorry," said Guerchard.
"Thank you, it was nothing. I'm all right now," said Sonia,
releasing herself from the Duke's supporting arm.
She drew herself up, and walked quietly out of the room.
Guerchard went back to M. Formery at the writing-table.
"You made a clumsy mistake there, Guerchard," said M. Formery, with
a touch of gratified malice in his tone.
Guerchard took no notice of it: "I want you to give orders that
nobody leaves the house without my permission," he said, in a low
"No one except Mademoiselle Kritchnoff, I suppose," said M.
"She less than any one," said Guerchard quickly.
"I don't understand what you're driving at a bit," said M. Formery.
"Unless you suppose that Mademoiselle Kritchnoff is Lupin in
Guerchard laughed softly: "You will have your joke, M. Formery," he
"Well, well, I'll give the order," said M. Formery, somewhat
mollified by the tribute to his humour.
He called the inspector to him and whispered a word in his ear.
Then he rose and said: "I think, gentlemen, we ought to go and examine
the bedrooms, and, above all, make sure that the safe in M. Gournay-
Martin's bedroom has not been tampered with."
"I was wondering how much longer we were going to waste time here
talking about that stupid pendant," grumbled the millionaire; and he
rose and led the way.
"There may also be some jewel-cases in the bedrooms," said M.
Formery. "There are all the wedding presents. They were in charge of
Victoire." said Germaine quickly. "It would be dreadful if they had
been stolen. Some of them are from the first families in France."
"They would replace them . . . those paper-knives," said the Duke,
Germaine and her father led the way. M. Formery, Guerchard, and the
inspector followed them. At the door the Duke paused, stopped, closed
it on them softly. He came back to the window, put his hand in his
pocket, and drew out the packet wrapped in tissue-paper.
He unfolded the paper with slow, reluctant fingers, and revealed
The Duke stared at the pendant, his eyes full of wonder and pity.
"Poor little girl!" he said softly under his breath.
He put the pendant carefully away in his waistcoat-pocket and stood
staring thoughtfully out of the window.
The door opened softly, and Sonia came quickly into the room,
closed the door, and leaned back against it. Her face was a dead
white; her skin had lost its lustre of fine porcelain, and she stared
at him with eyes dim with anguish.
In a hoarse, broken voice, she muttered: "Forgive me! Oh, forgive
"A thief—you?" said the Duke, in a tone of pitying wonder.
"You mustn't stop here," said the Duke in an uneasy tone, and he
looked uneasily at the door.
"Ah, you don't want to speak to me any more," said Sonia, in a
heartrending tone, wringing her hands.
"Guerchard is suspicious of everything. It is dangerous for us to
be talking here. I assure you that it's dangerous," said the Duke.
"What an opinion must you have of me! It's dreadful—cruel!" wailed
"For goodness' sake don't speak so loud," said the Duke, with even
greater uneasiness. "You MUST think of Guerchard."
"What do I care?" cried Sonia. "I've lost the liking of the only
creature whose liking I wanted. What does anything else matter? What
DOES it matter?"
"We'll talk somewhere else presently. That'll be far safer," said
"No, no, we must talk now!" cried Sonia. "You must know. . . . I
must tell . . . Oh, dear! . . . Oh, dear! . . . I don't know how to
tell you. . . . And then it is so unfair. . . . she . . . Germaine . .
. she has everything," she panted. "Yesterday, before me, you gave her
that pendant, . . . she smiled . . . she was proud of it. . . . I saw
her pleasure. . . . Then I took it—I took it—I took it! And if I
could, I'd take her fortune, too. . . . I hate her! Oh, how I hate
"What!" said the Duke.
"Yes, I do . . . I hate her!" said Sonia; and her eyes, no longer
gentle, glowed with the sombre resentment, the dull rage of the weak
who turn on Fortune. Her gentle voice was harsh with rebellious
"You hate her?" said the Duke quickly.
"I should never have told you that. . . . But now I dare. . . . I
dare speak out. . . . It's you! . . . It's you—" The avowal died on
her lips. A burning flush crimsoned her cheeks and faded as quickly
as it came: "I hate her!" she muttered.
"Sonia—" said the Duke gently.
"Oh! I know that it's no excuse. . . . I know that you're thinking
'This is a very pretty story, but it's not her first theft'; . . . and
it's true—it's the tenth, . . . perhaps it's the twentieth. . . .
It's true—I am a thief." She paused, and the glow deepened in her
eyes. "But there's one thing you must believe—you shall believe;
since you came, since I've known you, since the first day you set eyes
on me, I have stolen no more . . . till yesterday when you gave her
the pendant before me. I could not bear it . . . I could not." She
paused and looked at him with eyes that demanded an assent.
"I believe you," said the Duke gravely.
She heaved a deep sigh of relief, and went on more quietly—some of
its golden tone had returned to her voice: "And then, if you knew how
it began . . . the horror of it," she said.
"Poor child!" said the Duke softly.
"Yes, you pity me, but you despise me—you despise me beyond words.
You shall not! I will not have it!" she cried fiercely.
"Believe me, no," said the Duke, in a soothing tone.
"Listen," said Sonia. "Have you ever been alone—alone in the
world? . . . Have you ever been hungry? Think of it . . . in this big
city where I was starving in sight of bread . . . bread in the shops .
. . .One only had to stretch out one's hand to touch it . . . a penny
loaf. Oh, it's commonplace!" she broke off: "quite commonplace!"
"Go on: tell me," said the Duke curtly.
"There was one way I could make money and I would not do it: no, I
would not," she went on. "But that day I was dying . . . understand,
I was dying . . . .I went to the rooms of a man I knew a little. It
was my last resource. At first I was glad . . . he gave me food and
wine . . . and then, he talked to me . . . he offered me money."
"What!" cried the Duke; and a sudden flame of anger flared up in
"No; I could not . . . and then I robbed him. . . . I preferred to
. . . it was more decent. Ah, I had excuses then. I began to steal to
remain an honest woman . . . and I've gone on stealing to keep up
appearances. You see . . . I joke about it." And she laughed, the
faint, dreadful, mocking laugh of a damned soul. "Oh, dear! Oh, dear!"
she cried; and, burying her face in her hands, she burst into a storm
"Poor child," said the Duke softly. And he stared gloomily on the
ground, overcome by this revelation of the tortures of the feeble in
the underworld beneath the Paris he knew.
"Oh, you do pity me . . . you do understand . . . and feel," said
Sonia, between her sobs.
The Duke raised his head and gazed at her with eyes full of an
infinite sympathy and compassion.
"Poor little Sonia," he said gently. "I understand."
She gazed at him with incredulous eyes, in which joy and despair
He came slowly towards her, and stopped short. His quick ear had
caught the sound of a footstep outside the door.
"Quick! Dry your eyes! You must look composed. The other room!" he
cried, in an imperative tone.
He caught her hand and drew her swiftly into the further drawing-
With the quickness which came of long practice in hiding her
feelings Sonia composed her face to something of its usual gentle
calm. There was even a faint tinge of colour in her cheeks; they had
lost their dead whiteness. A faint light shone in her eyes; the
anguish had cleared from them. They rested on the Duke with a look of
ineffable gratitude. She sat down on a couch. The Duke went to the
window and lighted a cigarette. They heard the door of the outer
drawing-room open, and there was a pause. Quick footsteps crossed the
room, and Guerchard stood in the doorway. He looked from one to the
other with keen and eager eyes. Sonia sat staring rather listlessly at
the carpet. The Duke turned, and smiled at him.
"Well, M. Guerchard," he said. "I hope the burglars have not stolen
"The coronet is safe, your Grace," said Guerchard.
"And the paper-knives?" said the Duke.
"The paper-knives?" said Guerchard with an inquiring air.
"The wedding presents," said the Duke.
"Yes, your Grace, the wedding presents are safe," said Guerchard.
"I breathe again," said the Duke languidly.
Guerchard turned to Sonia and said, "I was looking for you,
Mademoiselle, to tell you that M. Formery has changed his mind. It is
impossible for you to go out. No one will be allowed to go out."
"Yes?" said Sonia, in an indifferent tone.
"We should be very much obliged if you would go to your room," said
Guerchard. "Your meals will be sent up to you."
"What?" said Sonia, rising quickly; and she looked from Guerchard
to the Duke. The Duke gave her the faintest nod.
"Very well, I will go to my room," she said coldly.
They accompanied her to the door of the outer drawing-room.
Guerchard opened it for her and closed it after her.
"Really, M. Guerchard," said the Duke, shrugging his shoulders.
"This last measure—a child like that!"
"Really, I'm very sorry, your Grace; but it's my trade, or, if you
prefer it, my duty. As long as things are taking place here which I
am still the only one to perceive, and which are not yet clear to me,
I must neglect no precaution."
"Of course, you know best," said the Duke. "But still, a child like
that—you're frightening her out of her life."
Guerchard shrugged his shoulders, and went quietly out of the room.
The Duke sat down in an easy chair, frowning and thoughtful.
Suddenly there struck on his ears the sound of a loud roaring and
heavy bumping on the stairs, the door flew open, and M. Gournay-
Martin stood on the threshold waving a telegram in his hand.
M. Formery and the inspector came hurrying down the stairs behind
him, and watched his emotion with astonished and wondering eyes.
"Here!" bellowed the millionaire. "A telegram! A telegram from the
scoundrel himself! Listen! Just listen:"
"A thousand apologies for not having been
able to keep my promise about the coronet.
Had an appointment at the Acacias. Please
have coronet ready in your room to-night. Will
come without fail to fetch it, between a quarter
to twelve and twelve o'clock."
"There! What do you think of that?"
"If you ask me, I think he's humbug," said the Duke with
"Humbug! You always think it's humbug! You thought the letter was
humbug; and look what has happened!" cried the millionaire.
"Give me the telegram, please," said M. Formery quickly.
The millionaire gave it to him; and he read it through.
"Find out who brought it, inspector," he said.
The inspector hurried to the top of the staircase and called to the
policeman in charge of the front door. He came back to the drawing-
room and said: "It was brought by an ordinary post-office messenger,
"Where is he?" said M. Formery. "Why did you let him go?"
"Shall I send for him, sir?" said the inspector.
"No, no, it doesn't matter," said M. Formery; and, turning to M.
Gournay-Martin and the Duke, he said, "Now we're really going to have
trouble with Guerchard. He is going to muddle up everything. This
telegram will be the last straw. Nothing will persuade him now that
this is not Lupin's work. And just consider, gentlemen: if Lupin had
come last night, and if he had really set his heart on the coronet, he
would have stolen it then, or at any rate he would have tried to open
the safe in M. Gournay-Martin's bedroom, in which the coronet actually
is, or this safe here"—he went to the safe and rapped on the door of
it—"in which is the second key."
"That's quite clear," said the inspector.
"If, then, he did not make the attempt last night, when he had a
clear field—when the house was empty—he certainly will not make the
attempt now when we are warned, when the police are on the spot, and
the house is surrounded. The idea is childish, gentlemen"—he leaned
against the door of the safe—"absolutely childish, but Guerchard is
mad on this point; and I foresee that his madness is going to hamper
us in the most idiotic way."
He suddenly pitched forward into the middle of the room, as the
door of the safe opened with a jerk, and Guerchard shot out of it.
"What the devil!" cried M. Formery, gaping at him.
"You'd be surprised how clearly you hear everything in these
safes— you'd think they were too thick," said Guerchard, in his
gentle, husky voice.
"How on earth did you get into it?" cried M. Formery.
"Getting in was easy enough. It's the getting out that was awkward.
These jokers had fixed up some kind of a spring so that I nearly shot
out with the door," said Guerchard, rubbing his elbow.
"But how did you get into it? How the deuce DID you get into it?"
cried M. Formery.
"Through the little cabinet into which that door behind the safe
opens. There's no longer any back to the safe; they've cut it clean
out of it—a very neat piece of work. Safes like this should always
be fixed against a wall, not stuck in front of a door. The backs of
them are always the weak point."
"And the key? The key of the safe upstairs, in my bedroom, where
the coronet is—is the key there?" cried M. Gournay-Martin.
Guerchard went back into the empty safe, and groped about in it. He
came out smiling.
"Well, have you found the key?" cried the millionaire.
"No. I haven't; but I've found something better," said Guerchard.
"What is it?" said M. Formery sharply.
"I'll give you a hundred guesses," said Guerchard with a
"What is it?" said M. Formery.
"A little present for you," said Guerchard.
"What do you mean?" cried M. Formery angrily.
Guerchard held up a card between his thumb and forefinger and said
"The card of Arsene Lupin."
The millionaire gazed at the card with stupefied eyes, the
inspector gazed at it with extreme intelligence, the Duke gazed at it
with interest, and M. Formery gazed at it with extreme disgust.
"It's part of the same ruse—it was put there to throw us off the
scent. It proves nothing—absolutely nothing," he said scornfully.
"No; it proves nothing at all," said Guerchard quietly.
"The telegram is the important thing—this telegram," said M.
Gournay-Martin feverishly. "It concerns the coronet. Is it going to
"Oh, no, no," said M. Formery in a soothing tone. "It will be taken
into account. It will certainly be taken into account."
M. Gournay-Martin's butler appeared in the doorway of the drawing-
room: "If you please, sir, lunch is served," he said.
At the tidings some of his weight of woe appeared to be lifted from
the head of the millionaire. "Good!" he said, "good! Gentlemen, you
will lunch with me, I hope."
"Thank you," said M. Formery. "There is nothing else for us to do,
at any rate at present, and in the house. I am not quite satisfied
about Mademoiselle Kritchnoff—at least Guerchard is not. I propose
to question her again—about those earlier thefts."
"I'm sure there's nothing in that," said the Duke quickly.
"No, no; I don't think there is," said M. Formery. "But still one
never knows from what quarter light may come in an affair like this.
Accident often gives us our best clues."
"It seems rather a shame to frighten her—she's such a child," said
"Oh, I shall be gentle, your Grace—as gentle as possible, that is.
But I look to get more from the examination of Victoire. She was on
the scene. She has actually seen the rogues at work; but till she
recovers there is nothing more to be done, except to wait the
discoveries of the detectives who are working outside; and they will
report here. So in the meantime we shall be charmed to lunch with
you, M. Gournay-Martin."
They went downstairs to the dining-room and found an elaborate and
luxurious lunch, worthy of the hospitality of a millionaire, awaiting
them. The skill of the cook seemed to have been quite unaffected by
the losses of his master. M. Formery, an ardent lover of good things,
enjoyed himself immensely. He was in the highest spirits. Germaine, a
little upset by the night-journey, was rather querulous. Her father
was plunged in a gloom which lifted for but a brief space at the
appearance of a fresh delicacy. Guerchard ate and drank seriously,
answering the questions of the Duke in a somewhat absent-minded
fashion. The Duke himself seemed to have lost his usual flow of good
spirits, and at times his brow was knitted in an anxious frown. His
questions to Guerchard showed a far less keen interest in the affair.
To him the lunch seemed very long and very tedious; but at last it
came to an end. M. Gournay-Martin seemed to have been much cheered by
the wine he had drunk. He was almost hopeful. M. Formery, who had not
by any means trifled with the champagne, was raised to the very height
of sanguine certainty. Their coffee and liqueurs were served in the
smoking-room. Guerchard lighted a cigar, refused a liqueur, drank his
coffee quickly, and slipped out of the room.
The Duke followed him, and in the hall said: "I will continue to
watch you unravel the threads of this mystery, if I may, M.
Good Republican as Guerchard was, he could not help feeling
flattered by the interest of a Duke; and the excellent lunch he had
eaten disposed him to feel the honour even more deeply.
"I shall be charmed," he said. "To tell the truth, I find the
company of your Grace really quite stimulating."
"It must be because I find it all so extremely interesting," said
They went up to the drawing-room and found the red-faced young
policeman seated on a chair by the door eating a lunch, which had
been sent up to him from the millionaire's kitchen, with a very
They went into the drawing-room. Guerchard shut the door and turned
the key: "Now," he said, "I think that M. Formery will give me half
an hour to myself. His cigar ought to last him at least half an hour.
In that time I shall know what the burglars really did with their
plunder—at least I shall know for certain how they got it out of the
"Please explain," said the Duke. "I thought we knew how they got it
out of the house." And he waved his hand towards the window.
"Oh, that!—that's childish," said Guerchard contemptuously. "Those
are traces for an examining magistrate. The ladder, the table on the
window-sill, they lead nowhere. The only people who came up that
ladder were the two men who brought it from the scaffolding. You can
see their footsteps. Nobody went down it at all. It was mere waste of
time to bother with those traces."
"But the footprint under the book?" said the Duke.
"Oh, that," said Guerchard. "One of the burglars sat on the couch
there, rubbed plaster on the sole of his boot, and set his foot down
on the carpet. Then he dusted the rest of the plaster off his boot
and put the book on the top of the footprint."
"Now, how do you know that?" said the astonished Duke.
"It's as plain as a pike-staff," said Guerchard. "There must have
been several burglars to move such pieces of furniture. If the soles
of all of them had been covered with plaster, all the sweeping in the
world would not have cleared the carpet of the tiny fragments of it.
I've been over the carpet between the footprint and the window with a
magnifying glass. There are no fragments of plaster on it. We dismiss
the footprint. It is a mere blind, and a very fair blind too—for an
"I understand," said the Duke.
"That narrows the problem, the quite simple problem, how was the
furniture taken out of the room. It did not go through that window
down the ladder. Again, it was not taken down the stairs, and out of
the front door, or the back. If it had been, the concierge and his
wife would have heard the noise. Besides that, it would have been
carried down into a main street, in which there are people at all
hours. Somebody would have been sure to tell a policeman that this
house was being emptied. Moreover, the police were continually
patrolling the main streets, and, quickly as a man like Lupin would
do the job, he could not do it so quickly that a policeman would not
have seen it. No; the furniture was not taken down the stairs or out
of the front door. That narrows the problem still more. In fact,
there is only one mode of egress left."
"The chimney!" cried the Duke.
"You've hit it," said Guerchard, with a husky laugh. "By that well-
known logical process, the process of elimination, we've excluded all
methods of egress except the chimney."
He paused, frowning, in some perplexity; and then he said uneasily:
"What I don't like about it is that Victoire was set in the
fireplace. I asked myself at once what was she doing there. It was
unnecessary that she should be drugged and set in the fireplace—
"It might have been to put off an examining magistrate," said the
Duke. "Having found Victoire in the fireplace, M. Formery did not
look for anything else."
"Yes, it might have been that," said Guerchard slowly. "On the
other hand, she might have been put there to make sure that I did not
miss the road the burglars took. That's the worst of having to do with
Lupin. He knows me to the bottom of my mind. He has something up his
sleeve—some surprise for me. Even now, I'm nowhere near the bottom
of the mystery. But come along, we'll take the road the burglars
took. The inspector has put my lantern ready for me."
As he spoke he went to the fireplace, picked up a lantern which had
been set on the top of the iron fire-basket, and lighted it. The Duke
stepped into the great fireplace beside him. It was four feet deep,
and between eight and nine feet broad. Guerchard threw the light from
the lantern on to the back wall of it. Six feet from the floor the
soot from the fire stopped abruptly, and there was a dappled patch of
bricks, half of them clean and red, half of them blackened by soot,
five feet broad, and four feet high.
"The opening is higher up than I thought," said Guerchard. "I must
get a pair of steps."
He went to the door of the drawing-room and bade the young
policeman fetch him a pair of steps. They were brought quickly. He
took them from the policeman, shut the door, and locked it again. He
set the steps in the fireplace and mounted them.
"Be careful," he said to the Duke, who had followed him into the
fireplace, and stood at the foot of the steps. "Some of these bricks
may drop inside, and they'll sting you up if they fall on your toes."
The Duke stepped back out of reach of any bricks that might fall.
Guerchard set his left hand against the wall of the chimney-piece
between him and the drawing-room, and pressed hard with his right
against the top of the dappled patch of bricks. At the first push,
half a dozen of them fell with a hang on to the floor of the next
house. The light came flooding in through the hole, and shone on
Guerchard's face and its smile of satisfaction. Quickly he pushed row
after row of bricks into the next house until he had cleared an
opening four feet square.
"Come along," he said to the Duke, and disappeared feet foremost
through the opening.
The Duke mounted the steps, and found himself looking into a large
empty room of the exact size and shape of the drawing-room of M.
Gournay-Martin, save that it had an ordinary modern fireplace instead
of one of the antique pattern of that in which he stood. Its
chimney-piece was a few inches below the opening. He stepped out on
to the chimney-piece and dropped lightly to the floor.
"Well," he said, looking back at the opening through which he had
come. "That's an ingenious dodge."
"Oh, it's common enough," said Guerchard. "Robberies at the big
jewellers' are sometimes Worked by these means. But what is uncommon
about it, and what at first sight put me off the track, is that these
burglars had the cheek to Pierce the wall with an opening large enough
to enable them to remove the furniture of a house."
"It's true," said the Duke. "The opening's as large as a good-sized
window. Those burglars seem capable of everything—even of a first-
class piece of mason's work."
"Oh, this has all been prepared a long while ago. But now I'm
really on their track. And after all, I haven't really lost any time.
Dieusy wasted no time in making inquiries in Sureau Street; he's been
working all this side of the house."
Guerchard drew up the blinds, opened the shutters, and let the
daylight flood the dim room. He came back to the fireplace and looked
down at the heap of bricks, frowning:
"I made a mistake there," he said. "I ought to have taken those
bricks down carefully, one by one."
Quickly he took brick after brick from the pile, and began to range
them neatly against the wall on the left. The Duke watched him for
two or three minutes, then began to help him. It did not take them
long, and under one of the last few bricks Guerchard found a fragment
of a gilded picture-frame.
"Here's where they ought to have done their sweeping," he said,
holding it up to the Duke.
"I tell you what," said the Duke, "I shouldn't wonder if we found
the furniture in this house still."
"Oh, no, no!" said Guerchard. "I tell you that Lupin would allow
for myself or Ganimard being put in charge of the case; and he would
know that we should find the opening in the chimney. The furniture
was taken straight out into the side-street on to which this house
opens." He led the way out of the room on to the landing and went
down the dark staircase into the hall. He opened the shutters of the
hall windows, and let in the light. Then he examined the hall. The
dust lay thick on the tiled floor. Down the middle of it was a lane
formed by many feet. The footprints were faint, but still plain in
the layer of dust. Guerchard came back to the stairs and began to
examine them. Half-way up the flight he stooped, and picked up a
little spray of flowers: "Fresh!" he said. "These have not been long
"Salvias," said the Duke.
"Salvias they are," said Guerchard. "Pink salvias; and there is
only one gardener in France who has ever succeeded in getting this
shade- -M. Gournay-Martin's gardener at Charmerace. I'm a gardener
"Well, then, last night's burglars came from Charmerace. They must
have," said the Duke.
"It looks like it," said Guerchard.
"The Charolais," said the Duke.
"It looks like it," said Guerchard.
"It must be," said the Duke. "This IS interesting—if only we could
get an absolute proof."
"We shall get one presently," said Guerchard confidently.
"It is interesting," said the Duke in a tone of lively enthusiasm.
"These clues—these tracks which cross one another—each fact by
degrees falling into its proper place—extraordinarily interesting."
He paused and took out his cigarette-case: "Will you have a
cigarette?" he said.
"Are they caporal?" said Guerchard.
"Thank you," said Guerchard; and he took one.
The Duke struck a match, lighted Guerchard's cigarette, and then
"Yes, it's very interesting," he said. "In the last quarter of an
hour you've practically discovered that the burglars came from
Charmerace—that they were the Charolais—that they came in by the
front door of this house, and carried the furniture out of it."
"I don't know about their coming in by it," said Guerchard. "Unless
I'm very much mistaken, they came in by the front door of M.
"Of course," said the Duke. "I was forgetting. They brought the
keys from Charmerace."
"Yes, but who drew the bolts for them?" said Guerchard. "The
concierge bolted them before he went to bed. He told me so. He was
telling the truth—I know when that kind of man is telling the
"By Jove!" said the Duke softly. "You mean that they had an
"I think we shall find that they had an accomplice. But your Grace
is beginning to draw inferences with uncommon quickness. I believe
that you would make a first-class detective yourself—with practice,
of course—with practice."
"Can I have missed my true career?" said the Duke, smiling. "It's
certainly a very interesting game."
"Well, I'm not going to search this barracks myself," said
Guerchard. "I'll send in a couple of men to do it; but I'll just take
a look at the steps myself."
So saying, he opened the front door and went out and examined the
"We shall have to go back the way we came," he said, when he had
finished his examination. "The drawing-room door is locked. We ought
to find M. Formery hammering on it." And he smiled as if he found the
They went back up the stairs, through the opening, into the
drawing- room of M. Gournay-Martin's house. Sure enough, from the
other side of the locked door came the excited voice of M. Formery,
"Guerchard! Guerchard! What are you doing? Let me in! Why don't you
let me in?"
Guerchard unlocked the door; and in bounced M. Formery, very
excited, very red in the face.
"Hang it all, Guerchard! What on earth have you been doing?" he
cried. "Why didn't you open the door when I knocked?"
"I didn't hear you," said Guerchard. "I wasn't in the room."
"Then where on earth have you been?" cried M. Formery.
Guerchard looked at him with a faint, ironical smile, and said in
his gentle voice, "I was following the real track of the burglars."
M. Formery gasped: "The real track?" he muttered.
"Let me show you," said Guerchard. And he led him to the fireplace,
and showed him the opening between the two houses.
"I must go into this myself!" cried M. Formery in wild excitement.
Without more ado he began to mount the steps. Guerchard followed
him. The Duke saw their heels disappear up the steps. Then he came
out of the drawing-room and inquired for M. Gournay-Martin. He was
told that the millionaire was up in his bedroom; and he went
upstairs, and knocked at the door of it.
M. Gournay-Martin bade him enter in a very faint voice, and the
Duke found him lying on the bed. He was looking depressed, even
exhausted, the shadow of the blusterous Gournay-Martin of the day
before. The rich rosiness of his cheeks had faded to a moderate
"That telegram," moaned the millionaire. "It was the last straw. It
has overwhelmed me. The coronet is lost."
"What, already?" said the Duke, in a tone of the liveliest
"No, no; it's still in the safe," said the millionaire. "But it's
as good as lost—before midnight it will be lost. That fiend will get
"If it's in this safe now, it won't be lost before midnight," said
the Duke. "But are you sure it's there now?"
"Look for yourself," said the millionaire, taking the key of the
safe from his waistcoat pocket, and handing it to the Duke.
The Duke opened the safe. The morocco case which held the coronet
lay on the middle shell in front of him. He glanced at the
millionaire, and saw that he had closed his eyes in the exhaustion of
despair. Whistling softly, the Duke opened the case, took out the
diadem, and examined it carefully, admiring its admirable
workmanship. He put it back in the case, turned to the millionaire,
and said thoughtfully:
"I can never make up my mind, in the case of one of these old
diadems, whether one ought not to take out the stones and have them
re-cut. Look at this emerald now. It's a very fine stone, but this
old-fashioned cutting does not really do it justice."
"Oh, no, no: you should never interfere with an antique, historic
piece of jewellery. Any alteration decreases its value—its value as
an historic relic," cried the millionaire, in a shocked tone.
"I know that," said the Duke, "but the question for me is, whether
one ought not to sacrifice some of its value to increasing its
"You do have such mad ideas," said the millionaire, in a tone of
"Ah, well, it's a nice question," said the Duke.
He snapped the case briskly, put it back on the shelf, locked the
safe, and handed the key to the millionaire. Then he strolled across
the room and looked down into the street, whistling softly.
"I think—I think—I'll go home and get out of these motoring
clothes. And I should like to have on a pair of boots that were a
trifle less muddy," he said slowly.
M. Gournay-Martin sat up with a jerk and cried, "For Heaven's sake,
don't you go and desert me, my dear chap! You don't know what my
nerves are like!"
"Oh, you've got that sleuth-hound, Guerchard, and the splendid
Formery, and four other detectives, and half a dozen ordinary
policemen guarding you. You can do without my feeble arm. Besides, I
shan't be gone more than half an hour—three-quarters at the outside.
I'll bring back my evening clothes with me, and dress for dinner here.
I don't suppose that anything fresh will happen between now and
midnight; but I want to be on the spot, and hear the information as it
comes in fresh. Besides, there's Guerchard. I positively cling to
Guerchard. It's an education, though perhaps not a liberal education,
to go about with him," said the Duke; and there was a sub-acid irony
in his voice.
"Well, if you must, you must," said M. Gournay-Martin grumpily.
"Good-bye for the present, then," said the Duke. And he went out of
the room and down the stairs. He took his motor-cap from the hall-
table, and had his hand on the latch of the door, when the policeman
in charge of it said, "I beg your pardon, sir, but have you M.
Guerchard's permission to leave the house?"
"M. Guerchard's permission?" said the Duke haughtily. "What has M.
Guerchard to do with me? I am the Duke of Charmerace." And he opened
"It was M. Formery's orders, your Grace," stammered the policeman
"M. Formery's orders?" said the Duke, standing on the top step.
"Call me a taxi-cab, please."
The concierge, who stood beside the policeman, ran down the steps
and blew his whistle. The policeman gazed uneasily at the Duke,
shifting his weight from one foot to the other; but he said no more.
A taxi-cab came up to the door, the Duke went down the steps,
stepped into it, and drove away.
Three-quarters of an hour later he came back, having changed into
clothes more suited to a Paris drawing-room. He went up to the
drawing-room, and there he found Guerchard, M. Formery, and the
inspector, who had just completed their tour of inspection of the
house next door and had satisfied themselves that the stolen
treasures were not in it. The inspector and his men had searched it
thoroughly just to make sure; but, as Guerchard had foretold, the
burglars had not taken the chance of the failure of the police to
discover the opening between the two houses. M. Formery told the Duke
about their tour of inspection at length. Guerchard went to the
telephone and told the exchange to put him through to Charmerace. He
was informed that the trunk line was very busy and that he might have
to wait half an hour.
The Duke inquired if any trace of the burglars, after they had left
with their booty, had yet been found. M. Formery told him that, so
far, the detectives had failed to find a single trace. Guerchard said
that he had three men at work on the search, and that he was hopeful
of getting some news before long.
"The layman is impatient in these matters," said M. Formery, with
an indulgent smile. "But we have learnt to be patient, after long
He proceeded to discuss with Guerchard the new theories with which
the discovery of the afternoon had filled his mind. None of them
struck the Duke as being of great value, and he listened to them with
a somewhat absent-minded air. The coming examination of Sonia weighed
heavily on his spirit. Guerchard answered only in monosyllables to the
questions and suggestions thrown out by M. Formery. It seemed to the
Duke that he paid very little attention to him, that his mind was
still working hard on the solution of the mystery, seeking the missing
facts which would bring him to the bottom of it. In the middle of one
of M. Formery's more elaborate dissertations the telephone bell rang.
Guerchard rose hastily and went to it. They heard him say: "Is
that Charmerace? . . . I want the gardener. . . . Out? When will he
be back? . . . Tell him to ring me up at M. Gournay-Martin's house in
Paris the moment he gets back. . . . Detective-Inspector Guerchard . .
. Guerchard . . . Detective-Inspector."
He turned to them with a frown, and said, "Of course, since I want
him, the confounded gardener has gone out for the day. Still, it's of
very little importance—a mere corroboration I wanted." And he went
back to his seat and lighted another cigarette.
M. Formery continued his dissertation. Presently Guerchard said,
"You might go and see how Victoire is, inspector—whether she shows
any signs of waking. What did the doctor say?"
"The doctor said that she would not really be sensible and have her
full wits about her much before ten o'clock to-night," said the
inspector; but he went to examine her present condition.
M. Formery proceeded to discuss the effects of different
anesthetics. The others heard him with very little attention.
The inspector came back and reported that Victoire showed no signs
"Well, then, M. Formery, I think we might get on with the
examination of Mademoiselle Kritchnoff," said Guerchard. "Will you go
and fetch her, inspector?"
"Really, I cannot conceive why you should worry that poor child,"
the Duke protested, in a tone of some indignation.
"It seems to me hardly necessary," said M. Formery.
"Excuse me," said Guerchard suavely, "but I attach considerable
importance to it. It seems to me to be our bounden duty to question
her fully. One never knows from what quarter light may come."
"Oh, well, since you make such a point of it," said M. Formery.
"Inspector, ask Mademoiselle Kritchnoff to come here. Fetch her."
The inspector left the room.
Guerchard looked at the Duke with a faint air of uneasiness: "I
think that we had better question Mademoiselle Kritchnoff by
ourselves," he said.
M. Formery looked at him and hesitated. Then he said: "Oh, yes, of
course, by ourselves."
"Certainly," said the Duke, a trifle haughtily. And he rose and
opened the door. He was just going through it when Guerchard said
The Duke paid no attention to him. He shut the door quickly behind
him and sprang swiftly up the stairs. He met the inspector coming
down with Sonia. Barring their way for a moment he said, in his
kindliest voice: "Now you mustn't be frightened, Mademoiselle Sonia.
All you have to do is to try to remember as clearly as you can the
circumstances of the earlier thefts at Charmerace. You mustn't let
them confuse you."
"Thank you, your Grace, I will try and be as clear as I can," said
Sonia; and she gave him an eloquent glance, full of gratitude for the
warning; and went down the stairs with firm steps.
The Duke went on up the stairs, and knocked softly at the door of
M. Gournay-Martin's bedroom. There was no answer to his knock, and he
quietly opened the door and looked in. Overcome by his misfortunes,
the millionaire had sunk into a profound sleep and was snoring
softly. The Duke stepped inside the room, left the door open a couple
of inches, drew a chair to it, and sat down watching the staircase
through the opening of the door.
He sat frowning, with a look of profound pity on his face. Once the
suspense grew too much for him. He rose and walked up and down the
room. His well-bred calm seemed to have deserted him. He muttered
curses on Guerchard, M. Formery, and the whole French criminal
system, very softly, under his breath. His face was distorted to a
mask of fury; and once he wiped the little beads of sweat from his
forehead with his handkerchief. Then he recovered himself, sat down
in the chair, and resumed his watch on the stairs.
At last, at the end of half an hour, which had seemed to him months
long, he heard voices. The drawing-room door shut, and there were
footsteps on the stairs. The inspector and Sonia came into view.
He waited till they were at the top of the stairs: then he came out
of the room, with his most careless air, and said: "Well,
Mademoiselle Sonia, I hope you did not find it so very dreadful,
She was very pale, and there were undried tears on her cheeks. "It
was horrible," she said faintly. "Horrible. M. Formery was all
right—he believed me; but that horrible detective would not believe
a word I said. He confused me. I hardly knew what I was saying."
The Duke ground his teeth softly. "Never mind, it's over now. You
had better lie down and rest. I will tell one of the servants to
bring you up a glass of wine."
He walked with her to the door of her room, and said: "Try to
sleep- -sleep away the unpleasant memory."
She went into her room, and the Duke went downstairs and told the
butler to take a glass of champagne up to her. Then he went upstairs
to the drawing-room. M. Formery was at the table writing. Guerchard
stood beside him. He handed what he had written to Guerchard, and,
with a smile of satisfaction, Guerchard folded the paper and put it
in his pocket.
"Well, M. Formery, did Mademoiselle Kritchnoff throw any fresh
light on this mystery?" said the Duke, in a tone of faint contempt.
"No—in fact she convinced ME that she knew nothing whatever about
it. M. Guerchard seems to entertain a different opinion. But I think
that even he is convinced that Mademoiselle Kritehnoff is not a
friend of Arsene Lupin."
"Oh, well, perhaps she isn't. But there's no telling," said
"Arsene Lupin?" cried the Duke. "Surely you never thought that
Mademoiselle Kritchnoff had anything to do with Arsene Lupin?"
"I never thought so," said M. Formery. "But when one has a fixed
idea . . . well, one has a fixed idea." He shrugged his shoulders,
and looked at Guerchard with contemptuous eyes.
The Duke laughed, an unaffected ringing laugh, but not a pleasant
one: "It's absurd!" he cried.
"There are always those thefts," said Guerchard, with a nettled
"You have nothing to go upon," said M. Formery. "What if she did
enter the service of Mademoiselle Gournay-Martin just before the
thefts began? Besides, after this lapse of time, if she had committed
the thefts, you'd find it a job to bring them home to her. It's not a
job worth your doing, anyhow—it's a job for an ordinary detective,
"There's always the pendant," said Guerchard. "I am convinced that
that pendant is in the house."
"Oh, that stupid pendant! I wish I'd never given it to Mademoiselle
Gournay-Martin," said the Duke lightly.
"I have a feeling that if I could lay my hand on that pendant—if I
could find who has it, I should have the key to this mystery."
"The devil you would!" said the Duke softly. "That is odd. It is
the oddest thing about this business I've heard yet."
"I have that feeling—I have that feeling," said Guerchard quietly.
The Duke smiled.
They were silent. The Duke walked to the fireplace, stepped into
it, and studied the opening. He came out again and said: "Oh, by the
way, M. Formery, the policeman at the front door wanted to stop me
going out of the house when I went home to change. I take it that M.
Guerchard's prohibition does not apply to me?"
"Of course not—of course not, your Grace," said M. Formery
"I saw that you had changed your clothes, your Grace," said
Guerchard. "I thought that you had done it here."
"No," said the Duke, "I went home. The policeman protested; but he
went no further, so I did not throw him into the middle of the
"Whatever our station, we should respect the law," said M. Formery
"The Republican Law, M. Formery? I am a Royalist," said the Duke,
smiling at him.
M. Formery shook his head sadly.
"I was wondering," said the Duke, "about M. Guerchard's theory that
the burglars were let in the front door of this house by an
accomplice. Why, when they had this beautiful large opening, did they
want a front door, too?"
"I did not know that that was Guerchard's theory?" said M. Formery,
a trifle contemptuously. "Of course they had no need to use the front
"Perhaps they had no need to use the front door," said Guerchard;
"but, after all, the front door was unbolted, and they did not draw
the bolts to put us off the scent. Their false scent was already
prepared"—he waved his hand towards the window—"moreover, you must
bear in mind that that opening might not have been made when they
entered the house. Suppose that, while they were on the other side of
the wall, a brick had fallen on to the hearth, and alarmed the
concierge. We don't know how skilful they are; they might not have
cared to risk it. I'm inclined to think, on the whole, that they did
come in through the front door."
M. Formery sniffed contemptuously.
"Perhaps you're right," said the Duke. "But the accomplice?"
"I think we shall know more about the accomplice when Victoire
awakes," said Guerchard.
"The family have such confidence in Victoire," said the Duke.
"Perhaps Lupin has, too," said Guerchard grimly.
"Always Lupin!" said M. Formery contemptuously.
There came a knock at the door, and a footman appeared on the
threshold. He informed the Duke that Germaine had returned from her
shopping expedition, and was awaiting him in her boudoir. He went to
her, and tried to persuade her to put in a word for Sonia, and
endeavour to soften Guerchard's rigour.
She refused to do anything of the kind, declaring that, in view of
the value of the stolen property, no stone must be left unturned to
recover it. The police knew what they were doing; they must have a
free hand. The Duke did not press her with any great vigour; he
realized the futility of an appeal to a nature so shallow, so self-
centred, and so lacking in sympathy. He took his revenge by teasing
her about the wedding presents which were still flowing in. Her
father's business friends were still striving to outdo one another in
the costliness of the jewelry they were giving her. The great houses
of the Faubourg Saint-Germain were still refraining firmly from
anything that savoured of extravagance or ostentation. While he was
with her the eleventh paper-knife came—from his mother's friend, the
Duchess of Veauleglise. The Duke was overwhelmed with joy at the sight
of it, and his delighted comments drove Germaine to the last extremity
of exasperation. The result was that she begged him, with petulant
asperity, to get out of her sight.
He complied with her request, almost with alacrity, and returned to
M. Formery and Guerchard. He found them at a standstill, waiting for
reports from the detectives who were hunting outside the house for
information about the movements of the burglars with the stolen
booty, and apparently finding none. The police were also hunting for
the stolen motor-cars, not only in Paris and its environs, but also
all along the road between Paris and Charmerace.
At about five o'clock Guerchard grew tired of the inaction, and
went out himself to assist his subordinates, leaving M. Formery in
charge of the house itself. He promised to be back by half-past seven,
to let the examining magistrate, who had an engagement for the
evening, get away. The Duke spent his time between the drawing-room,
where M. Formery entertained him with anecdotes of his professional
skill, and the boudoir, where Germaine was entertaining envious young
friends who came to see her wedding presents. The friends of Germaine
were always a little ill at ease in the society of the Duke, belonging
as they did to that wealthy middle class which has made France what
she is. His indifference to the doings of the old friends of his
family saddened them; and they were unable to understand his airy and
persistent trifling. It seemed to them a discord in the cosmic tune.
The afternoon wore away, and at half-past seven Guerchard had not
returned. M. Formery waited for him, fuming, for ten minutes, then
left the house in charge of the inspector, and went off to his
engagement. M. Gournay-Martin was entertaining two financiers and
their wives, two of their daughters, and two friends of the Duke, the
Baron de Vernan and the Comte de Vauvineuse, at dinner that night.
Thanks to the Duke, the party was of a liveliness to which the
gorgeous dining-room had been very little used since it had been so
fortunate as to become the property of M. Gournay-Martin.
The millionaire had been looking forward to an evening of luxurious
woe, deploring the loss of his treasures—giving their prices—to his
sympathetic friends. The Duke had other views; and they prevailed.
After dinner the guests went to the smoking-room, since the
drawing-rooms were in possession of Guerchard. Soon after ten the Duke
slipped away from them, and went to the detective. Guerchard's was not
a face at any time full of expression, and all that the Duke saw on it
was a subdued dulness.
"Well, M. Guerchard," he said cheerfully, "what luck? Have any of
your men come across any traces of the passage of the burglars with
"No, your Grace; so far, all the luck has been with the burglars.
For all that any one seems to have seen them, they might have
vanished into the bowels of the earth through the floor of the
cellars in the empty house next door. That means that they were very
quick loading whatever vehicle they used with their plunder. I should
think, myself, that they first carried everything from this house down
into the hall of the house next door; and then, of course, they could
be very quick getting them from hall to their van, or whatever it was.
But still, some one saw that van—saw it drive up to the house, or
waiting at the house, or driving away from it."
"Is M. Formery coming back?" said the Duke.
"Not to-night," said Guerchard. "The affair is in my hands now; and
I have my own men on it—men of some intelligence, or, at any rate,
men who know my ways, and how I want things done."
"It must be a relief," said the Duke.
"Oh, no, I'm used to M. Formery—to all the examining magistrates
in Paris, and in most of the big provincial towns. They do not really
hamper me; and often I get an idea from them; for some of them are
men of real intelligence."
"And others are not: I understand," said the Duke.
The door opened and Bonavent, the detective, came in.
"The housekeeper's awake, M. Guerchard," he said.
"Good, bring her down here," said Guerchard.
"Perhaps you'd like me to go," said the Duke.
"Oh, no," said Guerchard. "If it would interest you to hear me
question her, please stay."
Bonavent left the room. The Duke sat down in an easy chair, and
Guerchard stood before the fireplace.
"M. Formery told me, when you were out this afternoon, that he
believed this housekeeper to be quite innocent," said the Duke idly.
"There is certainly one innocent in this affair," said Guerchard,
"Who is that?" said the Duke.
"The examining magistrate," said Guerchard.
The door opened, and Bonavent brought Victoire in. She was a big,
middle-aged woman, with a pleasant, cheerful, ruddy face, black-
haired, with sparkling brown eyes, which did not seem to have been at
all dimmed by her long, drugged sleep. She looked like a well-to- do
farmer's wife, a buxom, good-natured, managing woman.
As soon as she came into the room, she said quickly:
"I wish, Mr. Inspector, your man would have given me time to put on
a decent dress. I must have been sleeping in this one ever since
those rascals tied me up and put that smelly handkerchief over my
face. I never saw such a nasty-looking crew as they were in my life."
"How many were there, Madame Victoire?" said Guerchard.
"Dozens! The house was just swarming with them. I heard the noise;
I came downstairs; and on the landing outside the door here, one of
them jumped on me from behind and nearly choked me—to prevent me
from screaming, I suppose."
"And they were a nasty-looking crew, were they?" said Guerchard.
"Did you see their faces?"
"No, I wish I had! I should know them again if I had; but they were
all masked," said Victoire.
"Sit down, Madame Victoire. There's no need to tire you," said
Guerchard. And she sat down on a chair facing him.
"Let's see, you sleep in one of the top rooms, Madame Victoire. It
has a dormer window, set in the roof, hasn't it?" said Guerchard, in
the same polite, pleasant voice.
"Yes; yes. But what has that got to do with it?" said Victoire.
"Please answer my questions," said Guerchard sharply. "You went to
sleep in your room. Did you hear any noise on the roof?"
"On the roof? How should I hear it on the roof? There wouldn't be
any noise on the roof," said Victoire.
"You heard nothing on the roof?" said Guerchard.
"No; the noise I heard was down here," said Victoire.
"Yes, and you came down to see what was making it. And you were
seized from behind on the landing, and brought in here," said
"Yes, that's right," said Madame Victoire.
"And were you tied up and gagged on the landing, or in here?" said
"Oh, I was caught on the landing, and pushed in here, and then tied
up," said Victoire.
"I'm sure that wasn't one man's job," said Guerchard, looking at
her vigorous figure with admiring eyes.
"You may be sure of that," said Victoire. "It took four of them;
and at least two of them have some nice bruises on their shins to show
"I'm sure they have. And it serves them jolly well right," said
Guerchard, in a tone of warm approval. "And, I suppose, while those
four were tying you up the others stood round and looked on."
"Oh, no, they were far too busy for that," said Victoire.
"What were they doing?" said Guerchard.
"They were taking the pictures off the walls and carrying them out
of the window down the ladder," said Victoire.
Guerchard's eyes flickered towards the Duke, but the expression of
earnest inquiry on his face never changed.
"Now, tell me, did the man who took a picture from the walls carry
it down the ladder himself, or did he hand it through the window to a
man who was standing on the top of a ladder ready to receive it?" he
Victoire paused as if to recall their action; then she said, "Oh,
he got through the window, and carried it down the ladder himself."
"You're sure of that?" said Guerchard.
"Oh, yes, I am quite sure of it—why should I deceive you, Mr.
Inspector?" said Victoire quickly; and the Duke saw the first shadow
of uneasiness on her face.
"Of course not," said Guerchard. "And where were you?"
"Oh, they put me behind the screen."
"No, no, where were you when you came into the room?"
"I was against the door," said Victoire.
"And where was the screen?" said Guerchard. "Was it before the
"No; it was on one side—the left-hand side," said Victoire.
"Oh, will you show me exactly where it stood?" said Guerchard.
Victoire rose, and, Guerchard aiding her, set the screen on the
left-hand side of the fireplace.
Guerchard stepped back and looked at it.
"Now, this is very important," he said. "I must have the exact
position of the four feet of that screen. Let's see . . . some chalk
. . . of course. . . . You do some dressmaking, don't you, Madame
"Oh, yes, I sometimes make a dress for one of the maids in my spare
time," said Victoire.
"Then you've got a piece of chalk on you," said Guerchard.
"Oh, yes," said Victoire, putting her hand to the pocket of her
She paused, took a step backwards, and looked wildly round the
room, while the colour slowly faded in her ruddy cheeks.
"What am I talking about?" she said in an uncertain, shaky voice.
"I haven't any chalk—I—ran out of chalk the day before yesterday."
"I think you have, Madame Victoire. Feel in your pocket and see,"
said Guerchard sternly. His voice had lost its suavity; his face its
smile: his eyes had grown dangerous.
"No, no; I have no chalk," cried Victoire.
With a sudden leap Guerchard sprang upon her, caught her in a firm
grip with his right arm, and his left hand plunged into her pocket.
"Let me go! Let me go! You're hurting," she cried.
Guerchard loosed her and stepped back.
"What's this?" he said; and he held up between his thumb and
forefinger a piece of blue chalk.
Victoire drew herself up and faced him gallantly: "Well, what of
it?—it is chalk. Mayn't an honest woman carry chalk in her pockets
without being insulted and pulled about by every policeman she comes
across?" she cried.
"That will be for the examining magistrate to decide," said
Guerchard; and he went to the door and called Bonavent. Bonavent came
in, and Guerchard said: "When the prison van comes, put this woman in
it; and send her down to the station."
"But what have I done?" cried Victoire. "I'm innocent! I declare
I'm innocent. I've done nothing at all. It's not a crime to carry a
piece of chalk in one's pocket."
"Now, that's a matter for the examining magistrate. You can explain
it to him," said Guerchard. "I've got nothing to do with it: so it's
no good making a fuss now. Do go quietly, there's a good woman."
He spoke in a quiet, business-like tone. Victoire looked him in the
eyes, then drew herself up, and went quietly out of the room.
"One of M. Formery's innocents," said Guerchard, turning to the
"The chalk?" said the Duke. "Is it the same chalk?"
"It's blue," said Guerchard, holding it out. "The same as that of
the signatures on the walls. Add that fact to the woman's sudden
realization of what she was doing, and you'll see that they were
written with it."
"It is rather a surprise," said the Duke. "To look at her you would
think that she was the most honest woman in the world."
"Ah, you don't know Lupin, your Grace," said Guerchard. "He can do
anything with women; and they'll do anything for him. And, what's
more, as far as I can see, it doesn't make a scrap of difference
whether they're honest or not. The fair-haired lady I was telling you
about was probably an honest woman; Ganimard is sure of it. We should
have found out long ago who she was if she had been a wrong 'un. And
Ganimard also swears that when he arrested Lupin on board the Provence
some woman, some ordinary, honest woman among the passengers, carried
away Lady Garland's jewels, which he had stolen and was bringing to
America, and along with them a matter of eight hundred pounds which he
had stolen from a fellow-passenger on the voyage."
"That power of fascination which some men exercise on women is one
of those mysteries which science should investigate before it does
anything else," said the Duke, in a reflective tone. "Now I come to
think of it, I had much better have spent my time on that
investigation than on that tedious journey to the South Pole. All the
same, I'm deucedly sorry for that woman, Victoire. She looks such a
Guerchard shrugged his shoulders: "The prisons are full of good
souls," he said, with cynical wisdom born of experience. "They get
caught so much more often than the bad."
"It seems rather mean of Lupin to make use of women like this, and
get them into trouble," said the Duke.
"But he doesn't," said Guerchard quickly. "At least he hasn't up to
now. This Victoire is the first we've caught. I look on it as a good
He walked across the room, picked up his cloak, and took a
card-case from the inner pocket of it. "If you don't mind, your Grace,
I want you to show this permit to my men who are keeping the door,
whenever you go out of the house. It's just a formality; but I attach
considerable importance to it, for I really ought not to make
exceptions in favour of any one. I have two men at the door, and they
have orders to let nobody out without my written permission. Of course
M. Gournay-Martin's guests are different. Bonavent has orders to pass
them out. And, if your Grace doesn't mind, it will help me. If you
carry a permit, no one else will dream of complaining of having to do
"Oh, I don't mind, if it's of any help to you," said the Duke
"Thank you," said Guerchard. And he wrote on his card and handed it
to the Duke.
The Duke took it and looked at it. On it was written:
"Pass the Duke of Charmerace."
"It's quite military," said the Duke, putting the card into his
There came a knock at the door, and a tall, thin, bearded man came
into the room.
"Ah, Dieusy! At last! What news?" cried Guerchard.
Dieusy saluted: "I've learnt that a motor-van was waiting outside
the next house—in the side street," he said.
"At what time?" said Guerchard.
"Between four and five in the morning," said Dieusy.
"Who saw it?" said Guerchard.
"A scavenger. He thinks that it was nearly five o'clock when the
van drove off."
"Between four and five—nearly five. Then they filled up the
opening before they loaded the van. I thought they would," said
Guerchard, thoughtfully. "Anything else?"
"A few minutes after the van had gone a man in motoring dress came
out of the house," said Dieusy.
"In motoring dress?" said Guerchard quickly.
"Yes. And a little way from the house he threw away his cigarette.
The scavenger thought the whole business a little queer, and he
picked up the cigarette and kept it. Here it is."
He handed it to Guerchard, whose eyes scanned it carelessly and
then glued themselves to it.
"A gold-tipped cigarette . . . marked Mercedes . . . Why, your
Grace, this is one of your cigarettes!"
"But this is incredible!" cried the Duke.
"Not at all," said Guerchard. "It's merely another link in the
chain. I've no doubt you have some of these cigarettes at
"Oh, yes, I've had a box on most of the tables," said the Duke.
"Well, there you are," said Guerchard.
"Oh, I see what you're driving at," said the Duke. "You mean that
one of the Charolais must have taken a box."
"Well, we know that they'd hardly stick at a box of cigarettes,"
"Yes . . . but I thought . . ." said the Duke; and he paused.
"You thought what?" said Guerchard.
"Then Lupin . . . since it was Lupin who managed the business last
night—since you found those salvias in the house next door . . .
then Lupin came from Charmerace."
"Evidently," said Guerchard.
"And Lupin is one of the Charolais."
"Oh, that's another matter," said Guerchard.
"But it's certain, absolutely certain," said the Duke. "We have the
connecting links . . . the salvias . . . this cigarette."
"It looks very like it. You're pretty quick on a scent, I must
say," said Guerchard. "What a detective you would have made! Only . .
. nothing is certain."
"But it IS. Whatever more do you want? Was he at Charmerace
yesterday, or was he not? Did he, or did he not, arrange the theft of
"Certainly he did. But he himself might have remained in the
background all the while," said Guerchard.
"In what shape? . . . Under what mask? . . . By Jove, I should like
to see this fellow!" said the Duke.
"We shall see him to-night," said Guerchard.
"To-night?" said the Duke.
"Of course we shall; for he will come to steal the coronet between
a quarter to twelve and midnight," said Guerchard.
"Never!" said the Duke. "You don't really believe that he'll have
the cheek to attempt such a mad act?"
"Ah, you don't know this man, your Grace . . . his extraordinary
mixture of coolness and audacity. It's the danger that attracts him.
He throws himself into the fire, and he doesn't get burnt. For the
last ten years I've been saying to myself, 'Here we are: this time
I've got him! . . . At last I'm going to nab him.' But I've said that
day after day," said Guerchard; and he paused.
"Well?" said the Duke.
"Well, the days pass; and I never nab him. Oh, he is thick, I tell
you. . . . He's a joker, he is . . . a regular artist"—he ground his
teeth—"The damned thief!"
The Duke looked at him, and said slowly, "Then you think that to-
"You've followed the scent with me, your Grace," Guerchard
interrupted quickly and vehemently. "We've picked up each clue
together. You've almost seen this man at work. . . . You've
understood him. Isn't a man like this, I ask you, capable of
"He is," said the Duke, with conviction.
"Well, then," said Guerchard.
"Perhaps you're right," said the Duke.
Guerchard turned to Dieusy and said, in a quieter voice, "And when
the scavenger had picked up the cigarette, did he follow the
"Yes, he followed him for about a hundred yards. He went down into
Sureau Street, and turned westwards. Then a motor-car came along; he
got into it, and went off."
"What kind of a motor-car?" said Guerchard.
"A big car, and dark red in colour," said Dieusy.
"The Limousine!" cried the Duke.
"That's all I've got so far, sir," said Dieusy.
"Well, off you go," said Guerchard. "Now that you've got started,
you'll probably get something else before very long."
Dieusy saluted and went.
"Things are beginning to move," said Guerchard cheerfully. "First
Victoire, and now this motor-van."
"They are indeed," said the Duke.
"After all, it ought not to be very difficult to trace that motor-
van," said Guerchard, in a musing tone. "At any rate, its movements
ought to be easy enough to follow up till about six. Then, of course,
there would be a good many others about, delivering goods."
"You seem to have all the possible information you can want at your
finger-ends," said the Duke, in an admiring tone.
"I suppose I know the life of Paris as well as anybody," said
They were silent for a while. Then Germaine's maid, Irma, came into
the room and said:
"If you please, your Grace, Mademoiselle Kritchnoff would like to
speak to you for a moment."
"Oh? Where is she?" said the Duke.
"She's in her room, your Grace."
"Oh, very well, I'll go up to her," said the Duke. "I can speak to
her in the library."
He rose and was going towards the door when Guerchard stepped
forward, barring his way, and said, "No, your Grace."
"No? Why?" said the Duke haughtily.
"I beg you will wait a minute or two till I've had a word with
you," said Guerchard; and he drew a folded sheet of paper from his
pocket and held it up.
The Duke looked at Guerchard's face, and he looked at the paper in
his hand; then he said: "Oh, very well." And, turning to Irma, he
added quietly, "Tell Mademoiselle Kritchnoff that I'm in the
"Yes, your Grace, in the drawing-room," said Irma; and she turned
"Yes; and say that I shall be engaged for the next five
minutes—the next five minutes, do you understand?" said the Duke.
"Yes, your Grace," said Irma; and she went out of the door.
"Ask Mademoiselle Kritchnoff to put on her hat and cloak," said
"Yes, sir," said Irma; and she went.
The Duke turned sharply on Guerchard, and said: "Now, why on earth?
. . . I don't understand."
"I got this from M. Formery," said Guerchard, holding up the paper.
"Well," said the Duke. "What is it?"
"It's a warrant, your Grace," said Guerchard.
"What! . . . A warrant! . . . Not for the arrest of Mademoiselle
"Yes," said Guerchard.
"Oh, come, it's impossible," said the Duke. "You're never going to
arrest that child?"
"I am, indeed," said Guerchard. "Her examination this afternoon was
in the highest degree unsatisfactory. Her answers were embarrassed,
contradictory, and in every way suspicious."
"And you've made up your mind to arrest her?" said the Duke slowly,
knitting his brow in anxious thought.
"I have, indeed," said Guerchard. "And I'm going to do it now. The
prison van ought to be waiting at the door." He looked at his watch.
"She and Victoire can go together."
"So . . . you're going to arrest her . . . you're going to arrest
her?" said the Duke thoughtfully: and he took a step or two up and
down the room, still thinking hard.
"Well, you understand the position, don't you, your Grace?" said
Guerchard, in a tone of apology. "Believe me that, personally, I've
no animosity against Mademoiselle Kritchnoff. In fact, the child
"Yes," said the Duke softly, in a musing tone. "She has the air of
a child who has lost its way . . . lost its way in life. . . . And
that poor little hiding-place she found . . . that rolled-up
handkerchief . . . thrown down in the corner of the little room in
the house next door . . . it was absolutely absurd."
"What! A handkerchief!" cried Guerchard, with an air of sudden,
"The child's clumsiness is positively pitiful," said the Duke.
"What was in the handkerchief? . . . The pearls of the pendant?"
"Yes: I supposed you knew all about it. Of course M. Formery left
word for you," said the Duke, with an air of surprise at the
ignorance of the detective.
"No: I've heard nothing about it," cried Guerchard.
"He didn't leave word for you?" said the Duke, in a tone of greater
surprise. "Oh, well, I dare say that he thought to-morrow would do.
Of course you were out of the house when he found it. She must have
slipped out of her room soon after you went."
"He found a handkerchief belonging to Mademoiselle Kritchnoff.
Where is it?" cried Guerchard.
"M. Formery took the pearls, but he left the handkerchief. I
suppose it's in the corner where he found it," said the Duke.
"He left the handkerchief?" cried Guerchard. "If that isn't just
like the fool! He ought to keep hens; it's all he's fit for!"
He ran to the fireplace, seized the lantern, and began lighting it:
"Where is the handkerchief?" he cried.
"In the left-hand corner of the little room on the right on the
second floor. But if you're going to arrest Mademoiselle Kritchnoff,
why are you bothering about the handkerchief? It can't be of any
importance," said the Duke.
"I beg your pardon," said Guerchard. "But it is."
"But why?" said the Duke.
"I was arresting Mademoiselle Kritchnoff all right because I had a
very strong presumption of her guilt. But I hadn't the slightest
proof of it," said Guerchard.
"What?" cried the Duke, in a horrified tone.
"No, you've just given me the proof; and since she was able to hide
the pearls in the house next door, she knew the road which led to it.
Therefore she's an accomplice," said Guerchard, in a triumphant tone.
"What? Do you think that, too?" cried the Duke. "Good Heavens! And
it's me! . . . It's my senselessness! . . . It's my fault that you've
got your proof!" He spoke in a tone of acute distress.
"It was your duty to give it me," said Guerchard sternly; and he
began to mount the steps.
"Shall I come with you? I know where the handkerchief is," said the
"No, thank you, your Grace," said Guerchard. "I prefer to go
"You'd better let me help you," said the Duke.
"No, your Grace," said Guerchard firmly.
"I must really insist," said the Duke.
"No—no—no," said Guerchard vehemently, with stern decision. "It's
no use your insisting, your Grace; I prefer to go alone. I shall only
be gone a minute or two."
"Just as you like," said the Duke stiffly.
The legs of Guerchard disappeared up the steps. The Duke stood
listening with all his ears. Directly he heard the sound of
Guerchard's heels on the floor, when he dropped from the chimney-
piece of the next room, he went swiftly to the door, opened it, and
went out. Bonavent was sitting on the chair on which the young
policeman had sat during the afternoon. Sonia, in her hat and cloak,
was half-way down the stairs.
The Duke put his head inside the drawing-room door, and said to the
empty room: "Here is Mademoiselle Kritchnoff, M. Guerchard." He held
open the door, Sonia came down the stairs, and went through it. The
Duke followed her into the drawing-room, and shut the door.
"There's not a moment to lose," he said in a low voice.
"Oh, what is it, your Grace?" said Sonia anxiously.
"Guerchard has a warrant for your arrest."
"Then I'm lost!" cried Sonia, in a panic-stricken voice.
"No, you're not. You must go—at once," said the Duke.
"But how can I go? No one can get out of the house. M. Guerchard
won't let them," cried Sonia, panic-stricken.
"We can get over that," said the Duke.
He ran to Guerchard's cloak, took the card-case from the inner
pocket, went to the writing-table, and sat down. He took from his
waist-coat pocket the permit which Guerchard had given him, and a
pencil. Then he took a card from the card-case, set the permit on the
table before him, and began to imitate Guerchard's handwriting with an
amazing exactness. He wrote on the card:
"Pass Mademoiselle Kritchnoff."
Sonia stood by his side, panting quickly with fear, and watched him
do it. He had scarcely finished the last stroke, when they heard a
noise on the other side of the opening into the empty house. The Duke
looked at the fireplace, and his teeth bared in an expression of cold
ferocity. He rose with clenched fists, and took a step towards the
"Your Grace? Your Grace?" called the voice of Guerchard.
"What is it?" answered the Duke quietly.
"I can't see any handkerchief," said Guerchard. "Didn't you say it
was in the left-hand corner of the little room on the right?"
"I told you you'd better let me come with you, and find it," said
the Duke, in a tone of triumph. "It's in the right-hand corner of the
little room on the left."
"I could have sworn you said the little room on the right," said
They heard his footfalls die away.
"Now, you must get out of the house quickly." said the Duke. "Show
this card to the detectives at the door, and they'll pass you without
He pressed the card into her hand.
"But—but—this card?" stammered Sonia.
"There's no time to lose," said the Duke.
"But this is madness," said Sonia. "When Guerchard finds out about
this card—that you—you—"
"There's no need to bother about that," interrupted the Duke
quickly. "Where are you going to?"
"A little hotel near the Star. I've forgotten the name of it," said
Sonia. "But this card—"
"Has it a telephone?" said the Duke.
"Yes—No. 555, Central," said Sonia.
"If I haven't telephoned to you before half-past eight to-morrow
morning, come straight to my house," said the Duke, scribbling the
telephone number on his shirt-cuff.
"Yes, yes," said Sonia. "But this card. . . . When Guerchard knows
. . . when he discovers. . . . Oh, I can't let you get into trouble
"I shan't. But go—go," said the Duke, and he slipped his right arm
round her and drew her to the door.
"Oh, how good you are to me," said Sonia softly.
The Duke's other arm went round her; he drew her to him, and their
He loosed her, and opened the door, saying loudly: "You're sure you
won't have a cab, Mademoiselle Kritchnoff?"
"No; no, thank you, your Grace. Goodnight," said Sonia. And she
went through the door with a transfigured face.
The Duke shut the door and leant against it, listening anxiously,
breathing quickly. There came the bang of the front door. With a deep
sigh of relief he left the door, came briskly, smiling, across the
room, and put the card-case back into the pocket of Guerchard's cloak.
He lighted a cigarette, dropped into an easy chair, and sat waiting
with an entirely careless air for the detective's return. Presently he
heard quick footsteps on the bare boards of the empty room beyond the
opening. Then Guerchard came down the steps and out of the fireplace.
His face wore an expression of extreme perplexity:
"I can't understand it," he said." I found nothing."
"Nothing?" said the Duke.
"No. Are you sure you saw the handkerchief in one of those little
rooms on the second floor—quite sure?" said Guerchard.
"Of course I did," said the Duke. "Isn't it there?"
"No," said Guerchard.
"You can't have looked properly," said the Duke, with a touch of
irony in his voice. "If I were you, I should go back and look again."
"No. If I've looked for a thing, I've looked for it. There's no
need for me to look a second time. But, all the same, it's rather
funny. Doesn't it strike you as being rather funny, your Grace?" said
Guerchard, with a worried air.
"It strikes me as being uncommonly funny," said the Duke, with an
Guerchard looked at him with a sudden uneasiness; then he rang the
Bonavent came into the room.
"Mademoiselle Kritchnoff, Bonavent. It's quite time," said
"Mademoiselle Kritchnoff?" said Bonavent, with an air of surprise.
"Yes, it's time that she was taken to the police-station."
"Mademoiselle Kritchnoff has gone, sir," said Bonavent, in a tone
of quiet remonstrance.
"Gone? What do you mean by gone?" said Guerchard.
"Gone, sir, gone!" said Bonavent patiently.
"But you're mad. . . . Mad!" cried Guerchard.
"No, I'm not mad," said Bonavent. "Gone! But who let her go?" cried
"The men at the door," said Bonavent.
"The men at the door," said Guerchard, in a tone of stupefaction.
"But she had to have my permit . . . my permit on my card! Send the
fools up to me!"
Bonavent went to the top of the staircase, and called down it.
Guerchard followed him. Two detectives came hurrying up the stairs
and into the drawing-room.
"What the devil do you mean by letting Mademoiselle Kritchnoff
leave the house without my permit, written on my card?" cried
"But she had your permit, sir, and it WAS written on your card,"
stammered one of the detectives.
"It was? . . . it was?" said Guerchard. "Then, by Jove, it was a
He stood thoughtful for a moment. Then quietly he told his two men
to go back to their post. He did not stir for a minute or two,
puzzling it out, seeking light.
Then he came back slowly into the drawing-room and looked uneasily
at the Duke. The Duke was sitting in his easy chair, smoking a
cigarette with a listless air. Guerchard looked at him, and looked at
him, almost as if he now saw him for the first time.
"Well?" said the Duke, "have you sent that poor child off to
prison? If I'd done a thing like that I don't think I should sleep
very well, M. Guerchard."
"That poor child has just escaped, by means of a forged permit,"
said Guerchard very glumly.
"By Jove, I AM glad to hear that!" cried the Duke. "You'll forgive
my lack of sympathy, M. Guerchard; but she was such a child."
"Not too young to be Lupin's accomplice," said Guerchard drily.
"You really think she is?" said the Duke, in a tone of doubt.
"I'm sure of it," said Guerchard, with decision; then he added
slowly, with a perplexed air:
"But how—how—could she get that forged permit?"
The Duke shook his head, and looked as solemn as an owl. Guerchard
looked at him uneasily, went out of the drawing-room, and shut the
"How long has Mademoiselle Kritchnoff been gone?" he said to
"Not much more than five minutes," said Bonavent. "She came out
from talking to you in the drawing-room—"
"Talking to me in the drawing-room!" exclaimed Guerchard.
"Yes," said Bonavent. "She came out and went straight down the
stairs and out of the house."
A faint, sighing gasp came from Guerchard's lips. He dashed into
the drawing-room, crossed the room quickly to his cloak, picked it up,
took the card-case out of the pocket, and counted the cards in it.
Then he looked at the Duke.
The Duke smiled at him, a charming smile, almost caressing.
There seemed to be a lump in Guerchard's throat; he swallowed it
He put the card-case into the breast-pocket of the coat he was
wearing. Then he cried sharply, "Bonavent! Bonavent!"
Bonavent opened the door, and stood in the doorway.
"You sent off Victoire in the prison-van, I suppose," said
"Oh, a long while ago, sir," said Bonavent.
"The van had been waiting at the door since half-past nine."
"Since half-past nine? . . . But I told them I shouldn't want it
till a quarter to eleven. I suppose they were making an effort to be
in time for once. Well, it doesn't matter," said Guerchard.
"Then I suppose I'd better send the other prison-van away?" said
"What other van?" said Guerchard.
"The van which has just arrived," said Bonavent.
"What! What on earth are you talking about?" cried Guerchard, with
a sudden anxiety in his voice and on his face.
"Didn't you order two prison-vans?" said Bonavent.
Guerchard jumped; and his face went purple with fury and dismay.
"You don't mean to tell me that two prison-vans have been here?" he
"Yes, sir," said Bonavent.
"Damnation!" cried Guerchard. "In which of them did you put
Victoire? In which of them?"
"Why, in the first, sir," said Bonavent.
"Did you see the police in charge of it? The coachman?"
"Yes, sir," said Bonavent.
"Did you recognize them?" said Guerchard.
"No," said Bonavent; "they must have been new men. They told me
they came from the Sante."
"You silly fool!" said Guerchard through his teeth. "A fine lot of
sense you've got."
"Why, what's the matter?" said Bonavent.
"We're done, done in the eye!" roared Guerchard. "It's a stroke—a
"Of Lupin's!" interposed the Duke softly.
"But I don't understand," said Bonavent.
"You don't understand, you idiot!" cried Guerchard. "You've sent
Victoire away in a sham prison-van—a prison-van belonging to Lupin.
Oh, that scoundrel! He always has something up his sleeve."
"He certainly shows foresight," said the Duke. "It was very clever
of him to foresee the arrest of Victoire and provide against it."
"Yes, but where is the leakage? Where is the leakage?" cried
Guerchard, fuming. "How did he learn that the doctor said that she
would recover her wits at ten o'clock? Here I've had a guard at the
door all day; I've imprisoned the household; all the provisions have
been received directly by a man of mine; and here he is, ready to
pick up Victoire the very moment she gives herself away! Where is the
He turned on Bonavent, and went on: "It's no use your standing
there with your mouth open, looking like a fool. Go upstairs to the
servants' quarters and search Victoire's room again. That fool of an
inspector may have missed something, just as he missed Victoire
herself. Get on! Be smart!"
Bonavent went off briskly. Guerchard paced up and down the room,
"Really, I'm beginning to agree with you, M. Guerchard, that this
Lupin is a remarkable man," said the Duke. "That prison-van is
"I'll prison-van him!" cried Guerchard. "But what fools I have to
work with. If I could get hold of people of ordinary intelligence it
would be impossible to play such a trick as that,"
"I don't know about that," said the Duke thoughtfully. "I think it
would have required an uncommon fool to discover that trick."
"What on earth do you mean? Why?" said Guerchard.
"Because it's so wonderfully simple," said the Duke. "And at the
same time it's such infernal cheek."
"There's something in that," said Guerchard grumpily. "But then,
I'm always saying to my men, 'Suspect everything; suspect everybody;
suspect, suspect, suspect.' I tell you, your Grace, that there is
only one motto for the successful detective, and that is that one
"It can't be a very comfortable business, then," said the Duke.
"But I suppose it has its charms."
"Oh, one gets used to the disagreeable part," said Guerchard.
The telephone bell rang; and he rose and went to it. He put the
receiver to his ear and said, "Yes; it's I—Chief-Inspector
He turned and said to the Duke, "It's the gardener at Charmerace,
"Is it?" said the Duke indifferently.
Guerchard turned to the telephone. "Are you there?" he said. "Can
you hear me clearly? . . . I want to know who was in your hot-house
yesterday . . . who could have gathered some of your pink salvias?"
"I told you that it was I," said the Duke.
"Yes, yes, I know," said Guerchard. And he turned again to the
telephone. "Yes, yesterday," he said. "Nobody else? . . . No one but
the Duke of Charmerace? . . . Are you sure?. . . quite sure?. ..
absolutely sure? .. Yes, that's all I wanted to know . . . thank
He turned to the Duke and said, "Did you hear that, your Grace? The
gardener says that you were the only person in his hot-houses
yesterday, the only person who could have plucked any pink salvias."
"Does he?" said the Duke carelessly.
Guerchard looked at him, his brow knitted in a faint, pondering
frown. Then the door opened, and Bonavent came in: "I've been through
Victoire's room," he said, "and all I could find that might be of any
use is this—a prayer-book. It was on her dressing-table just as she
left it. The inspector hadn't touched it."
"What about it?" said Guerchard, taking the prayer-book.
"There's a photograph in it," said Bonavent. "It may come in useful
when we circulate her description; for I suppose we shall try to get
hold of Victoire."
Guerchard took the photograph from the prayer-book and looked at
it: "It looks about ten years old," he said. "It's a good deal faded
for reproduction. Hullo! What have we here?"
The photograph showed Victoire in her Sunday best, and with her a
boy of seventeen or eighteen. Guerchard's eyes glued themselves to
the face of the boy. He stared at it, holding the portrait now
nearer, now further off. His eyes kept stealing covertly from the
photograph to the face of the Duke.
The Duke caught one of those covert glances, and a vague uneasiness
flickered in his eyes. Guerchard saw it. He came nearer to the Duke
and looked at him earnestly, as if he couldn't believe his eyes.
"What's the matter?" said the Duke. "What are you looking at so
curiously? Isn't my tie straight?" And he put up his hand and felt
"Oh, nothing, nothing," said Guerchard. And he studied the
photograph again with a frowning face.
There was a noise of voices and laughter in the hall.
"Those people are going," said the Duke. "I must go down and say
good-bye to them." And he rose and went out of the room.
Guerchard stood staring, staring at the photograph.
The Duke ran down the stairs, and said goodbye to the millionaire's
guests. After they had gone, M. Gournay-Martin went quickly up the
stairs; Germaine and the Duke followed more slowly.
"My father is going to the Ritz to sleep," said Germaine, "and I'm
going with him. He doesn't like the idea of my sleeping in this house
to-night. I suppose he's afraid that Lupin will make an attack in
force with all his gang. Still, if he did, I think that Guerchard
could give a good account of himself—he's got men enough in the
house, at any rate. Irma tells me it's swarming with them. It would
never do for me to be in the house if there were a fight."
"Oh, come, you don't really believe that Lupin is coming to-night?"
said the Duke, with a sceptical laugh. "The whole thing is sheer
bluff—he has no more intention of coming tonight to steal that
coronet than—than I have."
"Oh, well, there's no harm in being on the safe side," said
Germaine. "Everybody's agreed that he's a very terrible person. I'll
just run up to my room and get a wrap; Irma has my things all packed.
She can come round tomorrow morning to the Ritz and dress me."
She ran up the stairs, and the Duke went into the drawing-room. He
found Guerchard standing where he had left him, still frowning, still
"The family are off to the Ritz. It's rather a reflection on your
powers of protecting them, isn't it?" said the Duke.
"Oh, well, I expect they'd be happier out of the house," said
Guerchard. He looked at the Duke again with inquiring, searching
"What's the matter?" said the Duke. "IS my tie crooked?"
"Oh, no, no; it's quite straight, your Grace," said Guerchard, but
he did not take his eyes from the Duke's face.
The door opened, and in came M. Gournay-Martin, holding a bag in
his hand. "It seems to be settled that I'm never to sleep in my own
house again," he said in a grumbling tone.
"There's no reason to go," said the Duke. "Why ARE you going?"
"Danger," said M. Gournay-Martin. "You read Lupin's telegram: 'I
shall come to-night between a quarter to twelve and midnight to take
the coronet.' He knows that it was in my bedroom. Do you think I'm
going to sleep in that room with the chance of that scoundrel turning
up and cutting my throat?"
"Oh. you can have a dozen policemen in the room if you like," said
the Duke. "Can't he, M. Guerchard?"
"Certainly," said Guerchard. "I can answer for it that you will be
in no danger, M. Gournay-Martin."
"Thank you," said the millionaire. "But all the same, outside is
good enough for me."
Germaine came into the room, cloaked and ready to start.
"For once in a way you are ready first, papa," she said. "Are you
"No; I think I'll stay here, on the chance that Lupin is not
bluffing," said the Duke. "I don't think, myself, that I'm going to
be gladdened by the sight of him—in fact, I'm ready to bet against
it. But you're all so certain about it that I really must stay on the
chance. And, after all, there's no doubt that he's a man of immense
audacity and ready to take any risk."
"Well, at any rate, if he does come he won't find the diadem," said
M. Gournay-Martin, in a tone of triumph. "I'm taking it with me—
I've got it here." And he held up his bag.
"You are?" said the Duke.
"Yes, I am," said M. Gournay-Martin firmly.
"Do you think it's wise?" said the Duke.
"Why not?" said M. Gournay-Martin.
"If Lupin's really made up his mind to collar that coronet, and if
you're so sure that, in spite of all these safeguards, he's going to
make the attempt, it seems to me that you're taking a considerable
risk. He asked you to have it ready for him in your bedroom. He
didn't say which bedroom."
"Good Lord! I never thought of that!" said M. Gournay-Martin, with
an air of sudden and very lively alarm.
"His Grace is right," said Guerchard. "It would be exactly like
Lupin to send that telegram to drive you out of the house with the
coronet to some place where you would be less protected. That is
exactly one of his tricks."
"Good Heavens!" said the millionaire, pulling out his keys and
unlocking the bag. He opened it, paused hesitatingly, and snapped it
"Half a minute," he said. "I want a word with you, Duke."
He led the way out of the drawing-room door and the Duke followed
him. He shut the door and said in a whisper:
"In a case like this, I suspect everybody."
"Everybody suspects everybody, apparently," said the Duke. "Are you
sure you don't suspect me?"
"Now, now, this is no time for joking," said the millionaire
impatiently. "What do you think about Guerchard?"
"About Guerchard?" said the Duke. "What do you mean?"
"Do you think I can put full confidence in Guerchard?" said M.
"Oh, I think so," said the Duke. "Besides, I shall be here to look
after Guerchard. And, though I wouldn't undertake to answer for
Lupin, I think I can answer for Guerchard. If he tries to escape with
the coronet, I will wring his neck for you with pleasure. It would do
me good. And it would do Guerchard good, too."
The millionaire stood reflecting for a minute or two. Then he said,
"Very good; I'll trust him."
hardly had the door closed behind the millionaire and the Duke,
when Guerchard crossed the room quickly to Germaine and drew from his
pocket the photograph of Victoire and the young man.
"Do you know this photograph of his Grace, mademoiselle?" he said
Germaine took the photograph and looked at it.
"It's rather faded," she said.
"Yes; it's about ten years old," said Guerchard.
"I seem to know the face of the woman," said Germaine. "But if it's
ten years old it certainly isn't the photograph of the Duke."
"But it's like him?" said Guerchard.
"Oh, yes, it's like the Duke as he is now—at least, it's a little
like him. But it's not like the Duke as he was ten years ago. He has
changed so," said Germaine.
"Oh, has he?" said Guerchard.
"Yes; there was that exhausting journey of his—and then his
illness. The doctors gave up all hope of him, you know."
"Oh, did they?" said Guerchard.
"Yes; at Montevideo. But his health is quite restored now."
The door opened and the millionaire and the Duke came into the
room. M. Gournay-Martin set his bag upon the table, unlocked it, and
with a solemn air took out the case which held the coronet. He opened
it; and they looked at it.
"Isn't it beautiful?" he said with a sigh.
"Marvellous!" said the Duke.
M. Gournay-Martin closed the case, and said solemnly:
"There is danger, M. Guerchard, so I am going to trust the coronet
to you. You are the defender of my hearth and home—you are the
proper person to guard the coronet. I take it that you have no
"Not the slightest, M. Gournay-Martin," said Guerchard. "It's
exactly what I wanted you to ask me to do."
M. Gournay-Martin hesitated. Then he handed the coronet to
Guerchard, saying with a frank and noble air, "I have every
confidence in you, M. Guerchard."
"Thank you," said Guerchard.
"Good-night," said M. Gournay-Martin.
"Good-night, M. Guerchard," said Germaine.
"I think, after all, I'll change my mind and go with you. I'm very
short of sleep," said the Duke. "Good-night, M. Guerchard."
"You're never going too, your Grace!" cried Guerchard.
"Why, you don't want me to stay, do you?" said the Duke.
"Yes," said Guerchard slowly.
"I think I would rather go to bed," said the Duke gaily.
"Are you afraid?" said Guerchard, and there was challenge, almost
an insolent challenge, in his tone.
There was a pause. The Duke frowned slightly with a reflective air.
Then he drew himself up; and said a little haughtily:
"You've certainly found the way to make me stay, M. Guerchard."
"Yes, yes; stay, stay," said M. Gournay-Martin hastily. "It's an
excellent idea, excellent. You're the very man to help M. Guerchard,
Duke. You're an intrepid explorer, used to danger and resourceful,
"Do you really mean to say you're not going home to bed, Jacques?"
said Germaine, disregarding her father's wish with her usual
"No; I'm going to stay with M. Guerchard," said the Duke slowly.
"Well, you will be fresh to go to the Princess's to-morrow night."
said Germaine petulantly. "You didn't get any sleep at all last
night, you couldn't have. You left Charmerace at eight o'clock; you
were motoring all the night, and only got to Paris at six o'clock
"Motoring all night, from eight o'clock to six!" muttered Guerchard
under his breath.
"Oh, that will be all right," said the Duke carelessly. "This
interesting affair is to be over by midnight, isn't it?"
"Well, I warn you that, tired or fresh, you will have to come with
me to the Princess's to-morrow night. All Paris will be there—all
Paris, that is, who are in Paris."
"Oh, I shall be fresh enough," said the Duke.
They went out of the drawing-room and down the stairs, all four of
them. There was an alert readiness about Guerchard, as if he were
ready to spring. He kept within a foot of the Duke right to the front
door. The detective in charge opened it; and they went down the steps
to the taxi-cab which was awaiting them. The Duke kissed Germaine's
fingers and handed her into the taxi-cab.
M. Gournay-Martin paused at the cab-door, and turned and said, with
a pathetic air, "Am I never to sleep in my own house again?" He got
into the cab and drove off.
The Duke turned and came up the steps, followed by Guerchard. In
the hall he took his opera-hat and coat from the stand, and went
upstairs. Half-way up the flight he paused and said:
"Where shall we wait for Lupin, M. Guerchard? In the drawing-room,
or in M. Gournay-Martin's bedroom?"
"Oh, the drawing-room," said Guerchard. "I think it very unlikely
that Lupin will look for the coronet in M. Gournay-Martin's bedroom.
He would know very well that that is the last place to find it now."
The Duke went on into the drawing-room. At the door Guerchard
stopped and said: "I will just go and post my men, your Grace."
"Very good," said the Duke; and he went into the drawing-room.
He sat down, lighted a cigarette, and yawned. Then he took out his
watch and looked at it.
"Another twenty minutes," he said.
When Guerchard joined the Duke in the drawing-room, he had lost his
calm air and was looking more than a little nervous. He moved about
the room uneasily, fingering the bric-a-brac, glancing at the Duke
and looking quickly away from him again. Then he came to a standstill
on the hearth-rug with his back to the fireplace.
"Do you think it's quite safe to stand there, at least with your
back to the hearth? If Lupin dropped through that opening suddenly,
he'd catch you from behind before you could wink twice," said the
Duke, in a tone of remonstrance.
"There would always be your Grace to come to my rescue," said
Guerchard; and there was an ambiguous note in his voice, while his
piercing eyes now rested fixed on the Duke's face. They seemed never
to leave it; they explored, and explored it.
"It's only a suggestion," said the Duke.
"This is rather nervous work, don't you know."
"Yes; and of course you're hardly fit for it," said Guerchard. "If
I'd known about your break-down in your car last night, I should have
hesitated about asking you—"
"A break-down?" interrupted the Duke.
"Yes, you left Charmerace at eight o'clock last night. And you only
reached Paris at six this morning. You couldn't have had a very
high-power car?" said Guerchard.
"I had a 100 h.-p. car," said the Duke.
"Then you must have had a devil of a break-down," said Guerchard.
"Yes, it was pretty bad, but I've known worse," said the Duke
carelessly. "It lost me about three hours: oh, at least three hours.
I'm not a first-class repairer, though I know as much about an engine
as most motorists."
"And there was nobody there to help you repair it?" said Guerchard.
"No; M. Gournay-Martin could not let me have his chauffeur to drive
me to Paris, because he was keeping him to help guard the chateau.
And of course there was nobody on the road, because it was two
o'clock in the morning."
"Yes, there was no one," said Guerchard slowly.
"Not a soul," said the Duke.
"It was unfortunate," said Guerchard; and there was a note of
incredulity in his voice.
"My having to repair the car myself?" said the Duke.
"Yes, of course," said Guerchard, hesitating a little over the
The Duke dropped the end of his cigarette into a tray, and took out
his case. He held it out towards Guerchard, and said, "A cigarette?
or perhaps you prefer your caporal?"
"Yes, I do, but all the same I'll have one," said Guerchard, coming
quickly across the room. And he took a cigarette from the case, and
looked at it.
"All the same, all this is very curious," he said in a new tone, a
challenging, menacing, accusing tone.
"What?" said the Duke, looking at him curiously.
"Everything: your cigarettes . . . the salvias . . . the photograph
that Bonavent found in Victoire's prayer-book . . . that man in
motoring dress . . . and finally, your break-down," said Guerchard;
and the accusation and the threat rang clearer.
The Duke rose from his chair quickly and said haughtily, in icy
tones: "M. Guerchard. you've been drinking!"
He went to the chair on which he had set his overcoat and his hat,
and picked them up. Guerchard sprang in front of him, barring his
way, and cried in a shaky voice: "No; don't go! You mustn't go!"
"What do you mean?" said the Duke, and paused. "What DO you mean?"
Guerchard stepped back, and ran his hand over his forehead. He was
very pale, and his forehead was clammy to his touch:
"No . . . I beg your pardon . . . I beg your pardon, your Grace .
. . I must be going mad," he stammered.
"It looks very like it," said the Duke coldly.
"What I mean to say is," said Guerchard in a halting, uncertain
voice, "what I mean to say is: help me . . . I want you to stay here,
to help me against Lupin, you understand. Will you, your Grace?"
"Yes, certainly; of course I will, if you want me to," said the
Duke, in a more gentle voice. "But you seem awfully upset, and you're
upsetting me too. We shan't have a nerve between us soon, if you don't
pull yourself together."
"Yes, yes, please excuse me," muttered Guerchard.
"Very good," said the Duke. "But what is it we're going to do?"
Guerchard hesitated. He pulled out his handkerchief, and mopped his
forehead: "Well . . . the coronet . . . is it in this case?" he said
in a shaky voice, and set the case on the table.
"Of course it is," said the Duke impatiently.
Guerchard opened the case, and the coronet sparkled and gleamed
brightly in the electric light: "Yes, it is there; you see it?" said
"Yes, I see it; well?" said the Duke, looking at him in some
bewilderment, so unlike himself did he seem.
"We're going to wait," said Guerchard.
"What for?" said the Duke.
"Lupin," said Guerchard.
"Lupin? And you actually do believe that, just as in a fairy tale,
when that clock strikes twelve, Lupin will enter and take the
"Yes, I do; I do," said Guerchard with stubborn conviction. And he
snapped the case to.
"This is most exciting," said the Duke.
"You're sure it doesn't bore you?" said Guerchard huskily.
"Not a bit of it," said the Duke, with cheerful derision. "To make
the acquaintance of this scoundrel who has fooled you for ten years
is as charming a way of spending the evening as I can think of."
"You say that to me?" said Guerchard with a touch of temper.
"Yes," said the Duke, with a challenging smile. "To you."
He sat down in an easy chair by the table. Guerchard sat down in a
chair on the other side of it, and set his elbows on it. They were
Suddenly the Duke said, "Somebody's coming."
Guerchard started, and said: "No, I don't hear any one."
Then there came distinctly the sound of a footstep and a knock at
"You've got keener ears than I," said Guerchard grudgingly. "In all
this business you've shown the qualities of a very promising
detective." He rose, went to the door, and unlocked it.
Bonavent came in: "I've brought you the handcuffs, sir," he said,
holding them out. "Shall I stay with you?"
"No," said Guerchard. "You've two men at the back door, and two at
the front, and a man in every room on the ground-floor?"
"Yes, and I've got three men on every other floor," said Bonavent,
in a tone of satisfaction.
"And the house next door?" said Guerchard.
"There are a dozen men in it," said Bonavent. "No communication
between the two houses is possible any longer."
Guerchard watched the Duke's face with intent eyes. Not a shadow
flickered its careless serenity.
"If any one tries to enter the house, collar him. If need be, fire
on him," said Guerchard firmly. "That is my order; go and tell the
"Very good, sir," said Bonavent; and he went out of the room.
"By Jove, we are in a regular fortress," said the Duke.
"It's even more of a fortress than you think, your Grace. I've four
men on that landing," said Guerchard, nodding towards the door.
"Oh, have you?" said the Duke, with a sudden air of annoyance.
"You don't like that?" said Guerchard quickly.
"I should jolly well think not," said the Duke. "With these
precautions, Lupin will never be able to get into this room at all."
"He'll find it a pretty hard job," said Guerchard, smiling. "Unless
he falls from the ceiling, or unless—"
"Unless you're Arsene Lupin," interrupted the Duke.
"In that case, you'd be another, your Grace," said Guerchard.
They both laughed. The Duke rose, yawned, picked up his coat and
hat, and said, "Ah, well, I'm off to bed."
"What?" said Guerchard.
"Well," said the Duke, yawning again, "I was staying to see Lupin.
As there's no longer any chance of seeing him—"
"But there is . . . there is . . . so stay," cried Guerchard.
"Do you still cling to that notion?" said the Duke wearily.
"We SHALL see him," said Guerchard.
"Nonsense!" said the Duke.
Guerchard lowered his voice and said with an air of the deepest
secrecy: "He's already here, your Grace."
"Lupin? Here?" cried the Duke.
"Yes; Lupin," said Guerchard.
"Where?" cried the astonished Duke.
"He is," said Guerchard.
"As one of your men?" said the Duke eagerly.
"I don't think so," said Guerchard, watching him closely.
"Well, but, well, but—if he's here we've got him. . . . He is
going to turn up," said the Duke triumphantly; and he set down his hat
on the table beside the coronet.
"I hope so," said Guerchard. "But will he dare to?"
"How do you mean?" said the Duke, with a puzzled air.
"Well, you have said yourself that this is a fortress. An hour ago,
perhaps, Lupin was resolved to enter this room, but is he now?"
"I see what you mean," said the Duke, in a tone of disappointment.
"Yes; you see that now it needs the devil's own courage. He must
risk everything to gain everything, and throw off the mask. Is Lupin
going to throw himself into the wolf's jaws? I dare not think it.
What do you think about it?"
Guerchard's husky voice had hardened to a rough harshness; there
was a ring of acute anxiety in it, and under the anxiety a faint note
of challenge, of a challenge that dare not make itself too distinct.
His anxious, challenging eyes burned on the face of the Duke, as if
they strove with all intensity to pierce a mask.
The Duke looked at him curiously, as if he were trying to divine
what he would be at, but with a careless curiosity, as if it were a
matter of indifference to him what the detective's object was; then
he said carelessly: "Well, you ought to know better than I. You have
known him for ten years . . . ." He paused, and added with just the
faintest stress in his tone, "At least, by reputation."
The anxiety in the detective's face grew plainer, it almost gave
him the air of being unnerved; and he said quickly, in a jerky voice:
"Yes, and I know his way of acting too. During the last ten years I
have learnt to unravel his intrigues—to understand and anticipate
his manoeuvres. . . . Oh, his is a clever system! . . . Instead of
lying low, as you'd expect, he attacks his opponent . . . openly. . .
. He confuses him—at least, he tries to." He smiled a half-
confident, a half-doubtful smile, "It is a mass of entangled,
mysterious combinations. I've been caught in them myself again and
again. You smile?"
"It interests me so," said the Duke, in a tone of apology.
"Oh, it interests me," said Guerchard, with a snarl. "But this time
I see my way clearly. No more tricks—no more secret paths . . .
We're fighting in the light of day." He paused, and said in a clear,
sneering voice, "Lupin has pluck, perhaps, but it's only thief's
"Oh, is it?" said the Duke sharply, and there was a sudden faint
glitter in his eyes.
"Yes; rogues have very poor qualities," sneered Guerchard.
"One can't have everything," said the Duke quietly; but his languid
air had fallen from him.
"Their ambushes, their attacks, their fine tactics aren't up to
much," said Guerchard, smiling contemptuously.
"You go a trifle too far, I think," said the Duke, smiling with
They looked one another in the eyes with a long, lingering look.
They had suddenly the air of fencers who have lost their tempers, and
are twisting the buttons off their foils.
"Not a bit of it, your Grace," said Guerchard; and his voice
lingered on the words "your Grace" with a contemptuous stress. "This
famous Lupin is immensely overrated."
"However, he has done some things which aren't half bad," said the
Duke, with his old charming smile.
He had the air of a duelist drawing his blade lovingly through his
fingers before he falls to.
"Oh, has he?" said Guerchard scornfully.
"Yes; one must be fair. Last night's burglary, for instance: it is
not unheard of, but it wasn't half bad. And that theft of the
motorcars: it was a neat piece of work," said the Duke in a gentle,
insolent voice, infinitely aggravating.
Guerchard snorted scornfully.
"And a robbery at the British Embassy, another at the Treasury, and
a third at M. Lepine's—all in the same week—it wasn't half bad,
don't you know?" said the Duke, in the same gentle, irritating voice.
"Oh, no, it wasn't. But—"
"And the time when he contrived to pass as Guerchard—the Great
Guerchard—do you remember that?" the Duke interrupted. "Come, come-
-to give the devil his due—between ourselves—it wasn't half bad."
"No," snarled Guerchard. "But he has done better than that lately.
. . . Why don't you speak of that?"
"Of what?" said the Duke.
"Of the time when he passed as the Duke of Charmerace," snapped
"What! Did he do that?" cried the Duke; and then he added slowly,
"But, you know, I'm like you—I'm so easy to imitate."
"What would have been amusing, your Grace, would have been to get
as far as actual marriage," said Guerchard more calmly.
"Oh, if he had wanted to," said the Duke; and he threw out his
hands. "But you know—married life—for Lupin."
"A large fortune . . . a pretty girl," said Guerchard, in a mocking
"He must be in love with some one else," said the Duke.
"A thief, perhaps," sneered Guerchard.
"Like himself. . . . And then, if you wish to know what I think, he
must have found his fiancee rather trying," said the Duke, with his
"After all, it's pitiful—heartrending, you must admit it, that, on
the very eve of his marriage, he was such a fool as to throw off the
mask. And yet at bottom it's quite logical; it's Lupin coming out
through Charmerace. He had to grab at the dowry at the risk of losing
the girl," said Guerchard, in a reflective tone; but his eyes were
intent on the face of the Duke.
"Perhaps that's what one should call a marriage of reason," said
the Duke, with a faint smile.
"What a fall!" said Guerchard, in a taunting voice. "To be
expected, eagerly, at the Princess's to-morrow evening, and to pass
the evening in a police-station . . . to have intended in a month's
time, as the Duke of Charmerace, to mount the steps of the Madeleine
with all pomp and to fall down the father-in-law's staircase this
evening—this very evening"—his voice rose suddenly on a note of
savage triumph—"with the handcuffs on! What? Is that a good enough
revenge for Guerchard—for that poor old idiot, Guerchard? The
rogues' Brummel in a convict's cap! The gentleman-burglar in a gaol!
For Lupin it's only a trifling annoyance, but for a duke it's a
disaster! Come, in your turn, be frank: don't you find that amusing?"
The Duke rose quietly, and said coldly, "Have you finished?"
"DO you?" cried Guerchard; and he rose and faced him.
"Oh, yes; I find it quite amusing," said the Duke lightly.
"And so do I," cried Guerchard.
"No; you're frightened," said the Duke calmly.
"Frightened!" cried Guerchard, with a savage laugh.
"Yes, you're frightened," said the Duke. "And don't think,
policeman, that because I'm familiar with you, I throw off a mask. I
don't wear one. I've none to throw off. I AM the Duke of Charmerace."
"You lie! You escaped from the Sante four years ago. You are Lupin!
I recognize you now."
"Prove it," said the Duke scornfully.
"I will!" cried Guerchard.
"You won't. I AM the Duke of Charmerace."
Guerchard laughed wildly.
"Don't laugh. You know nothing—nothing, dear boy," said the Duke
"Dear boy?" cried Guerchard triumphantly, as if the word had been a
"What do I risk?" said the Duke, with scathing contempt. "Can you
arrest me? . . . You can arrest Lupin . . . but arrest the Duke of
Charmerace, an honourable gentleman, member of the Jockey Club, and
of the Union, residing at his house, 34 B, University Street . . .
arrest the Duke of Charmerace, the fiance of Mademoiselle Gournay-
"Scoundrel!" cried Guerchard, pale with sudden, helpless fury.
"Well, do it," taunted the Duke. "Be an ass. . . . Make yourself
the laughing-stock of Paris . . . call your coppers in. Have you a
proof—one single proof? Not one."
"Oh, I shall get them," howled Guerchard, beside himself.
"I think you may," said the Duke coolly. "And you might be able to
arrest me next week . . . the day after to-morrow perhaps . . .
perhaps never . . . but not to-night, that's certain."
"Oh, if only somebody could hear you!" gasped Guerchard.
"Now, don't excite yourself," said the Duke. "That won't produce
any proofs for you. . . . The fact is, M. Formery told you the truth
when he said that, when it is a case of Lupin, you lose your head.
Ah, that Formery—there is an intelligent man if you like."
"At all events, the coronet is safe . . . to-night—"
"Wait, my good chap . . . wait," said the Duke slowly; and then he
snapped out: "Do you know what's behind that door?" and he flung out
his hand towards the door of the inner drawing-room, with a
mysterious, sinister air.
"What?" cried Guerchard; and he whipped round and faced the door,
with his eyes starting out of his head.
"Get out, you funk!" said the Duke, with a great laugh.
"Hang you!" said Guerchard shrilly.
"I said that you were going to be absolutely pitiable," said the
Duke, and he laughed again cruelly.
"Oh, go on talking, do!" cried Guerchard, mopping his forehead.
"Absolutely pitiable," said the Duke, with a cold, disquieting
certainty. "As the hand of that clock moves nearer and nearer
midnight, you will grow more and more terrified." He paused, and then
shouted violently, "Attention!"
Guerchard jumped; and then he swore.
"Your nerves are on edge," said the Duke, laughing.
"Joker!" snarled Guerchard.
"Oh, you're as brave as the next man. But who can stand the anguish
of the unknown thing which is bound to happen? . . . I'm right. You
feel it, you're sure of it. At the end of these few fixed minutes an
inevitable, fated event must happen. Don't shrug your shoulders, man;
you're green with fear."
The Duke was no longer a smiling, cynical dandy. There emanated
from him an impression of vivid, terrible force. His voice had
deepened. It thrilled with a consciousness of irresistible power; it
was overwhelming, paralyzing. His eyes were terrible.
"My men are outside . . . I'm armed," stammered Guerchard.
"Child! Bear in mind . . . bear in mind that it is always when you
have foreseen everything, arranged everything, made every combination
. . . bear in mind that it is always then that some accident dashes
your whole structure to the ground," said the Duke, in the same deep,
thrilling voice." Remember that it is always at the very moment at
which you are going to triumph that he beats you, that he only lets
you reach the top of the ladder to throw you more easily to the
"Confess, then, that you are Lupin," muttered Guerchard.
"I thought you were sure of it," said the Duke in a jeering tone.
Guerchard dragged the handcuffs out of his pocket, and said between
his teeth, "I don't know what prevents me, my boy."
The Duke drew himself up, and said haughtily, "That's enough."
"What?" cried Guerchard.
"I say that that's enough," said the Duke sternly. "It's all very
well for me to play at being familiar with you, but don't you call me
"Oh, you won't impose on me much longer," muttered Guerchard; and
his bloodshot, haggard eyes scanned the Duke's face in an agony, an
anguish of doubting impotence.
"If I'm Lupin, arrest me," said the Duke.
"I'll arrest you in three minutes from now, or the coronet will be
untouched," cried Guerchard in a firmer tone.
"In three minutes from now the coronet will have been stolen; and
you will not arrest me," said the Duke, in a tone of chilling
"But I will! I swear I will!" cried Guerchard.
"Don't swear any foolish oaths! . . . THERE ARE ONLY TWO MINUTES
LEFT," said the Duke; and he drew a revolver from his pocket.
"No, you don't!" cried Guerchard, drawing a revolver in his turn.
"What's the matter?" said the Duke, with an air of surprise. "You
haven't forbidden me to shoot Lupin. I have my revolver ready, since
he's going to come. . . . THERE'S ONLY A MINUTE LEFT."
"There are plenty of us," said Guerchard; and he went towards the
"Funk!" said the Duke scornfully.
Guerchard turned sharply. "Very well," he said, "I'll stick it out
"How rash!" sneered the Duke.
Guerchard ground his teeth. He was panting; his bloodshot eyes
rolled in their sockets; the beads of cold sweat stood out on his
forehead. He came back towards the table on unsteady feet, trembling
from head to foot in the last excitation of the nerves. He kept
jerking his head to shake away the mist which kept dimming his eyes.
"At your slightest gesture, at your slightest movement, I'll fire,"
he said jerkily, and covered the Duke with his revolver.
"I call myself the Duke of Charmerace. You will be arrested to-
morrow!" said the Duke, in a compelling, thrilling voice.
"I don't care a curse!" cried Guerchard.
"Only FIFTY SECONDS!" said the Duke.
"Yes, yes," muttered Guerchard huskily. And his eyes shot from the
coronet to the Duke, from the Duke to the coronet.
"In fifty seconds the coronet will be stolen," said the Duke.
"No!" cried Guerchard furiously.
"Yes," said the Duke coldly.
"No! no! no!" cried Guerchard.
Their eyes turned to the clock.
To Guerchard the hands seemed to be standing still. He could have
sworn at them for their slowness.
Then the first stroke rang out; and the eyes of the two men met
like crossing blades. Twice the Duke made the slightest movement.
Twice Guerchard started forward to meet it.
At the last stroke both their hands shot out. Guerchard's fell
heavily on the case which held the coronet. The Duke's fell on the
brim of his hat; and he picked it up.
Guerchard gasped and choked. Then he cried triumphantly:
"I HAVE it; now then, have I won? Have I been fooled this time? Has
Lupin got the coronet?"
"It doesn't look like it. But are you quite sure?" said the Duke
"Sure?" cried Guerchard.
"It's only the weight of it," said the Duke, repressing a laugh.
"Doesn't it strike you that it's just a trifle light?"
"What?" cried Guerchard.
"This is merely an imitation." said the Duke, with a gentle laugh.
"Hell and damnation!" howled Guerchard. "Bonavent! Dieusy!"
The door flew open, and half a dozen detectives rushed in.
Guerchard sank into a chair, stupefied, paralyzed; this blow, on
the top of the strain of the struggle with the Duke, had broken him.
"Gentlemen," said the Duke sadly, "the coronet has been stolen."
They broke into cries of surprise and bewilderment, surrounding the
gasping Guerchard with excited questions.
The Duke walked quietly out of the room.
Guerchard sobbed twice; his eyes opened, and in a dazed fashion
wandered from face to face; he said faintly: "Where is he?"
"Where's who?" said Bonavent.
"The Duke—the Duke!" gasped Guerchard.
"Why, he's gone!" said Bonavent.
Guerchard staggered to his feet and cried hoarsely, frantically:
"Stop him from leaving the house! Follow him! Arrest him! Catch him
before he gets home!"
The cold light of the early September morning illumined but dimly
the charming smoking-room of the Duke of Charmerace in his house at
34 B, University Street, though it stole in through two large
windows. The smoking-room was on the first floor; and the Duke's
bedroom opened into it. It was furnished in the most luxurious
fashion, but with a taste which nowadays infrequently accompanies
luxury. The chairs were of the most comfortable, but their lines were
excellent; the couch against the wall, between the two windows, was
the last word in the matter of comfort. The colour scheme, of a light
greyish-blue, was almost too bright for a man's room; it would have
better suited a boudoir. It suggested that the owner of the room
enjoyed an uncommon lightness and cheerfulness of temperament. On the
walls, with wide gaps between them so that they did not clash, hung
three or four excellent pictures. Two ballet-girls by Degas, a group
of shepherdesses and shepherds, in pink and blue and white beribboned
silk, by Fragonard, a portrait of a woman by Bastien-Lepage, a
charming Corot, and two Conder fans showed that the taste of their
fortunate owner was at any rate eclectic. At the end of the room was,
of all curious things, the opening into the well of a lift. The doors
of it were open, though the lift itself was on some other floor. To
the left of the opening stood a book- case, its shelves loaded with
books of a kind rather suited to a cultivated, thoughtful man than to
an idle dandy.
Beside the window, half-hidden, and peering through the side of the
curtain into the street, stood M. Charolais. But it was hardly the M.
Charolais who had paid M. Gournay-Martin that visit at the Chateau de
Charmerace, and departed so firmly in the millionaire's favourite
motor-car. This was a paler M. Charolais; he lacked altogether the
rich, ruddy complexion of the millionaire's visitor. His nose, too,
was thinner, and showed none of the ripe acquaintance with the
vintages of the world which had been so plainly displayed on it during
its owner's visit to the country. Again, hair and eyebrows were no
longer black, but fair; and his hair was no longer curly and
luxuriant, but thin and lank. His moustache had vanished, and along
with it the dress of a well-to-do provincial man of business. He wore
a livery of the Charmeraces, and at that early morning hour had not
yet assumed the blue waistcoat which is an integral part of it. Indeed
it would have required an acute and experienced observer to recognize
in him the bogus purchaser of the Mercrac. Only his eyes, his
close-set eyes, were unchanged.
Walking restlessly up and down the middle of the room, keeping out
of sight of the windows, was Victoire. She wore a very anxious air,
as did Charolais too. By the door stood Bernard Charolais; and his
natural, boyish timidity, to judge from his frightened eyes, had
assumed an acute phase.
"By the Lord, we're done!" cried Charolais, starting back from the
window. "That was the front-door bell."
"No, it was only the hall clock," said Bernard.
"That's seven o'clock! Oh, where can he be?" said Victoire,
wringing her hands. "The coup was fixed for midnight. . . . Where can
"They must be after him," said Charolais. "And he daren't come
home." Gingerly he drew back the curtain and resumed his watch.
"I've sent down the lift to the bottom, in case he should come back
by the secret entrance," said Victoire; and she went to the opening
into the well of the lift and stood looking down it, listening with
all her ears.
"Then why, in the devil's name, have you left the doors open?"
cried Charolais irritably. "How do you expect the lift to come up if
the doors are open?"
"I must be off my head!" cried Victoire.
She stepped to the side of the lift and pressed a button. The doors
closed, and there was a grunting click of heavy machinery settling
into a new position.
"Suppose we telephone to Justin at the Passy house?" said Victoire.
"What on earth's the good of that?" said Charolais impatiently.
"Justin knows no more than we do. How can he know any more?"
"The best thing we can do is to get out," said Bernard, in a shaky
"No, no; he will come. I haven't given up hope," Victoire
protested. "He's sure to come; and he may need us."
"But, hang it all! Suppose the police come! Suppose they ransack
his papers. . . . He hasn't told us what to do . . . we are not ready
for them. . . . What are we to do?" cried Charolais, in a tone of
"Well, I'm worse off than you are; and I'm not making a fuss. If
the police come they'll arrest me," said Victoire.
"Perhaps they've arrested him," said Bernard, in his shaky voice.
"Don't talk like that," said Victoire fretfully. "Isn't it bad
enough to wait and wait, without your croaking like a scared crow?"
She started again her pacing up and down the room, twisting her
hands, and now and again moistening her dry lips with the tip of her
Presently she said: "Are those two plain-clothes men still there
watching?" And in her anxiety she came a step nearer the window.
"Keep away from the window!" snapped Charolais. "Do you want to be
recognized, you great idiot?" Then he added, more quietly, "They're
still there all right, curse them, in front of the cafe. . . .
"What is it, now?" cried Victoire, starting.
"A copper and a detective running," said Charolais. "They are
running for all they're worth."
"Are they coming this way?" said Victoire; and she ran to the door
and caught hold of the handle.
"No," said Charolais.
"Thank goodness!" said Victoire.
"They're running to the two men watching the house . . . they're
telling them something. Oh, hang it, they're all running down the
"This way? . . . Are they coming this way?" cried Victoire faintly;
and she pressed her hand to her side.
"They are!" cried Charolais. "They are!" And he dropped the curtain
with an oath.
"And he isn't here! Suppose they come. . . . Suppose he comes to
the front door! They'll catch him!" cried Victoire.
There came a startling peal at the front-door bell. They stood
frozen to stone, their eyes fixed on one another, staring.
The bell had hardly stopped ringing, when there was a slow,
whirring noise. The doors of the lift flew open, and the Duke stepped
out of it. But what a changed figure from the admirably dressed dandy
who had walked through the startled detectives and out of the house of
M. Gournay-Martin at midnight! He was pale, exhausted, almost
fainting. His eyes were dim in a livid face; his lips were grey. He
was panting heavily. He was splashed with mud from head to foot: one
sleeve of his coat was torn along half its length. The sole of his
left-hand pump was half off; and his cut foot showed white and red
through the torn sock.
"The master! The master!" cried Charolais in a tone of extravagant
relief; and he danced round the room snapping his fingers.
"You're wounded?" cried Victoire.
"No," said Arsene Lupin.
The front-door bell rang out again, startling, threatening,
The note of danger seemed to brace Lupin, to spur him to a last
He pulled himself together, and said in a hoarse but steady voice:
"Your waistcoat, Charolais. . . . Go and open the door . . . not too
quickly . . . fumble the bolts. . . . Bernard, shut the book-case.
Victoire, get out of sight, do you want to ruin us all? Be smart now,
all of you. Be smart!"
He staggered past them into his bedroom, and slammed the door.
Victoire and Charolais hurried out of the room, through the anteroom,
on to the landing. Victoire ran upstairs, Charolais went slowly down.
Bernard pressed the button. The doors of the lift shut and there was a
slow whirring as it went down. He pressed another button, and the
book-case slid slowly across and hid the opening into the lift-well.
Bernard ran out of the room and up the stairs.
Charolais went to the front door and fumbled with the bolts. He
bawled through the door to the visitors not to be in such a hurry at
that hour in the morning; and they bawled furiously at him to be
quick, and knocked and rang again and again. He was fully three
minutes fumbling with the bolts, which were already drawn. At last he
opened the door an inch or two, and looked out.
On the instant the door was dashed open, flinging him back against
the wall; and Bonavent and Dieusy rushed past him, up the stairs, as
hard as they could pelt. A brown-faced, nervous, active policeman
followed them in and stopped to guard the door.
On the landing the detectives paused, and looked at one another,
"Which way did he go?" said Bonavent. "We were on his very heels."
"I don't know; but we've jolly well stopped his getting into his
own house; and that's the main thing," said Dieusy triumphantly.
"But are you sure it was him?" said Bonavent, stepping into the
"I can swear to it," said Dieusy confidently; and he followed him.
Charolais came rushing up the stairs and caught them up as they
were entering the smoking-room:
"Here! What's all this?" he cried. "You mustn't come in here! His
Grace isn't awake yet."
"Awake? Awake? Your precious Duke has been galloping all night,"
cried Dieusy. "And he runs devilish well, too."
The door of the bedroom opened; and Lupin stood on the threshold in
slippers and pyjamas.
"What's all this?" he snapped, with the irritation of a man whose
sleep has been disturbed; and his tousled hair and eyes dim with
exhaustion gave him every appearance of being still heavy with sleep.
The eyes and mouths of Bonavent and Dieusy opened wide; and they
stared at him blankly, in utter bewilderment and wonder.
"Is it you who are making all this noise?" said Lupin, frowning at
them. "Why, I know you two; you're in the service of M. Guerchard."
"Yes, your Grace," stammered Bonavent.
"Well, what are you doing here? What is it you want?" said Lupin.
"Oh, nothing, your Grace . . . nothing . . . there's been a
mistake," stammered Bonavent.
"A mistake?" said Lupin haughtily. "I should think there had been a
mistake. But I take it that this is Guerchard's doing. I'd better
deal with him directly. You two can go." He turned to Charolais and
added curtly, "Show them out."
Charolais opened the door, and the two detectives went out of the
room with the slinking air of whipped dogs. They went down the stairs
in silence, slowly, reflectively; and Charolais let them out of the
As they went down the steps Dieusy said: "What a howler! Guerchard
risks getting the sack for this!"
"I told you so," said Bonavent. "A duke's a duke."
When the door closed behind the two detectives Lupin tottered
across the room, dropped on to the couch with a groan of exhaustion,
and closed his eyes. Presently the door opened, Victoire came in, saw
his attitude of exhaustion, and with a startled cry ran to his side.
"Oh, dearie! dearie!" she cried. "Pull yourself together! Oh, do
try to pull yourself together." She caught his cold hands and began to
rub them, murmuring words of endearment like a mother over a young
child. Lupin did not open his eyes; Charolais came in.
"Some breakfast!" she cried. "Bring his breakfast . . . he's faint
. . . he's had nothing to eat this morning. Can you eat some
"Yes," said Lupin faintly.
"Hurry up with it," said Victoire in urgent, imperative tones; and
Charolais left the room at a run.
"Oh, what a life you lead!" said Victoire, or, to be exact, she
wailed it. "Are you never going to change? You're as white as a
sheet. . . . Can't you speak, dearie?"
She stooped and lifted his legs on to the couch.
He stretched himself, and, without opening his eyes, said in a
faint voice: "Oh, Victoire, what a fright I've had!"
"You? You've been frightened?" cried Victoire, amazed.
"Yes. You needn't tell the others, though. But I've had a night of
it . . . I did play the fool so . . . I must have been absolutely
mad. Once I had changed the coronet under that fat old fool Gournay-
Martin's very eyes . . . once you and Sonia were out of their
clutches, all I had to do was to slip away. Did I? Not a hit of it! I
stayed there out of sheer bravado, just to score off Guerchard. . . .
And then I . . . I, who pride myself on being as cool as a cucumber .
. . I did the one thing I ought not to have done. . . . Instead of
going quietly away as the Duke of Charmerace . . . what do you think I
did? . . . I bolted . . . I started running . . . running like a
thief. . . . In about two seconds I saw the slip I had made. It did
not take me longer; but that was too long— Guerchard's men were on my
track . . . I was done for."
"Then Guerchard understood—he recognized you?" said Victoire
"As soon as the first paralysis had passed, Guerchard dared to see
clearly . . . to see the truth," said Lupin. "And then it was a
chase. There were ten—fifteen of them on my heels. Out of breath—
grunting, furious—a mob—a regular mob. I had passed the night
before in a motor-car. I was dead beat. In fact, I was done for
before I started . . . and they were gaining ground all the time."
"Why didn't you hide?" said Victoire.
"For a long while they were too close. They must have been within
five feet of me. I was done. Then I was crossing one of the bridges.
. . . There was the Seine . . . handy . . . I made up my mind that,
rather than be taken, I'd make an end of it . . . I'd throw myself
"Good Lord!—and then?" cried Victoire.
"Then I had a revulsion of feeling. At any rate, I'd stick it out
to the end. I gave myself another minute. . . one more minute—the
last, and I had my revolver on me. . . but during that minute I put
forth every ounce of strength I had left . . . I began to gain ground
. . . I had them pretty well strung out already . . . they were blown
too. The knowledge gave me back my courage, and I plugged on . . . my
feet did not feel so much as though they were made of lead. I began to
run away from them . . . they were dropping behind . . . all of them
but one . . . he stuck to me. We went at a jog- trot, a slow jog-trot,
for I don't know how long. Then we dropped to a walk—we could run no
more; and on we went. My strength and wind began to come back. I
suppose my pursuer's did too; for exactly what I expected happened. He
gave a yell and dashed for me. I was ready for him. I pretended to
start running, and when he was within three yards of me I dropped on
one knee, caught his ankles, and chucked him over my head. I don't
know whether he broke his neck or not. I hope he did."
"Splendid!" said Victoire. "Splendid!"
"Well, there I was, outside Paris, and I'm hanged if I know where.
I went on half a mile, and then I rested. Oh, how sleepy I was! I
would have given a hundred thousand francs for an hour's sleep—
cheerfully. But I dared not let myself sleep. I had to get back here
unseen. There were you and Sonia."
"Sonia? Another woman?" cried Victoire. "Oh, it's then that I'm
frightened . . . when you get a woman mixed up in your game. Always,
when you come to grief . . . when you really get into danger, there's
a woman in it."
"Oh, but she's charming!" protested Lupin.
"They always are," said Victoire drily. "But go on. Tell me how you
"Well, I knew it was going to be a tough job, so I took a good
rest- -an hour, I should think. And then I started to walk back. I
found that I had come a devil of a way—I must have gone at Marathon
pace. I walked and walked, and at last I got into Paris, and found
myself with still a couple of miles to go. It was all right now; I
should soon find a cab. But the luck was dead against me. I heard a
man come round the corner of a side-street into a long street I was
walking down. He gave a yell, and came bucketing after me. It was
that hound Dieusy. He had recognized my figure. Off I went; and the
chase began again. I led him a dance, but I couldn't shake him off.
All the while I was working my way towards home. Then, just at last,
I spurted for all I was worth, got out of his sight, bolted round the
corner of the street into the secret entrance, and here I am." He
smiled weakly, and added, "Oh, my dear Victoire, what a profession it
The door opened, and in came Charolais, bearing a tray.
"Here's your breakfast, master," he said.
"Don't call me master—that's how his men address Guerchard. It's a
disgusting practice," said Lupin severely.
Victoire and Charolais were quick laying the table. Charolais kept
up a running fire of questions as he did it; but Lupin did not
trouble to answer them. He lay back, relaxed, drawing deep breaths.
Already his lips had lost their greyness, and were pink; there was a
suggestion of blood under the skin of his pale face. They soon had
the table laid; and he walked to it on fairly steady feet. He sat
down; Charolais whipped off a cover, and said:
"Anyhow, you've got out of the mess neatly. It was a jolly smart
"Oh, yes. So far it's all right," said Lupin. "But there's going to
be trouble presently—lots of it. I shall want all my wits. We all
He fell upon his breakfast with the appetite but not the manners of
a wolf. Charolais went out of the room. Victoire hovered about him,
pouring out his coffee and putting sugar into it.
"By Jove, how good these eggs are!" he said. "I think that, of all
the thousand ways of cooking eggs, en cocotte is the best."
"Heavens! how empty I was!" he said presently. "What a meal I'm
making! It's really a very healthy life, this of mine, Victoire. I
feel much better already."
"Oh, yes; it's all very well to talk," said Victoire, in a scolding
tone; for since he was better, she felt, as a good woman should, that
the time had come to put in a word out of season. "But, all the same,
you're trying to kill yourself—that's what you're doing. Just because
you're young you abuse your youth. It won't last for ever; and you'll
be sorry you used it up before it's time. And this life of lies and
thefts and of all kinds of improper things—I suppose it's going to
begin all over again. It's no good your getting a lesson. It's just
thrown away upon you."
"What I want next is a bath," said Lupin.
"It's all very well your pretending not to listen to me, when you
know very well that I'm speaking for your good," she went on, raising
her voice a little. "But I tell you that all this is going to end
badly. To be a thief gives you no position in the world—no position
at all—and when I think of what you made me do the night before last,
I'm just horrified at myself."
"We'd better not talk about that—the mess you made of it! It was
positively excruciating!" said Lupin.
"And what did you expect? I'm an honest woman, I am!" said Victoire
sharply. "I wasn't brought up to do things like that, thank goodness!
And to begin at my time of life!"
"It's true, and I often ask myself how you bring yourself to stick
to me," said Lupin, in a reflective, quite impersonal tone. "Please
pour me out another cup of coffee."
"That's what I'm always asking myself," said Victoire, pouring out
the coffee. "I don't know—I give it up. I suppose it is because I'm
fond of you."
"Yes, and I'm very fond of you, my dear Victoire," said Lupin, in a
"And then, look you, there are things that there's no
understanding. I often talked to your poor mother about them. Oh, your
poor mother! Whatever would she have said to these goings-on?"
Lupin helped himself to another cutlet; his eves twinkled and he
said, "I'm not sure that she would have been very much surprised. I
always told her that I was going to punish society for the way it had
treated her. Do you think she would have been surprised?"
"Oh, nothing you did would have surprised her," said Victoire.
"When you were quite a little boy you were always making us wonder.
You gave yourself such airs, and you had such nice manners of your
own— altogether different from the other boys. And you were already a
bad boy, when you were only seven years old, full of all kinds of
tricks; and already you had begun to steal."
"Oh, only sugar," protested Lupin.
"Yes, you began by stealing sugar," said Victoire, in the severe
tones of a moralist. "And then it was jam, and then it was pennies.
Oh, it was all very well at that age—a little thief is pretty
enough. But now—when you're twenty-eight years old."
"Really, Victoire, you're absolutely depressing," said Lupin,
yawning; and he helped himself to jam.
"I know very well that you're all right at heart," said Victoire.
"Of course you only rob the rich, and you've always been kind to the
poor. . . . Yes; there's no doubt about it: you have a good heart."
"I can't help it—what about it?" said Lupin, smiling.
"Well, you ought to have different ideas in your head. Why are you
"You ought to try it yourself, my dear Victoire," said Lupin
gently; and he watched her with a humorous eye.
"Goodness, what a thing to say!" cried Victoire.
"I assure you, you ought," said Lupin, in a tone of thoughtful
conviction. "I've tried everything. I've taken my degree in medicine
and in law. I have been an actor, and a professor of Jiu-jitsu. I
have even been a member of the detective force, like that wretched
Guerchard. Oh, what a dirty world that is! Then I launched out into
society. I have been a duke. Well, I give you my word that not one of
these professions equals that of burglar—not even the profession of
Duke. There is so much of the unexpected in it, Victoire—the splendid
unexpected. . . . And then, it's full of variety, so terrible, so
fascinating." His voice sank a little, and he added, "And what fun it
"Fun!" cried Victoire.
"Yes . . . these rich men, these swells in their luxury—when one
relieves them of a bank-note, how they do howl! . . . You should have
seen that fat old Gournay-Martin when I relieved him of his
treasures—what an agony! You almost heard the death-rattle in his
throat. And then the coronet! In the derangement of their minds—and
it was sheer derangement, mind you—already prepared at Charmerace,
in the derangement of Guerchard, I had only to put out my hand and
pluck the coronet. And the joy, the ineffable joy of enraging the
police! To see Guerchard's furious eyes when I downed him. . . . And
look round you!" He waved his hand round the luxurious room. "Duke of
Charmerace! This trade leads to everything . . . to everything on
condition that one sticks to it . . . .I tell you, Victoire, that
when one cannot be a great artist or a great soldier, the only thing
to be is a great thief!"
"Oh, be quiet!" cried Victoire. "Don't talk like that. You're
working yourself up; you're intoxicating yourself! And all that, it
is not Catholic. Come, at your age, you ought to have one idea in
your head which should drive out all these others, which should make
you forget all these thefts. . . . Love . . . that would change you,
I'm sure of it. That would make another man of you. You ought to
"Yes . . . perhaps . . . that would make another man of me. That's
what I've been thinking. I believe you're right," said Lupin
"Is that true? Have you really been thinking of it?" cried Victoire
"Yes," said Lupin, smiling at her eagerness. "I have been thinking
"No more messing about—no more intrigues. But a real woman . . . a
woman for life?" cried Victoire.
"Yes," said Lupin softly; and his eyes were shining in a very grave
"Is it serious—is it real love, dearie?" said Victoire. "What's
"She's beautiful," said Lupin.
"Oh, trust you for that. Is she a blonde or a brunette?"
"She's very fair and delicate—like a princess in a fairy tale,"
said Lupin softly.
"What is she? What does she do?" said Victoire.
"Well, since you ask me, she's a thief," said Lupin with a
"Good Heavens!" cried Victoire.
"But she's a very charming thief," said Lupin; and he rose smiling.
He lighted a cigar, stretched himself and yawned: "She had ever so
much more reason for stealing than ever I had," he said. "And she has
always hated it like poison."
"Well, that's something," said Victoire; and her blank and fallen
face brightened a little.
Lupin walked up and down the room, breathing out long luxurious
puffs of smoke from his excellent cigar, and watching Victoire with a
humorous eye. He walked across to his book-shelf, and scanned the
titles of his books with an appreciative, almost affectionate smile.
"This is a very pleasant interlude," he said languidly. "But I
don't suppose it's going to last very long. As soon as Guerchard
recovers from the shock of learning that I spent a quiet night in my
ducal bed as an honest duke should, he'll be getting to work with
positively furious energy, confound him! I could do with a whole
day's sleep—twenty-four solid hours of it."
"I'm sure you could, dearie," said Victoire sympathetically.
"The girl I'm going to marry is Sonia Kritchnoff," he said.
"Sonia? That dear child! But I love her already!" cried Victoire.
"Sonia, but why did you say she was a thief? That was a silly thing
"It's my extraordinary sense of humour," said Lupin.
The door opened and Charolais bustled in: "Shall I clear away the
breakfast?" he said.
Lupin nodded; and then the telephone bell rang. He put his finger
on his lips and went to it.
"Are you there?" he said. "Oh, it's you, Germaine. . . . Good
morning. . . . Oh, yes, I had a good night—excellent, thank you. . .
. You want to speak to me presently? . . . You're waiting for me at
"Don't go—don't go—it isn't safe," said Victoire, in a whisper.
"All right, I'll be with you in about half an hour, or perhaps
three-quarters. I'm not dressed yet . . . but I'm ever so much more
impatient than you . . . good-bye for the present." He put the
receiver on the stand,
"It's a trap," said Charolais.
"Never mind, what if it is? Is it so very serious?" said Lupin.
"There'll be nothing but traps now; and if I can find the time I
shall certainly go and take a look at that one."
"And if she knows everything? If she's taking her revenge . . . if
she's getting you there to have you arrested?" said Victoire.
"Yes, M. Formery is probably at the Ritz with Gournay-Martin.
They're probably all of them there, weighing the coronet," said
Lupin, with a chuckle.
He hesitated a moment, reflecting; then he said, "How silly you
are! If they wanted to arrest me, if they had the material proof which
they haven't got, Guerchard would be here already!"
"Then why did they chase you last night?" said Charolais.
"The coronet," said Lupin. "Wasn't that reason enough? But, as it
turned out, they didn't catch me: and when the detectives did come
here, they disturbed me in my sleep. And that me was ever so much
more me than the man they followed. And then the proofs . . . they
must have proofs. There aren't any—or rather, what there are, I've
got!" He pointed to a small safe let into the wall. "In that safe are
the coronet, and, above all, the death certificate of the Duke of
Charmerace . . . everything that Guerchard must have to induce M.
Formery to proceed. But still, there is a risk—I think I'd better
have those things handy in case I have to bolt."
He went into his bedroom and came back with the key of the safe and
a kit-bag. He opened the safe and took out the coronet, the real
coronet of the Princesse de Lamballe, and along with it a pocket-
book with a few papers in it. He set the pocket-book on the table,
ready to put in his coat-pocket when he should have dressed, and
dropped the coronet into the kit-bag.
"I'm glad I have that death certificate; it makes it much safer,"
he said. "If ever they do nab me, I don't wish that rascal Guerchard
to accuse me of having murdered the Duke. It might prejudice me badly.
I've not murdered anybody yet."
"That comes of having a good heart," said Victoire proudly.
"Not even the Duke of Charmerace," said Charolais sadly. "And it
would have been so easy when he was ill—just one little draught. And
he was in such a perfect place—so out of the way—no doctors."
"You do have such disgusting ideas, Charolais," said Lupin, in a
tone of severe reproof.
"Instead of which you went and saved his life," said Charolais, in
a tone of deep discontent; and he went on clearing the table.
"I did, I did: I had grown quite fond of him," said Lupin, with a
meditative air. "For one thing, he was so very like one. I'm not sure
that he wasn't even better-looking."
"No; he was just like you," said Victoire, with decision. "Any one
would have said you were twin brothers."
"It gave me quite a shock the first time I saw his portrait," said
Lupin. "You remember, Charolais? It was three years ago, the day, or
rather the night, of the first Gournay-Martin burglary at Charmerace.
Do you remember?"
"Do I remember?" said Charolais. "It was I who pointed out the
likeness to you. I said, 'He's the very spit of you, master.' And you
said, 'There's something to be done with that, Charolais.' And then
off you started for the ice and snow and found the Duke, and became
his friend; and then he went and died, not that you'd have helped him
to, if he hadn't."
"Poor Charmerace. He was indeed grand seigneur. With him a great
name was about to be extinguished. . . . Did I hesitate? . . . No. .
. . I continued it," said Lupin.
He paused and looked at the clock. "A quarter to eight," he said,
hesitating. "Shall I telephone to Sonia, or shall I not? Oh, there's
no hurry; let the poor child sleep on. She must be worn out after
that night-journey and that cursed Guerchard's persecution yesterday.
I'll dress first, and telephone to her afterwards. I'd better be
getting dressed, by the way. The work I've got to do can't be done in
pyjamas. I wish it could; for bed's the place for me. My wits aren't
quite as clear as I could wish them to deal with an awkward business
like this. Well, I must do the best I can with them."
He yawned and went to the bedroom, leaving the pocket-book on the
"Bring my shaving-water, Charolais, and shave me," he said,
pausing; and he went into the bedroom and shut the door.
"Ah," said Victoire sadly, "what a pity it is! A few years ago he
would have gone to the Crusades; and to-day he steals coronets. What
a pity it is!"
"I think myself that the best thing we can do is to pack up our
belongings," said Charolais. "And I don't think we've much time to do
it either. This particular game is at an end, you may take it from
"I hope to goodness it is: I want to get back to the country," said
He took up the tray; and they went out of the room. On the landing
they separated; she went upstairs and he went down. Presently he came
up with the shaving water and shaved his master; for in the house in
University Street he discharged the double functions of valet and
butler. He had just finished his task when there came a ring at the
"You'd better go and see who it is," said Lupin.
"Bernard is answering the door," said Charolais. "But perhaps I'd
better keep an eye on it myself; one never knows."
He put away the razor leisurely, and went. On the stairs he found
Bonavent, mounting—Bonavent, disguised in the livery and fierce
moustache of a porter from the Ritz.
"Why didn't you come to the servants' entrance?" said Charolais,
with the truculent air of the servant of a duke and a stickler for
his master's dignity.
"I didn't know that there was one," said Bonavent humbly. "Well,
you ought to have known that there was; and it's plain enough to see.
What is it you want?" said Charolais.
"I've brought a letter—a letter for the Duke of Charmerace," said
"Give it to me," said Charolais. "I'll take it to him."
"No, no; I'm to give it into the hands of the Duke himself and to
nobody else," said Bonavent.
"Well, in that case, you'll have to wait till he's finished
dressing," said Charolais.
They went on up to the stairs into the ante-room. Bonavent was
walking straight into the smoking-room.
"Here! where are you going to? Wait here," said Charolais quickly.
"Take a chair; sit down."
Bonavent sat down with a very stolid air, and Charolais looked at
him doubtfully, in two minds whether to leave him there alone or not.
Before he had decided there came a thundering knock on the front door,
not only loud but protracted. Charolais looked round with a scared
air; and then ran out of the room and down the stairs.
On the instant Bonavent was on his feet, and very far from stolid.
He opened the door of the smoking-room very gently and peered in. It
was empty. He slipped noiselessly across the room, a pair of clippers
ready in his hand, and cut the wires of the telephone. His quick eye
glanced round the room and fell on the pocket-book on the table. He
snatched it up, and slipped it into the breast of his tunic. He had
scarcely done it—one button of his tunic was still to fasten—when
the bedroom door opened, and Lupin came out:
"What do you want?" he said sharply; and his keen eyes scanned the
porter with a disquieting penetration.
"I've brought a letter to the Duke of Charmerace, to be given into
his own hands," said Bonavent, in a disguised voice.
"Give it to me," said Lupin, holding out his hand.
"But the Duke?" said Bonavent, hesitating.
"I am the Duke," said Lupin.
Bonavent gave him the letter, and turned to go.
"Don't go," said Lupin quietly. "Wait, there may be an answer."
There was a faint glitter in his eyes; but Bonavent missed it.
Charolais came into the room, and said, in a grumbling tone, "A
run- away knock. I wish I could catch the brats; I'd warm them. They
wouldn't go fetching me away from my work again, in a hurry, I can
Lupin opened the letter, and read it. As he read it, at first he
frowned; then he smiled; and then he laughed joyously. It ran:
"M. Guerchard has told me everything. With regard to Sonia I have
judged you: a man who loves a thief can be nothing but a rogue. I have
two pieces of news to announce to you: the death of the Duke of
Charmerace, who died three years ago, and my intention of becoming
engaged to his cousin and heir, M. de Relzieres, who will assume the
title and the arms."
"For Mademoiselle Gournay-Martin," "Her maid, IRMA."
"She does write in shocking bad taste," said Lupin, shaking his
head sadly. "Charolais, sit down and write a letter for me."
"Me?" said Charolais.
"Yes; you. It seems to be the fashion in financial circles; and I
am bound to follow it when a lady sets it. Write me a letter," said
Charolais went to the writing-table reluctantly, sat down, set a
sheet of paper on the blotter, took a pen in his hand, and sighed
"Ready?" said Lupin; and he dictated:
"I have a very robust constitution, and my indisposition will very
soon be over. I shall have the honour of sending, this afternoon, my
humble wedding present to the future Madame de Relzieres."
"For Jacques de Bartut, Marquis de Relzieres, Prince of Virieux,
Duke of Charmerace."
"His butler, ARSENE."
"Shall I write Arsene?" said Charolais, in a horrified tone.
"Why not?" said Lupin. "It's your charming name, isn't it?"
Bonavent pricked up his ears, and looked at Charolais with a new
Charolais shrugged his shoulders, finished the letter, blotted it,
put it in an envelope, addressed it, and handed it to Lupin.
"Take this to Mademoiselle Gournay-Martin," said Lupin, handing it
Bonavent took the letter, turned, and had taken one step towards
the door when Lupin sprang. His arm went round the detective's neck;
he jerked him backwards off his feet, scragging him.
"Stir, and I'll break your neck!" he cried in a terrible voice; and
then he said quietly to Charolais, "Just take my pocket-book out of
this fellow's tunic."
Charolais, with deft fingers, ripped open the detective's tunic,
and took out the pocket-book.
"This is what they call Jiu-jitsu, old chap! You'll be able to
teach it to your colleagues," said Lupin. He loosed his grip on
Bonavent, and knocked him straight with a thump in the back, and sent
him flying across the room. Then he took the pocket-book from
Charolais and made sure that its contents were untouched.
"Tell your master from me that if he wants to bring me down he'd
better fire the gun himself," said Lupin contemptuously. "Show the
gentleman out, Charolais."
Bonavent staggered to the door, paused, and turned on Lupin a face
livid with fury.
"He will be here himself in ten minutes," he said.
"Many thanks for the information," said Lupin quietly.
Charolais conducted the detective down the stairs and let him out
of the front door, cursing and threatening vengeance as he went.
Charolais took no notice of his words—he was the well-trained
servant. He came back upstairs, and on the landing called to Victoire
and Bernard. They came hurrying down; and the three of them went into
"Now we know where we are," said Lupin, with cheerful briskness.
"Guerchard will be here in ten minutes with a warrant for my arrest.
All of you clear out."
"It won't be so precious easy. The house is watched," said
Charolais. "And I'll bet it's watched back and front."
"Well, slip out by the secret entrance. They haven't found that
yet," said Lupin. "And meet me at the house at Passy."
Charolais and Bernard wanted no more telling; they ran to the book-
case and pressed the buttons; the book-case slid aside; the doors
opened and disclosed the lift. They stepped into it. Victoire had
followed them. She paused and said: "And you? Are you coming?"
"In an instant I shall slip out the same way," he said.
"I'll wait for him. You go on," said Victoire; and the lift went
Lupin went to the telephone, rang the bell, and put the receiver to
"You've no time to waste telephoning. They may be here at any
moment!" cried Victoire anxiously.
"I must. If I don't telephone Sonia will come here. She will run
right into Guerchard's arms. Why the devil don't they answer? They
must be deaf!" And he rang the bell again.
"Let's go to her! Let's get out of here!" cried Victoire, more
anxiously. "There really isn't any time to waste."
"Go to her? But I don't know where she is. I lost my head last
night," cried Lupin, suddenly anxious himself. "Are you there?" he
shouted into the telephone. "She's at a little hotel near the Star. .
. . Are you there? . . . But there are twenty hotels near the Star. .
. . Are you there? . . . Oh, I did lose my head last night. . . . Are
you there? Oh, hang this telephone! Here I'm fighting with a piece of
furniture. And every second is important!"
He picked up the machine, shook it, saw that the wires were cut,
and cried furiously: "Ha! They've played the telephone trick on me!
That's Guerchard. . . . The swine!"
"And now you can come along!" cried Victoire.
"But that's just what I can't do!" he cried.
"But there's nothing more for you to do here, since you can no
longer telephone," said Victoire, bewildered.
Lupin caught her arm and shook her, staring into her face with
panic-stricken eyes. "But don't you understand that, since I haven't
telephoned, she'll come here?" he cried hoarsely. "Five-and-twenty
minutes past eight! At half-past eight she will start—start to come
His face had suddenly grown haggard; this new fear had brought back
all the exhaustion of the night; his eyes were panic-stricken.
"But what about you?" said Victoire, wringing her hands.
"What about her?" said Lupin; and his voice thrilled with anguished
"But you'll gain nothing by destroying both of you—nothing at
"I prefer it," said Lupin slowly, with a suddenly stubborn air.
"But they're coming to take you," cried Victoire, gripping his arm.
"Take me?" cried Lupin, freeing himself quietly from her grip. And
he stood frowning, plunged in deep thought, weighing the chances, the
risks, seeking a plan, saving devices.
He crossed the room to the writing-table, opened a drawer, and took
out a cardboard box about eight inches square and set it on the
"They shall never take me alive," he said gloomily.
"Oh, hush, hush!" said Victoire. "I know very well that you're
capable of anything . . . and they too—they'll destroy you. No, look
you, you must go. They won't do anything to her—a child like that—so
frail. She'll get off quite easily. You're coming, aren't you?"
"No, I'm not," said Lupin stubbornly.
"Oh, well, if you won't," said Victoire; and with an air of
resolution she went to the side of the lift-well, and pressed the
buttons. The doors closed; the book-case slid across. She sat down
and folded her arms.
"What, you're not going to stop here?" cried Lupin.
"Make me stir if you can. I'm as fond of you as she is—you know I
am," said Victoire, and her face set stonily obstinate.
Lupin begged her to go; ordered her to go; he seized her by the
shoulder, shook her, and abused her like a pickpocket. She would not
stir. He abandoned the effort, sat down, and knitted his brow again
in profound and painful thought, working out his plan. Now and again
his eyes flashed, once or twice they twinkled. Victoire watched his
face with just the faintest hope on her own.
It was past five-and-twenty minutes to nine when the front-door
bell rang. They gazed at one another with an unspoken question on
their lips. The eyes of Victoire were scared, but in the eyes of Lupin
the light of battle was gathering.
"It's her," said Victoire under her breath.
"No," said Lupin. "It's Guerchard."
He sprang to his feet with shining eyes. His lips were curved in a
fighting smile. "The game isn't lost yet," he said in a tense, quiet
voice. "I'm going to play it to the end. I've a card or two left
still—good cards. I'm still the Duke of Charmerace." He turned to
"Now listen to me," he said. "Go down and open the door for him."
"What, you want me to?" said Victoire, in a shaky voice.
"Yes, I do. Listen to me carefully. When you have opened the door,
slip out of it and watch the house. Don't go too far from it. Look
out for Sonia. You'll see her coining. Stop her from entering,
Victoire—stop her from entering." He spoke coolly, but his voice
shook on the last words.
"But if Guerchard arrests me?" said Victoire.
"He won't. When he comes in, stand behind the door. He will be too
eager to get to me to stop for you. Besides, for him you don't count
in the game. Once you're out of the house, I'll hold him here for—
for half an hour. That will leave a margin. Sonia will hurry here.
She should be here in twelve minutes. Get her away to the house at
Passy. If I don't come keep her there; she's to live with you. But I
As he spoke he was pushing her towards the door.
The bell rang again. They were at the top of the stairs.
"And suppose he does arrest me?" said Victoire breathlessly.
"Never mind, you must go all the same," said Lupin. "Don't give up
hope—trust to me. Go—go—for my sake."
"I'm going, dearie," said Victoire; and she went down the stairs
steadily, with a brave air.
He watched her half-way down the flight; then he muttered:
"If only she gets to Sonia in time."
He turned, went into the smoking-room, and shut the door. He sat
quietly down in an easy chair, lighted a cigarette, and took up a
paper. He heard the noise of the traffic in the street grow louder as
the front door was opened. There was a pause; then he heard the door
bang. There was the sound of a hasty footstep on the stairs; the door
flew open, and Guerchard bounced into the room.
He stopped short in front of the door at the sight of Lupin,
quietly reading, smoking at his ease. He had expected to find the bird
flown. He stood still, hesitating, shuffling his feet—all his doubts
had returned; and Lupin smiled at him over the lowered paper.
Guerchard pulled himself together by a violent effort, and said
jerkily, "Good-morning, Lupin."
"Good-morning, M. Guerchard," said Lupin, with an ambiguous smile
and all the air of the Duke of Charmerace.
"You were expecting me? . . . I hope I haven't kept you waiting,"
said Guerchard, with an air of bravado.
"No, thank you: the time has passed quite quickly. I have so much
to do in the morning always," said Lupin. "I hope you had a good night
after that unfortunate business of the coronet. That was a disaster;
and so unexpected too."
Guerchard came a few steps into the room, still hesitating:
"You've a very charming house here," he said, with a sneer.
"It's central," said Lupin carelessly. "You must please excuse me,
if I cannot receive you as I should like; but all my servants have
bolted. Those confounded detectives of yours have frightened them
"You needn't bother about that. I shall catch them," said
"If you do, I'm sure I wish you joy of them. Do, please, keep your
hat on," said Lupin with ironic politeness.
Guerchard came slowly to the middle of the room, raising his hand
to his hat, letting it fall again without taking it off. He sat down
slowly facing him, and they gazed at one another with the wary eyes
of duellists crossing swords at the beginning of a duel.
"Did you get M. Formery to sign a little warrant?" said Lupin, in a
caressing tone full of quiet mockery.
"I did," said Guerchard through his teeth.
"And have you got it on you?" said Lupin.
"I have," said Guerchard.
"Against Lupin, or against the Duke of Charmerace?" said Lupin.
"Against Lupin, called Charmerace," said Guerchard.
"Well, that ought to cover me pretty well. Why don't you arrest me?
What are you waiting for?" said Lupin. His face was entirely serene,
his eyes were careless, his tone indifferent.
"I'm not waiting for anything," said Guerchard thickly; "but it
gives me such pleasure that I wish to enjoy this minute to the
utmost. Lupin," said Guerchard; and his eyes gloated on him.
"Lupin, himself," said Lupin, smiling.
"I hardly dare believe it," said Guerchard.
"You're quite right not to," said Lupin.
"Yes, I hardly dare believe it. You alive, here at my mercy?"
"Oh, dear no, not yet," said Lupin.
"Yes," said Guerchard, in a decisive tone. "And ever so much more
than you think." He bent forwards towards him, with his hands on his
knees, and said, "Do you know where Sonia Kritchnoff is at this
"What?" said Lupin sharply.
"I ask if you know where Sonia Kritchnoff is?" said Guerchard
slowly, lingering over the words.
"Do you?" said Lupin.
"I do," said Guerchard triumphantly.
"Where is she?" said Lupin, in a tone of utter incredulity.
"In a small hotel near the Star. The hotel has a telephone; and you
can make sure," said Guerchard.
"Indeed? That's very interesting. What's the number of it?" said
Lupin, in a mocking tone.
"555 Central: would you like to telephone to her?" said Guerchard;
and he smiled triumphantly at the disabled instrument.
Lupin shock his head with a careless smile, and said, "Why should I
telephone to her? What are you driving at?"
"Nothing . . . that's all," said Guerchard. And he leant back in
his chair with an ugly smile on his face.
"Evidently nothing. For, after all, what has that child got to do
with you? You're not interested in her, plainly. She's not big enough
game for you. It's me you are hunting . . . it's me you hate . . .
it's me you want. I've played you tricks enough for that, you old
scoundrel. So you're going to leave that child in peace? . . . You're
not going to revenge yourself on her? . . . It's all very well for you
to be a policeman; it's all very well for you to hate me; but there
are things one does not do." There was a ring of menace and appeal in
the deep, ringing tones of his voice. "You're not going to do that,
Guerchard. . . . You will not do it. . . . Me- -yes—anything you
like. But her—her you must not touch." He gazed at the detective with
fierce, appealing eyes.
"That depends on you," said Guerchard curtly.
"On me?" cried Lupin, in genuine surprise.
"Yes, I've a little bargain to propose to you," said Guerchard.
"Have you?" said Lupin; and his watchful face was serene again, his
smile almost pleasant.
"Yes," said Guerchard. And he paused, hesitating.
"Well, what is it you want?" said Lupin. "Out with it! Don't be shy
"I offer you—"
"You offer me?" cried Lupin. "Then it isn't true. You're fooling
"Reassure yourself," said Guerchard coldly. "To you personally I
"Then you are sincere," said Lupin. "And putting me out of the
"I offer you liberty."
"Who for? For my concierge?" said Lupin.
"Don't play the fool. You care only for a single person in the
world. I hold you through her: Sonia Kritchnoff."
Lupin burst into a ringing, irrepressible laugh:
"Why, you're trying to blackmail me, you old sweep!" he cried.
"If you like to call it so," said Guerchard coldly.
Lupin rose and walked backwards and forwards across the room,
frowning, calculating, glancing keenly at Guerchard, weighing him.
Twice he looked at the clock.
He stopped and said coldly: "So be it. For the moment you're the
stronger. . . . That won't last. . . . But you offer me this child's
"That's my offer," said Guerchard; and his eyes brightened at the
prospect of success.
"Her complete liberty? . . . on your word of honour?" said Lupin;
and he had something of the air of a cat playing with a mouse.
"On my word of honour," said Guerchard.
"Can you do it?" said Lupin, with a sudden air of doubt; and he
looked sharply from Guerchard to the clock.
"I undertake to do it," said Guerchard confidently.
"But how?" said Lupin, looking at him with an expression of the
"Oh, I'll put the thefts on your shoulders. That will let her out
all right," said Guerchard,
"I've certainly good broad shoulders," said Lupin, with a bitter
smile. He walked slowly up and down with an air that grew more and
more depressed: it was almost the air of a beaten man. Then he
stopped and faced Guerchard, and said: "And what is it you want in
"Everything," said Guerchard, with the air of a man who is winning.
"You must give me back the pictures, tapestry, Renaissance cabinets,
the coronet, and all the information about the death of the Duke of
Charmerace. Did you kill him?"
"If ever I commit suicide, you'll know all about it, my good
Guerchard. You'll be there. You may even join me," said Lupin grimly;
he resumed his pacing up and down the room.
"Done for, yes; I shall be done for," he said presently. "The fact
is, you want my skin."
"Yes, I want your skin," said Guerchard, in a low, savage,
"My skin," said Lupin thoughtfully.
"Are you going to do it? Think of that girl," said Guerchard, in a
fresh access of uneasy anxiety.
Lupin laughed: "I can give you a glass of port," he said, "but I'm
afraid that's all I can do for you."
"I'll throw Victoire in," said Guerchard.
"What?" cried Lupin. "You've arrested Victoire?" There was a ring
of utter dismay, almost despair, in his tone.
"Yes; and I'll throw her in. She shall go scot-free. I won't bother
with her," said Guerchard eagerly.
The front-door bell rang.
"Wait, wait. Let me think," said Lupin hoarsely; and he strove to
adjust his jostling ideas, to meet with a fresh plan this fresh
He stood listening with all his ears. There were footsteps on the
stairs, and the door opened. Dieusy stood on the threshold.
"Who is it?" said Guerchard.
"I accept—I accept everything," cried Lupin in a frantic tone.
"It's a tradesman; am I to detain him?" said Dieusy. "You told me
to let you know who came and take instructions."
"A tradesman? Then I refuse!" cried Lupin, in an ecstasy of relief.
"No, you needn't keep him," said Guerchard, to Dieusy.
Dieusy went out and shut the door.
"You refuse?" said Guerchard.
"I refuse," said Lupin.
"I'm going to gaol that girl," said Guerchard savagely; and he took
a step towards the door.
"Not for long," said Lupin quietly. "You have no proof."
"She'll furnish the proof all right herself—plenty of proofs,"
said Guerchard brutally. "What chance has a silly child like that got.
when we really start questioning her? A delicate creature like that
will crumple up before the end of the third day's cross-
"You swine!" said Lupin. "You know well enough that I can do it—on
my head—with a feeble child like that; and you know your Code; five
years is the minimum," said Guerchard, in a tone of relentless
brutality, watching him carefully, sticking to his hope.
"By Jove, I could wring your neck!" said Lupin, trembling with
fury. By a violent effort he controlled himself, and said
thoughtfully, "After all, if I give up everything to you, I shall be
free to take it back one of these days."
"Oh, no doubt, when you come out of prison," said Guerchard
ironically; and he laughed a grim, jeering laugh.
"I've got to go to prison first," said Lupin quietly.
"Pardon me—if you accept, I mean to arrest you," said Guerchard.
"Manifestly you'll arrest me if you can," said Lupin.
"Do you accept?" said Guerchard. And again his voice quivered with
"Well," said Lupin. And he paused as if finally weighing the
"Well?" said Guerchard, and his voice shook.
"Well—no!" said Lupin; and he laughed a mocking laugh.
"You won't?" said Guerchard between his teeth.
"No; you wish to catch me. This is just a ruse," said Lupin, in
quiet, measured tones. "At bottom you don't care a hang about Sonia,
Mademoiselle Kritchnoff. You will not arrest her. And then, if you
did you have no proofs. There ARE no proofs. As for the pendant,
you'd have to prove it. You can't prove it. You can't prove that it
was in her possession one moment. Where is the pendant?" He paused,
and then went on in the same quiet tone: "No, Guerchard; after having
kept out of your clutches for the last ten years, I'm not going to be
caught to save this child, who is not even in danger. She has a very
useful friend in the Duke of Charmerace. I refuse."
Guerchard stared at him, scowling, biting his lips, seeking a fresh
point of attack. For the moment he knew himself baffled, but he still
clung tenaciously to the struggle in which victory would be so
The front-door bell rang again.
"There's a lot of ringing at your bell this morning," said
Guerchard, under his breath; and hope sprang afresh in him.
Again they stood silent, waiting.
Dieusy opened the door, put in his head, and said, "It's
"Collar her! . . . Here's the warrant! . . . collar her!" shouted
Guerchard, with savage, triumphant joy.
"Never! You shan't touch her! By Heaven, you shan't touch her!"
cried Lupin frantically; and he sprang like a tiger at Guerchard.
Guerchard jumped to the other side of the table. "Will you accept,
then?" he cried.
Lupin gripped the edge of the table with both hands, and stood
panting, grinding his teeth, pale with fury. He stood silent and
motionless for perhaps half a minute, gazing at Guerchard with
burning, murderous eyes. Then he nodded his head.
"Let Mademoiselle Kritchnoff wait," said Guerchard, with a sigh of
deep relief. Dieusy went out of the room.
"Now let us settle exactly how we stand," said Lupin, in a clear,
incisive voice. "The bargain is this: If I give you the pictures, the
tapestry, the cabinets, the coronet, and the death-certificate of the
Duke of Charmerace, you give me your word of honour that Mademoiselle
Kritchnoff shall not be touched."
"That's it!" said Guerchard eagerly.
"Once I deliver these things to you, Mademoiselle Kritchnoff passes
out of the game."
"Yes," said Guerchard.
"Whatever happens afterwards. If I get back anything—if I escape—
she goes scot-free," said Lupin.
"Yes," said Guerchard; and his eyes were shining.
"On your word of honour?" said Lupin.
"On my word of honour," said Guerchard.
"Very well," said Lupin, in a quiet, businesslike voice. "To begin
with, here in this pocket-book you'll find all the documents relating
to the death of the Duke of Charmerace. In it you will also find the
receipt of the Plantin furniture repository at Batignolles for the
objects of art which I collected at Gournay-Martin's. I sent them to
Batignolles because, in my letters asking the owners of valuables to
forward them to me, I always make Batignolles the place to which they
are to be sent; therefore I knew that you would never look there. They
are all in cases; for, while you were making those valuable inquiries
yesterday, my men were putting them into cases. You'll not find the
receipt in the name of either the Duke of Charmerace or my own. It is
in the name of a respected proprietor of Batignolles, a M. Pierre
Servien. But he has lately left that charming suburb, and I do not
think he will return to it."
Guerchard almost snatched the pocket-book out of his hand. He
verified the documents in it with greedy eyes; and then he put them
back in it, and stuffed it into the breast-pocket of his coat.
"And where's the coronet?" he said, in an excited voice.
"You're nearly standing on it," said Lupin.
"It's in that kit-bag at your feet, on the top of the change of
clothes in it."
Guerchard snatched up the kit-bag, opened it, and took out the
"I'm afraid I haven't the case," said Lupin, in a tone of regret.
"If you remember, I left it at Gournay-Martin's—in your charge."
Guerchard examined the coronet carefully. He looked at the stones
in it; he weighed it in his right hand, and he weighed it in his left.
"Are you sure it's the real one?" said Lupin, in a tone of acute
but affected anxiety. "Do not—oh, do not let us have any more of
these painful mistakes about it. They are so wearing."
"Yes—yes—this is the real one," said Guerchard, with another deep
sigh of relief.
"Well, have you done bleeding me?" said Lupin contemptuously.
"Your arms," said Guerchard quickly.
"They weren't in the bond," said Lupin. "But here you are." And he
threw his revolver on the table.
Guerchard picked it up and put it into his pocket. He looked at
Lupin as if he could not believe his eyes, gloating over him. Then he
said in a deep, triumphant tone:
"And now for the handcuffs!"
"The handcuffs?" said Lupin; and his face fell. Then it cleared;
and he added lightly, "After all, there's nothing like being careful;
and, by Jove, with me you need to be. I might get away yet. What luck
it is for you that I'm so soft, so little of a Charmerace, so human!
Truly, I can't be much of a man of the world, to be in love like
"Come, come, hold out your hands!" said Guerchard, jingling the
"I should like to see that child for the last time," said Lupin
"All right," said Guerchard.
"Arsene Lupin—and nabbed by you! If you aren't in luck! Here you
are!" said Lupin bitterly; and he held out his wrists.
Guerchard snapped the handcuffs on them with a grunt of
Lupin gazed down at them with a bitter face, and said: "Oh, you are
in luck! You're not married by any chance?"
"Yes, yes; I am," said Guerchard hastily; and he went quickly to
the door and opened it: "Dieusy!" he called. "Dieusy! Mademoiselle
Kritchnoff is at liberty. Tell her so, and bring her in here."
Lupin started back, flushed and scowling; he cried: "With these
things on my hands! . . . No! . . . I can't see her!"
Guerchard stood still, looking at him. Lupin's scowl slowly
softened, and he said, half to himself, "But I should have liked to
see her . . . very much . . . for if she goes like that . . . I shall
not know when or where—" He stopped short, raised his eyes, and said
in a decided tone: "Ah, well, yes; I should like to see her."
"If you've quite made up your mind," said Guerchard impatiently,
and he went into the anteroom.
Lupin stood very still, frowning thoughtfully. He heard footsteps
on the stairs, and then the voice of Guerchard in the anteroom,
saying, in a jeering tone, "You're free, mademoiselle; and you can
thank the Duke for it. You owe your liberty to him."
"Free! And I owe it to him?" cried the voice of Sonia, ringing and
golden with extravagant joy.
"Yes, mademoiselle," said Guerchard. "You owe it to him."
She came through the open door, flushed deliciously and smiling,
her eyes brimming with tears of joy. Lupin had never seen her look
half so adorable.
"Is it to you I owe it? Then I shall owe everything to you. Oh,
thank you—thank you!" she cried, holding out her hands to him.
Lupin half turned away from her to hide his handcuffs.
She misunderstood the movement. Her face fell suddenly like that
of a child rebuked: "Oh, I was wrong. I was wrong to come here!" she
cried quickly, in changed, dolorous tones. "I thought yesterday . . .
I made a mistake . . . pardon me. I'm going. I'm going."
Lupin was looking at her over his shoulder, standing sideways to
hide the handcuffs. He said sadly. "Sonia—"
"No, no, I understand! It was impossible!" she cried quickly,
cutting him short. "And yet if you only knew—if you knew how I have
changed—with what a changed spirit I came here. . . . Ah, I swear
that now I hate all my past. I loathe it. I swear that now the mere
presence of a thief would overwhelm me with disgust."
"Hush!" said Lupin, flushing deeply, and wincing. "Hush!"
"But, after all, you're right," she said, in a gentler voice. "One
can't wipe out what one has done. If I were to give back everything
I've taken—if I were to spend years in remorse and repentance, it
would be no use. In your eyes I should always be Sonia Kritchnoff,
the thief!" The great tears welled slowly out of her eyes and rolled
down her cheeks; she let them stream unheeded.
"Sonia!" cried Lupin, protesting.
But she would not hear him. She broke out with fresh vehemence, a
feverish passion: "And yet, if I'd been a thief, like so many others.
. . but you know why I stole. I'm not trying to defend myself, but,
after all, I did it to keep honest; and when I loved you it was not
the heart of a thief that thrilled, it was the heart of a poor girl
who loved. . .that's all. . .who loved."
"You don't know what you're doing! You're torturing me! Be quiet!"
cried Lupin hoarsely, beside himself.
"Never mind. . .I'm going. . .we shall never see one another any
more," she sobbed. "But will you. . .will you shake hands just for
the last time?"
"No!" cried Lupin.
"You won't?" wailed Sonia in a heartrending tone.
"I can't!" cried Lupin.
"You ought not to be like this. . . . Last night . . . if you were
going to let me go like this . . . last night . . . it was wrong,"
she wailed, and turned to go.
"Wait, Sonia! Wait!" cried Lupin hoarsely. "A moment ago you said
something. . . . You said that the mere presence of a thief would
overwhelm you with disgust. Is that true?"
"Yes, I swear it is," cried Sonia.
Guerchard appeared in the doorway.
"And if I were not the man you believe?" said Lupin sombrely.
"What?" said Sonia; and a faint bewilderment mingled with her
grief. "If I were not the Duke of Charmerace?"
"Not the Duke?"
"If I were not an honest man?" said Lupin.
"You?" cried Sonia.
"If I were a thief? If I were—"
"Arsene Lupin," jeered Guerchard from the door.
Lupin turned and held out his manacled wrists for her to see.
"Arsene Lupin! . . . it's . . . it's true!" stammered Sonia. "But
then, but then . . . it must be for my sake that you've given
yourself up. And it's for me you're going to prison. Oh, Heavens! How
happy I am!"
She sprang to him, threw her arms round his neck, and pressed her
lips to his.
"And that's what women call repenting," said Guerchard.
He shrugged his shoulders, went out on to the landing, and called
to the policeman in the hall to bid the driver of the prison-van,
which was waiting, bring it up to the door.
"Oh, this is incredible!" cried Lupin, in a trembling voice; and he
kissed Sonia's lips and eyes and hair. "To think that you love me
enough to go on loving me in spite of this—in spite of the fact that
I'm Arsene Lupin. Oh, after this, I'll become an honest man! It's the
least I can do. I'll retire."
"You will?" cried Sonia.
"Upon my soul, I will!" cried Lupin; and he kissed her again and
Guerchard came back into the room. He looked at them with a cynical
grin, and said, "Time's up."
"Oh, Guerchard, after so many others, I owe you the best minute of
my life!" cried Lupin.
Bonavent, still in his porter's livery, came hurrying through the
anteroom: "Master," he cried, "I've found it."
"Found what?" said Guerchard.
"The secret entrance. It opens into that little side street. We
haven't got the door open yet; but we soon shall."
"The last link in the chain," said Guerchard, with warm
satisfaction. "Come along, Lupin."
"But he's going to take you away! We're going to be separated!"
cried Sonia, in a sudden anguish of realization.
"It's all the same to me now!" cried Lupin, in the voice of a
"Yes, but not to me!" cried Sonia, wringing her hands.
"Now you must keep calm and go. I'm not going to prison," said
Lupin, in a low voice. "Wait in the hall, if you can. Stop and talk
to Victoire; condole with her. If they turn you out of the house,
wait close to the front door."
"Come, mademoiselle," said Guerchard. "You must go."
"Go, Sonia, go—good-bye—good-bye," said Lupin; and he kissed her.
She went quietly out of the room, her handkerchief to her eyes.
Guerchard held open the door for her, and kept it open, with his hand
still on the handle; he said to Lupin: "Come along."
Lupin yawned, stretched himself, and said coolly, "My dear
Guerchard, what I want after the last two nights is rest—rest." He
walked quickly across the room and stretched himself comfortably at
full length on the couch.
"Come, get up," said Guerchard roughly. "The prison-van is waiting
for you. That ought to fetch you out of your dream."
"Really, you do say the most unlucky things," said Lupin gaily.
He had resumed his flippant, light-hearted air; his voice rang as
lightly and pleasantly as if he had not a care in the world.
"Do you mean that you refuse to come?" cried Guerchard in a rough,
"Oh, no," said Lupin quickly: and he rose.
"Then come along!" said Guerchard.
"No," said Lupin, "after all, it's too early." Once more he
stretched himself out on the couch, and added languidly, "I'm
lunching at the English Embassy."
"Now, you be careful!" cried Guerchard angrily. "Our parts are
changed. If you're snatching at a last straw, it's waste of time. All
your tricks—I know them. Understand, you rogue, I know them."
"You know them?" said Lupin with a smile, rising. "It's fatality!"
He stood before Guerchard, twisting his hands and wrists curiously.
Half a dozen swift movements; and he held out his handcuffs in one
hand and threw them on the floor.
"Did you know that trick, Guerchard? One of these days I shall
teach you to invite me to lunch," he said slowly, in a mocking tone;
and he gazed at the detective with menacing, dangerous eyes.
"Come, come, we've had enough of this!" cried Guerchard, in mingled
astonishment, anger, and alarm. "Bonavent! Boursin! Dieusy! Here!
Help! Help!" he shouted.
"Now listen, Guerchard, and understand that I'm not humbugging,"
said Lupin quickly, in clear, compelling tones. "If Sonia, just now,
had had one word, one gesture of contempt for me, I'd have given
way—yielded . . . half-yielded, at any rate; for, rather than fall
into your triumphant clutches, I'd have blown my brains out. I've now
to choose between happiness, life with Sonia, or prison. Well, I've
chosen. I will live happy with her, or else, my dear Guerchard, I'll
die with you. Now let your men come—I'm ready for them."
Guerchard ran to the door and shouted again.
"I think the fat's in the fire now," said Lupin, laughing.
He sprang to the table, opened the cardboard box, whipped off the
top layer of cotton-wool, and took out a shining bomb.
He sprang to the wall, pressed the button, the bookshelf glided
slowly to one side, the lift rose to the level of the floor and its
doors flew open just as the detectives rushed in.
"Collar him!" yelled Guerchard.
"Stand back—hands up!" cried Lupin, in a terrible voice, raising
his right hand high above his head. "You know what this is . . . a
bomb. . . . Come and collar me now, you swine! . . . Hands up, you .
. . Guerchard!"
"You silly funks!" roared Guerchard. "Do you think he'd dare?"
"Come and see!" cried Lupin.
"I will!" cried Guerchard. And he took a step forward.
As one man his detectives threw themselves upon him. Three of them
gripped his arms, a fourth gripped him round the waist; and they all
shouted at him together, not to be a madman! . . . To look at Lupin's
eyes! . . . That Lupin was off his head!
"What miserable swine you are!" cried Lupin scornfully. He sprang
forward, caught up the kit-bag in his left hand, and tossed it behind
him into the lift. "You dirty crew!" he cried again. "Oh, why isn't
there a photographer here? And now, Guerchard, you thief, give me back
"Never!" screamed Guerchard, struggling with his men, purple with
"Oh, Lord, master! Do be careful! Don't rile him!" cried Bonavent
in an agony.
"What? Do you want me to smash up the whole lot?" roared Lupin, in
a furious, terrible voice. "Do I look as if I were bluffing, you
"Let him have his way, master!" cried Dieusy.
"Yes, yes!" cried Bonavent.
"Let him have his way!" cried another.
"Give him his pocket-book!" cried a third.
"Never!" howled Guerchard.
"It's in his pocket—his breast-pocket! Be smart!" roared Lupin.
"Come, come, it's got to be given to him," cried Bonavent. "Hold
the master tight!" And he thrust his hand into the breast of
Guerchard's coat, and tore out the pocket-book.
"Throw it on the table!" cried Lupin.
Bonavent threw it on to the table; and it slid along it right to
Lupin. He caught it in his left hand, and slipped it into his pocket.
"Good!" he said. And then he yelled ferociously, "Look out for the
bomb!" and made a feint of throwing it.
The whole group fell back with an odd, unanimous, sighing groan.
Lupin sprang into the lift, and the doors closed over the opening.
There was a great sigh of relief from the frightened detectives, and
then the chunking of machinery as the lift sank.
Their grip on Guerchard loosened. He shook himself free, and
shouted, "After him! You've got to make up for this! Down into the
cellars, some of you! Others go to the secret entrance! Others to the
servants' entrance! Get into the street! Be smart! Dieusy, take the
lift with me!"
The others ran out of the room and down the stairs, but with no
great heartiness, since their minds were still quite full of the
bomb, and Lupin still had it with him. Guerchard and Dieusy dashed at
the doors of the opening of the lift-well, pulling and wrenching at
them. Suddenly there was a click; and they heard the grunting of the
machinery. There was a little bump and a jerk, the doors flew open of
themselves; and there was the lift, empty, ready for them. They jumped
into it; Guerchard's quick eye caught the button, and he pressed it.
The doors banged to, and, to his horror, the lift shot upwards about
eight feet, and stuck between the floors.
As the lift stuck, a second compartment, exactly like the one
Guerchard and Dieusy were in, came up to the level of the floor of
the smoking-room; the doors opened, and there was Lupin. But again
how changed! The clothes of the Duke of Charmerace littered the
floor; the kit-bag was open; and he was wearing the very clothes of
Chief-Inspector Guerchard, his seedy top-hat, his cloak. He wore also
Guerchard's sparse, lank, black hair, his little, bristling, black
moustache. His figure, hidden by the cloak, seemed to have shrunk to
the size of Guerchard's.
He sat before a mirror in the wall of the lift, a make-up box on
the seat beside him. He darkened his eyebrows, and put a line or two
about his eyes. That done he looked at himself earnestly for two or
three minutes; and, as he looked, a truly marvellous transformation
took place: the features of Arsene Lupin, of the Duke of Charmerace,
decomposed, actually decomposed, into the features of Jean Guerchard.
He looked at himself and laughed, the gentle, husky laugh of
He rose, transferred the pocket-book to the coat he was wearing,
picked up the bomb, came out into the smoking-room, and listened. A
muffled roaring thumping came from the well of the lift. It almost
sounded as if, in their exasperation, Guerchard and Dieusy were
engaged in a struggle to the death. Smiling pleasantly, he stole to
the window and looked out. His eyes brightened at the sight of the
motor-car, Guerchard's car, waiting just before the front door and in
charge of a policeman. He stole to the head of the stairs, and looked
down into the hall. Victoire was sitting huddled together on a chair;
Sonia stood beside her, talking to her in a low voice; and, keeping
guard on Victoire, stood a brown-faced, active, nervous policeman, all
alertness, briskness, keenness.
"Hi! officer! come up here! Be smart," cried Lupin over the
bannisters, in the husky, gentle voice of Chief-Inspector Guerchard.
The policeman looked up, recognized the great detective, and came
bounding zealously up the stairs.
Lupin led the way through the anteroom into the sitting-room. Then
he said sharply: "You have your revolver?"
"Yes," said the young policeman. And he drew it with a flourish.
"Put it away! Put it away at once!" said Lupin very smartly.
"You're not to use it. You're not to use it on any account! You
"Yes," said the policeman firmly; and with a slightly bewildered
air he put the revolver away.
"Here! Stand here!" cried Lupin, raising his voice. And he caught
the policeman's arm, and hustled him roughly to the front of the
doors of the lift-well. "Do you see these doors? Do you see them?" he
"Yes, yes," said the policeman, glaring at them.
"They're the doors of a lift," said Lupin. "In that lift are Dieusy
and Lupin. You know Dieusy?"
"Yes, yes," said the policeman.
"There are only Dieusy and Lupin in the lift. They are struggling
together. You can hear them," shouted Lupin in the policeman's ear.
"Lupin is disguised. You understand—Dieusy and a disguised man are
in the lift. The disguised man is Lupin. Directly the lift descends
and the doors open, throw yourself on him! Hold him! Shout for
assistance!" He almost bellowed the last words into the policeman's
"Yes, yes," said the policeman. And he braced himself before the
doors of the lift-well, gazing at them with harried eyes, as if he
expected them to bite him.
"Be brave! Be ready to die in the discharge of your duty!" bellowed
Lupin; and he walked out of the room, shut the door, and turned the
The policeman stood listening to the noise of the struggle in the
lift, himself strung up to fighting point; he was panting. Lupin's
instructions were whirling and dancing in his head.
Lupin went quietly down the stairs. Victoire and Sonia saw him
coming. Victoire rose; and as he came to the bottom of the stairs
Sonia stepped forward and said in an anxious, pleading voice:
"Oh, M. Guerchard, where is he?"
"He's here," said Lupin, in his natural voice.
Sonia sprang to him with outstretched arms.
"It's you! It IS you!" she cried.
"Just look how like him I am!" said Lupin, laughing triumphantly.
"But do I look quite ruffian enough?"
"Oh, NO! You couldn't!" cried Sonia.
"Isn't he a wonder?" said Victoire.
"This time the Duke of Charmerace is dead, for good and all," said
"No; it's Lupin that's dead," said Sonia softly.
"Lupin?" he said, surprised.
"Yes," said Sonia firmly.
"It would be a terrible loss, you know—a loss for France," said
"Never mind," said Sonia.
"Oh, I must be in love with you!" said Lupin, in a wondering tone;
and he put his arm round her and kissed her violently.
"And you won't steal any more?" said Sonia, holding him back with
both hands on his shoulders, looking into his eyes.
"I shouldn't dream of such a thing," said Lupin. "You are here.
Guerchard is in the lift. What more could I possibly desire?" His
voice softened and grew infinitely caressing as he went on: "Yet when
you are at my side I shall always have the soul of a lover and the
soul of a thief. I long to steal your kisses, your thoughts, the whole
of your heart. Ah, Sonia, if you want me to steal nothing else, you
have only to stay by my side."
Their lips met in a long kiss.
Sonia drew herself out of his arms and cried, "But we're wasting
time! We must make haste! We must fly!"
"Fly?" said Lupin sharply. "No, thank you; never again. I did
flying enough last night to last me a lifetime. For the rest of my
life I'm going to crawl—crawl like a snail. But come along, you two,
I must take you to the police-station."
He opened the front door, and they came out on the steps. The
policeman in charge of the car saluted.
Lupin paused and said softly: "Hark! I hear the sound of wedding
They went down the steps.
Even as they were getting into the car some chance blow of
Guerchard or Dieusy struck a hidden spring and released the lift. It
sank to the level of Lupin's smoking-room and stopped. The doors flew
open, Dieusy and Guerchard sprang out of it; and on the instant the
brown- faced, nervous policeman sprang actively on Guerchard and
pinned him. Taken by surprise, Guerchard yelled loudly, "You stupid
idiot!" somehow entangled his legs in those of his captor, and they
rolled on the floor. Dieusy surveyed them for a moment with blank
astonishment. Then, with swift intelligence, grasped the fact that
the policeman was Lupin in disguise. He sprang upon them, tore them
asunder, fell heavily on the policeman, and pinned him to the floor
with a strangling hand on his throat.
Guerchard dashed to the door, tried it, and found it locked, dashed
for the window, threw it open, and thrust out his head. Forty yards
down the street a motor-car was rolling smoothly away—rolling to a
"Oh, hang it!" he screamed. "He's doing a bunk in my motor-car!"